Living players and their claims and why they can or cannot be scum
PMJ - Mrs. Summer Fit - cannot be scum, murder was attempted but failed
scattered mind - Dr. Light - could be scum but can easily prove he isn't
Drac - Tracy - could be scum, but I want to believe.
IE - Sonic - This is probably a safe claim for Eggman. His recent posts are hugely anti-town.
Jabberwock - Benjamin Cloviet - I received a stuffed husky which matches his role and character; he's not scum
TAE - Paula - being able to get the alignments of 1/5 the players screams safe claim.
Now that I'm home I can finally make a proper post, starting with IE's sad attempt at a quickhammer:
What seems to be clear though, from what I received is that as Jabberwock claimed to be Benjamin Cloivet and Reinforce defended him so vigorously, Jabberwock is clearly an indie unless Reinforce didn't target him in time. What's also clear is that I'm going to die tomorrow night (*whelp*). We are at the point where we can't afford any more town casualties, and Jabberwock is clearly not town.
This was from a while ago. There is no evidence that suggests Jabberwock is anything but town. Where's this coming from? Also you didn't die, so LAL?
TAE's claim seems realistic enough and flavour friendly (and the role name is not on the list). Jabber is probably an indie but that, at the moment, doesn't really matter.
TAE's claim absolutely does not seem realistic enough. There is no way that both Celever and tgk allowed Jesi to give someone a three-shot seer in a game with only sixteen people. I refuse to believe it and if TAE is town and we lose because of it then shame on all three of them.
Jabber isn't indie. Where are you getting this from?
PMJ, however, has been leading the town unchallenged
This is one part because my cases are amazing and one part town apathy. Also, up until a couple of days ago my lynches have been wrong, so of course you guys aren't going to try and fight me on it.
Jabber is probably an indie but that, at the moment, doesn't really matter.
This is the second time in one post you have said Jabberwock is indie. He's not. You have no evidence to support this claim because it doesn't exist.
I don't think with this one we'll have time to take the lynch slow, as PMJ will probably mobilise his scum-buddy and get out of this. He's always been good at fabricating safeclaims and that example of when he was asking earlier about names used was probably his way of finding a name not on scattered mind's list.
Here's the quickhammer attempt. Notice how he has a vote weight of two and is trying to convince sm to either shoot me or just VOTE HURRY UP DO IT NOW COME ON HURRY. This isn't IE's first game nor is it his first game as scum; he knows exactly what he's doing. He's just doing it badly.
Also, I couldn't just invent a name to use as a safe claim because Jesi said all roles were in the OP. If I were dumb enough to claim something not in the OP I would be immediately lynched, so there goes that accusation.
@scattered mind , since you are on now as well I think we should put pressure on PMJ with a vote. You could use your vig kill instead if you are convinced, but your claim seems good enough that I'm fine with you not using it.
Here's how we find out if sm is scum:
Make him shoot IE. If he dies, he's town. If he doesn't, he's obviously lying and gets lynched.