RE: Murder VI - The Quest. Day 6 ends 29th August 8 PM GMT. PM Guy89 to test out Murder VII!
Well, since 42 ruined my theory I speant all night on, I might as well copy and paste it from word:
Nobody is gonna believe me, nor think this idea is smart... but I think I figured out who the murderer is:
Ok, I wasted spent a whole hour reading through every post ever made on Murder VI, and I noticed something: 42 Chocolate
He was really active on the very first day, and then that night we learn a accomplice was chosen... and since that announcement, 42 stopped posting.
He never died and he is really active on the forums, and him and Guy are good friends. I can tell 42 views this thread, and he could have at least bothered to post, to help, to even show he is active.
It seems to me that Guy and 42 have similar playing styles: Sit back, do nothing, just to make sure nobody knows your playing.
And you people really did jump me, I can't prove my innocence. But I can give you people a good CoG clue ;] And the fact that I actually solved something, get no congratulations, only jumped and left with a broken self esteem :| No thanks or nothing like that.
And when I do die, you people better listen to PMJ, you got that. He actually knows what to do. He's one of the best characters playing.
And of course everyone is gonna say "tDL, your an idiot *Ignores tDL's post*" I really think I got lucky finding out Guy was the murderer, but my wall of text did have some logic, and I was getting worried everybody was gonna ignore me so I took it a little to far, and I was really serious on quitting. It's gonna be funny to see your face when you look at Ice's post.
And you people think I'm the new murderer because I somehow knew Guy was the murderer. I put logic behind my post, narrowed down my selection, then figured Guy was the best match. If you people really think Guy set a trap, why are you contributing to it. It's like adding gasoline to a forest fire: Your not helping and your just putting yourself at risk. You can kill me, use me for a CoG clue, and use my theories.
Well since I'm gonna die, I might as well explain how I found out that Guy was the murderer.
When I applied to play this game, I thought of a way to keep track of the clues, and of who I think is the murderer. So I opened word and I created something called 'The Document'. My goal in the game was to try out Murder and see how far I get.
Well, Ice posted the start of Day 1, and I read the Murderer's note.
I was shocked. Everybody was now gonna kill me. So I gave myself a goal in this game, to find out who the Murderer was and nothing else.
I could tell just by looking at the note that it was someone who knew me personally. I created something called 'The List'. The list consisted of every person playing that I knew. My goal was to watch
what these people say and
how they say it.
Well, immediately after Ice posted the note, I was bashed for a short time. I had to get out of this,
quickly... I took back my vote, nice move on my part.
My first main suspect was Boddy and Kaiserchu on the first day. I knew these people the most. Boddy was the main suspect, as there was 39 dots in the note and his Username had 903 in it. If you re-arrange the numbers, you get 039.
After a while, Ice gave us a Antidote clue. I thought this could be a nice.
And there was another tactic I used was: ACT LIKE A COMPLETE MORON.
TheDarkLucario said:
"What would 'M' want with Celebi?"
That's just an example of the stupid stuff I would say. I thought if the murder knew I wasn't helping, he wouldn't kill me. Also people wouldn't claim I was the murderer. Smart huh?
And there was also something Snorchu said, that, now that I look back at it, makes me lol.
Several suspects, but that's to be expected for Day 1. For now, I suggest we lynch one of the following and see where it takes us:
The most suspicious
The best at giving CoG clues
I also think we should keep Guy89 in for as long as possible. After all, the game's creator is twice as likely to be the game's best player.
Does it make you laugh looking at this?
After a while, I noticed the point of helping Celebi: To throw us off track. Everyone spent there time on the clues, while I keep track of the murderer, I was being smart.
More and more clues came in on the first day, and more and more time was wasted.
And then Ice started the first night, called us idiots for suggesting music and the Florida Keys. And then I noticed it, Ice solves it for us. Even though we never solved the Antidote clues, we still advanced for the sake of the game. I felt so stupid for wasting my time on Celebi.
And then Ice started Day 2 and we learn an accomplice was picked. Great -_- I wasn't that worried on the accomplice, although it might help to look at his clues to help me find the murderer.
I choose not to waste my time on some egg and fire clue, and just review 'The Document' and 'The List'. My major hunch was Kaiserchu, as with Boddy dead, he was now my only 'good' friend playing. My other 2 choices were Guy89 and Snorchu, as I knew Guy from Chess, and I thought he was looking for revenge for DQing him.
And then PMJ said something that made me think:
PMJ said:
"No, no, no, no, no!"
