BW/BW2 Pokemon Black & White Reviews

Card Slinger J said:
there is no way to tell what IV's your Pokemon have therefore unless you action replay

Fixed. :p

Seriously, I checked. And it applies to previous games too.

Plus if you care enough about IVs to want to bother investing truckloads of time into them, I think you're better off just using the action replay to get the IVs you need.

Based on my salamence breeding in Emerald, I can testify that even if you get a pokemon whose IVs are praised by the IVs guy, you won't get a sense of satisfaction, you'd be wondering if it was good enough or if one of the other 5 stats that you also wanted happened to be inferior. Eventually it just gets frustrating.
 
The way I look at it is in terms of utility (how much enjoyment you get per unit time you invest in it), because breeding for IVs is a serious timesink, which I know first hand from my Salamence breeding which did not utilise any cheating mechanisms. Time and effort is something that once invested, cannot be regained, and there's limits on how much I'm willing to invest because I'm not 14 years old anymore with tons of free time to grind (and I use the term loosely to refer to having to do anything repeatedly for extended periods of time, in the attempts of achieving a certain result). I'm not strictly saying I hate grinding per se, it's just that if I do it frequently enough, I will grow to hate it.

Besides, there is no such thing in pokemon as a bragging right for having taken weeks or months of breeding to raise a pedigree. When I told my friend about my salamence, he thought I was nuts. He was the one who supplied me the initial seed pokemon for IV inheritance breeding, because he managed to luck out and get a bagon with good IVs, but he didn't spend a month fussing over the IVs breeding over and over again to try and hit that ideal spot. Looking back, I wish I followed his approach. I had invested a month of time and effort, and the return on investment was pathetic. I never used the Salamence anywhere other than the Battle Tower and Battle Dome in Emerald.

When I did my repeated playthroughs of Mass Effect 2, I also hacked the saves to save myself the tedium of having to mine for minerals in all the planets over and over again. Why? Because I'd already done it the first time round, and Mass Effect 2's gameplay focus is on a lot of things more crucial than having to do that planet scanning minigame for hours (which I did the first time round). The Salamence taught me a valuable lesson: that enjoying a game is way more important than trying to invest time and effort to excel in some obscure element of the gameplay. Of course it would have been ok if I had actually enjoyed those countless hours of breeding, but upon some soul searching, I realised I did not enjoy it.
 
IMo EVs are key, IVs are useless. Yeah, i breed my pokemon with good IVs but only when i plan to trade em away or by accident. As a breeder, only good EVs and awesome egg moves are important.
Closer to the topic, BW should of made it so you could count steps, check on pokemon ondaycare etc. and also maybe get a call when a pokemon wants to learn a new move.
 
@Frostwind
You kidding me, IVs are crucial (at least in competitive play) 31 extra points in a stat can make or break a game.

Also the key to breeding is to have a pokemon (specifically Ditto) with 31 in your desired stats, then breed, weed out the weaker Pokes and repeat until your satisfied. If you need a way to find IVs I recommend Serebii's IV calculator and plugging in stats at about level 10 it'll help.
 
^ hmm. Just meant for the subway. Competive play wise, im all for IVs. I have a perfect IV ditto and i only breed with it. Im just saying IVs arent really really really important outside of competitions.
 
Back
Top