So, if anyone remembers this post...
Athena said:
I've actually been debating trying to make fake cards myself. I really like the idea of playing around with blanks (especially some of the cool custom ones I've seen here and on dA and the like) and composing something nice. The biggest problem, really, is that I don't really know what makes an actual card good or interesting (I just appreciate the aesthetics), so I'd either be copying attacks and such or making up bullshit. I guess I could always just make a thread with my Pokémon and ideas and see if text fakers might want to contribute with the text for me to put into a card or something.
... you're not alone! I also remembered it, though I haven't expanded on any of my ideas or anything yet because, until recently, I haven't had have the time. Now that I'm back from vacation and my workload is lessening, I've been looking at this potential project in a new light and starting to do some research and prepare ideas.
Since I am so completely new to this, I would like to ask for some help from the community in getting started. My first decision is
picking a set. This may seem a simple choice, but I have some kind of cool concepts and ideas I'd like to play around with, and I'm not really sure how great I will be at customizing blanks. My main goal is to find an existing blank set that more or less captures most of what I'm looking for and would be easy enough to customize what I need with minimal risk. To this end, I've been looking at some blanks and stuff available on dA and elsewhere and evaluating my choices.
I would definitely love to hear opinions and feedback from image fakers, who would definitely be more knowledgeable about this than me, to help me start off on the right foot.
What I'm looking for: All current TCG types (including Dragon and Fairy), trainers, etc (yes, I do plan on including trainers). I also have designs on a secondary type/mechanic (think: dark/light Pokémon, dual-types, etc.), so it would be nice to have a blank that has some kind of secondary option like that that I can play with to fit what I'd like to include. FA support would be cool just so I could play around with that, but not a dealbreaker.
Another note is that, because I do plan on very probably making some edits/changes, I would also like to use a set made by someone(s) that do not object to edits being made. Of course I would give credit where credit is due, but I'm not sure how acceptable it is to different fakers about other people modifying their works. Specifically, I will very likely be editing borders no matter WHAT set I use because I strongly dislike the bright yellow border on English cards and would prefer to make something less obnoxious. However, it seems like a lot of people who make blanks put their trademark stuff on the border, so I'm not sure how best to handle that. Advice, please.
It seems like XY would be the default "easiest" option for what I'm looking for. It has all the types, trainers, etc., plus FAs, and offers a lot of support since the set is relatively new. The biggest downside is the lack of an alternate mechanic of sorts (there's megas, but that sort of design doesn't really fit much with what I had in mind), and the fact that I don't really care for XY's holo style, so I would likely have to make up my own holosheets (including borders) or find something different that could work as well.
Older sets appeal to me too, though there doesn't seem to be as much available for them. EX-era holds a lot of theoretical promise (it's basically my favourite era, too), but few blanks (though I'm really rather drawn to the Rocket ones). The Pokémon TCG Resources Wiki has some pretty cool Gym-era blanks, complete with what I'm assuming are meant to be FA blanks (marked as SR), which is tempting to play around with, too, even though owner's Pokémon isn't quite what I'm looking for in an alternate design framework. Of course, I'd have to make dragon and fairy blanks for all of these.
I'm not adverse to trying out custom sets, too. So many of them look really cool! There's just a lot to sift through in that respect, and I would really not want to make any significant changes to someone's custom work, so it would have to be something that fits my needs very well, and I wouldn't know where to start.
Alternatively, perhaps with so much weird shit that I want, I would be better off making my own custom blanks... though I'd have no idea where to start, so any kind of help or advice on that front would be much obliged.
Alternatively, alternatively, maybe I've jumped too far into the deep end of the faking pool with the things I have in mind and I should really be wading in on the opposite side over by the kiddy end. I could (temporarily, anyway) drop my designs about mechanics and alterations and just get a feel for the basic first with something more simple.
Anyway... HALP.
If it makes a difference, said cards would be made in photoshop. My own design experience is minimal, though I've made banners and icons and such for websites (mostly for the sadly now-defunct Fire Emblem Universe), and avatars and wallpapers for personal use, as well as digitally cleaning and colouring sketches of my own. I'm purely an amateur, having never taken any design courses or even read a photoshop book; the stuff I do is stuff I either figured out myself while playing around with the software, or from tips and tricks suggested to me by others.
tl;dr: Suggest Athena a blank set to use to make image-based cards.