Irritated, Dustox tried to get everyone's attention. "You guys need to stop this! Stop trying to figure out the murderer based on the note! You'll never get it. Since the murderer isn't required to implicate himself in them, you have to think that the entire thing is a red herring."
A little calmer now, Dustox floated casually over everyone's heads. "It's all too obvious that Gengar would be accused based on the nature of the note. Don't you see? It's too obvious... We must wait for the first council clue. That way, we can be sure that it can be trusted to lead us in the right direction."
(The rest of this is out of character because I have to drive this point home before I die. You guys seem to be forgetting one very important note: finding the murderer is not going to be that easy. Do you guys really think Multiplicity is going to be THAT STUPID so as to leave such an obvious clue in the note, when it would OBVIOUSLY say "Hey, I'm guilty, kill me please!"
If you can't trust all of it, you can't trust any of it. The murderer could include something in his note that casts vague suspicion on everyone (including himself, just to be safe), and then what would you do? Everyone would accuse everyone else, and we'd never figure out the murderer's identity. The only clue that can be trusted is the one given by the council of ghosts because they know who the murderer is.
Last game, when red blastoise mentioned we had to look at people with few ties to the murder note, I got scared. He's absolutely correct. You'll notice that I killed him the night after he said that, because I knew if I left him alone, he'd point the finger at me soon enough. Leaving Joeypals!! alive at the end was a dangerous move - I thought I could convince him to vote for whoever Gallade was, and I'd have it won. Instead, he used his head and accused me, and that was good game. I should have played it safe and nuked the one person who was ACTUALLY USING HIS HEAD.
The murderer is not going to be so dumb as to leave blatantly obvious clues in his note, and neither is his accomplice. I think you guys are way off base with your suggestions. Look at the murder notes I left in the last game. How many of them could be linked back to me, or Gastrodon? Like, one, and only because I intentionally made it so. Everything else--the colors, the bad grammar, everything--was a red herring. You guys have to assume that the murderer and his buddy are trying to be slick and leave clues that are way too obvious.
You guys did this all last game, too. You dismissed the council clues as being too vague and focused on the notes I left, which is the wrong thing to do. Have I ingrained this in your heads yet? I really hope so, because if I wind up dead tonight and you guys don't use the council clue to identify the murderer, I'm permabanning each and every one of you I'll be very upset =[.)
He was right, this wasn't going to be easy for me, and I had to keep my mouth shut and come up with more leads. I had to be acting stupid when I posted to ensure I can stay alive and get more leads, and I also had to ignore the Antidote clues.
And then Day 2 ended, and of course Ice solved the clue for us, making all that dumb work you people did pointless.
And then Kaiserchu posted in the night and was mod-killed, so he was removed from 'The List', bringing Guy to the top of 'The List'.
And of course the Murderer said something that shed some light on who the accomplice was:
And.my.friend.
Jam. Sandwiches.
And then Guy, the one on the top of 'The List' said one of the most dumbest things that said "I'm the Murderer/Accomplice"
I'm also afraid for shadoworganoid, the murderer said eh would kill the winners, and killed the Murder I winner, and shadoworganoid should be next, as he won Murder II.
The Accomplice never said something on a pattern. Unless, OMG, you know who the accomplice is \o/ But, I looked back at PMJ's post and I kept this info to myself for another day...
And then the accomplice confirms Guy was right on the 'Track'
And thiss timee Ii will followw thee samee exactt trackk
And then the Murderer posted that clue that narrowed my decision down to Guy
The.End.
Is.Near.
Your.All.LOST.
I posted most of my evidence [I chose not to post some of it], and then people were not believing me.
I was freaking out. I spent this whole game trying to find the murderer and now people don't believe me. I thought this whole game was stupid. Everyone was wasting there time on dumb Antidote Clues. I decided to quit, because nobody is playing the game 'good'. I hate people who have no sense. I spent this whole game finding the Murderer, and I finally complete it, and I get bashed.
But thankfully I had some supporters, and thank god they are smart.
And Ice sent me a PM, telling me not to quit, so I didn't.
And then Ice ends the day, and it turns out I was right. Yes, I completed my goal in this game, and then I looked back at the start of the game. Was it all worth it?
And then we get to today, were I get bashed even further. But I don't care. I did something. I didn't waste my time. I was conservative. I won. I get no thank yous, but I don't care. At least I didn't waste my time on Celebi.
And now that you braved through this whole post, I'm gonna quote something I said:
If you people really think Guy set a trap, why are you contributing to it. It's like adding gasoline to a forest fire: Your not helping and your just putting yourself at risk.
So why are you risking yourself?
