Fair enough then. :LI was busy in the army
NP's theory that neither Rainy nor TGK is scum? I don't like it much. It rings faintly of him trying to save a scumbuddy, especially since Blakers flipped town.
Finished Mafia XXXVIII: Battle for the Republic (Congratulations Darth Sidious!)
- Thread starter Squirtle Squad
- Start date
- Status
I felt like neither of the two had any good reason to lie at all. Post 353 (made by Vracken) stated an exact ability scum might have to make this situation not work (which I've never seen before, making me think he knows too much). In addition, a lot of "one of them must be scum" comments made me suspicious of it.
Blakers was a pretty good lynch, especially considering his refusal to defend. I didn't "shift the lynch" just because of this one point. It made me more suspicious of the likely lynch, making me want to find a better option
You going on about how you regret not voting is both scummy AtE and makes me wonder why you didn't actually vote for rainy.
##VOTE: scattered mind
SM has been sitting back and not taking part in much major discussion over the last few days. He's been there, since he's popped in to ask small questions, but he stayed mostly away from attaching himself to any wagons. from some "Yeah, that makes sense". This sounds like the classic scum letting town screw over themselves, especially so if rainy is town.
SM has been sitting back and not taking part in much major discussion over the last few days. He's been there, since he's popped in to ask small questions, but he stayed mostly away from attaching himself to any wagons. from some "Yeah, that makes sense". This sounds like the classic scum letting town screw over themselves, especially so if rainy is town.
My points against Rainy yesterday still stand.
For a refresher, Rainy yesterday claimed to be blocked. However, since he was blocked successfully, that should have triggered my Ability to activate. But since it didn't, it's very likely Rainy is anti-town.
For these reasons plus his subpar defence (Freaking out instantly, saying "it's me vs you" and his only barely passable defence is to say "you're lying but since everyone is mafia I'm going to die"), I'd like to lynch Rainy.
##VOTE: Rainyman123
For a refresher, Rainy yesterday claimed to be blocked. However, since he was blocked successfully, that should have triggered my Ability to activate. But since it didn't, it's very likely Rainy is anti-town.
For these reasons plus his subpar defence (Freaking out instantly, saying "it's me vs you" and his only barely passable defence is to say "you're lying but since everyone is mafia I'm going to die
"), I'd like to lynch Rainy.##VOTE: Rainyman123
I voted Rainy D1, and I said today how the TGK/Rainy issue is still relevant. No idea how one can attach himself to a wagon any further than that. I was inactive D1 because IRL issues, so? Inactivity is not an indication for alignment- something that you said many times in other games, iirc.
So?
Am I tunneling, or not attaching myself to a lynch? Because I can't see how one can do both. And if I was tunneling, why would I vote TSM D1?
Anyway, I am not tunneling- My suspect list contains Rainy, Robin and NP. It feels like you have been trying to stick that tunneling thing on me since D1.
I didn't say you were inactive. I said you were sitting back and not taking part in most major discussion. You made small comments on other things instead.
So your lack of contribution Day 2 could have been a result of your v/la, but not the case in Day 1.
You tunneled rainy at that point, but stayed neutral for most of both days. You can tunnel someone in a post like the one I linked, but back off.
Really? This is either the first or second time I've brought it up, so I don't know how I've been trying to stick this tunneling thing on you...
Do realize there is the possibility that Rainy is a Senator. However, I don't Senators would be given safe claims, as they aren't the anti-town faction...
##Vote: rainyman123
I still think this is the best lynch, even with the Senator possibility.
When TSM (A Senator, Jar Jar Binks) was lynched he didn't reveal a safe claim, so I find this unlikely.
He claims he wants to get lynched because he wants to get TGK's secrets out. Personally, I don't know if he's scum or not, but while TGK seems to want him gone, Rainy's not really defending himself anymore, and if he's town, that makes him sort of a weak link you could say (yeah, I know I can't really be talking).
Got any suggestions for players you think are scum?
TSM was lynched Day 1 and flipped town.
Wow. I've been gone that long. This is what overworking myself does to me, it leaves me confused. Sorry about that though.
Then I don't know who.
##VOTE: Robin Aisaga
Constant requests to speculate into the nightkill are scummy and unproductive, you are attacking people hypocritically, and you are posting at a much more infrequent rate than games you've been town in.
P.S. Does anyone who played with @Scorched Feathers years ago know if this is their normal activity level?
Constant requests to speculate into the nightkill are scummy and unproductive, you are attacking people hypocritically, and you are posting at a much more infrequent rate than games you've been town in.
P.S. Does anyone who played with @Scorched Feathers years ago know if this is their normal activity level?
I think that rainy has a high chance of flipping scum because he's been caught in a lie. I'm beginning to think that NP and Jabber are likely scum for producing a weak case to turn the lynch away from their scumbuddy. On a side note, has anyone present been targeted for the night kill? I think I could have been, provided no one comes forward.
- Status