The penalty for not following my imped is I lose my vote.
Yeah no Robin. That was terrible play if you were telling the truth.
Finished Mafia XXXVII: Celever's School Grades ~ Game Over!
- Thread starter Celever
- Start date
- Status
Yeah no Robin. That was terrible play if you were telling the truth.
Hm? I don't see many ways around it that could help me last another day, while also lynching a possible scum member.
Right now Robin seems like he is playing a solo game, not a team game, and last time I checked the town is a team trying to find scum.
I already suggested that in the past.
But scum also fit in that category, because 1 more mislynch for town, is 1 day closer to majority for the scum.
##Unvote: Robin Aisaga
I'm still all for the lynch, but Scattered does bring up a good point. We need all the leads we can get.
This might've been already asked, but Robin, if you didn't want PP lynched, then why did you change your ability to make him––or whoever had the other role––look like scum?
I'm still all for the lynch, but Scattered does bring up a good point. We need all the leads we can get.
This might've been already asked, but Robin, if you didn't want PP lynched, then why did you change your ability to make him––or whoever had the other role––look like scum?
I mean, if he is scum, which is very probable, he would have to most likely have no supporters at this point.
I can get that you didn't want to be lynched, but that was really bad play, like Camo said. What made you think that was a better idea than anything else you could've done? What were the other options you considered?
What makes you say that?
Think about it.
Let's pretend we are not in this game at the moment.
If everyone hates some accused criminal, and then you jump in to say that criminal isn't guilty, doesn't it make you just more suspicious?
[I might be wrong though, it won't be the first time I am wrong about something XD]
Making every defence attorney pretty much useless with this situation. I can see where you're coming from, as they may just have to bus their own member sometimes, but I can't see this being the case here. The flavour in Robin's claim is very believable, although it could be the safeclaim, which is doubtful after seeing PP's flip.
I mean his claim seems probable town, his actions don't.
Bad phrasing ^. Rephrase:
Yes, his claim does seem probable to be town, but his actions don't.
Yes, his claim does seem probable to be town, but his actions don't.
PMJ
Silhouette Gloom of the Sundown Lands
Forum Head
Articles Head
Elite Member
Advanced Member
Member
Let's not kid ourselves. Robin needs a policy lynch. Disclaiming that the partner may be scum is just to prevent them from both being automatically clear (which tbh wouldn't be true until one died).
Who is helped by scum? Certainly not town.
*cringes and thinks about XXXV*
I won't be replacing my vote until Robin explains himself further.
I'm not sure what occurrences you guys find hard to comprehend. Team Game? Don't be naive. If you're are a town member, start with being less stubborn. Don't just lynch a player out of policy or because actions don't make sense (in your eyes at least).
@PikaMasterJesi Could you please read my first D2 post again? Not trying to be sassy or anything, but it could answer some of your questions.
@PikaMasterJesi Could you please read my first D2 post again? Not trying to be sassy or anything, but it could answer some of your questions.
@Robin Aisaga What are your reads right now? Who did you use your ability on? Can you respond to all of our posts?
- Status