The Challenge: Season 5 | Rev3rsor is the Winner!

Status
Not open for further replies.
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

Celever said:
I think this'll work...
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1O1SaMd5z2oUlcfslgEAI1Bo_JAQ7QviU-9DekMOJyF4

If you want my criricism, Athena, which you probably don't, you forgot pluralize "kimonos" at one stage.
"Women walked along the streets wearing sandals and beautifully coloured kimono."

Other than that, the grammar is perfect, and the plot was pretty imaginative, too. Even if you did base it on a book... Whatever. My one nit pick would be there was little development of characters, which if you do read our team's... Novel... You will realize I quite enjoy! :p

In Japanese, words don't get separate plurals, so "kimono" would be the proper plural of a single kimono. Considering this region was supposed to be very Japanese, I used the Japanese plural, which is also sometimes used in English. "The standard plural of the word kimono in English is kimonos,[3] but the unmarked Japanese plural kimono is also sometimes used."

As far as basing it on a book goes... eh. The only thing I took was the reason of how the Axis won WWII; even the conflict I briefly described between the Nazis and Imperial Japan was extrapolated and not actually based on events in the book since the book takes place in the late-60s and this story took place modern day. I wasn't about to spend a few days researching WWII to come up with my own theory, or read other alternate WWII histories and make a medley. I draw a line at how much time I'll commit to something for a game like this. :p

One of the ideas that was tossed around was basically a larger version of this where Dialga travels through time solving different problems; it probably would have had a lot more characterization (and plot, for that matter), but I like I said in our PM discussions, such an idea would have taken 10k-15k words to do properly, and no way in hell was I going to spend that much time and effort. For a story about 1k words (I ended up going over into about 1.5k, but not bad), it's not realistic to expect any real character development or anything simply because the story isn't long enough.
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

Oh right. That would be why you say "Girafarig" instead of "Girafarigs", right? Japanese words don't get plurals. I have never made that connection before... Who needs school? I learn how to English on a Pokémon forum :p

To be honest, basing it on a tried-and-true idea about Axis winning WWII was probably better than writing about the dream I had the night before (yeah, I was literally dreaming about this game). I posted the plot line in as much detail as I could remember in the QT and the responses were basically "I love it!" Drohn pointed out an error which added more of a focus on Palkia, because if you read it's just about Xatu and the Mankey brothers for the first half really, but for the second half it's much more about Palkia than the second batch of characters, in Graham, Gillian, Scizor and Jack. So thank you for that, Drohn! Still, the plot line as a whole could do with some refining, so you basing it on an already successful plot line was certainly a good idea as far as I'm concerned.

Stories in this challenge taking about 10k words... I know the feeling.... I wish I had as much common sense as you, Athena...
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

Attent. Platinums:
Please just vote for an inactive. I think my team should have voted someone out already... we have a target planned, and I'm pretty sure all of you know who it is from some comments made by me earlier, but still...
We all want the next round ASAP, so please be nice and quick! :(
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

Agreed. I don't want to be waiting around while you guys waffle about who gets the ax. >_>
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

Well, the people that live at the right of the Greenwich Meridian want it, but we, that live at it's left are sleeping now (I should be but who cares).


And... we're still deciding because we don't want to kick Devin, he's new, it's not his fault. So we're deciding who.
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

I don't think anyone thinks you should decide NOW (especially those who have been asleep the whole time), I just hope this doesn't take the full 36 hours, because that seems kind of silly.
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

Athena said:
I don't think anyone thinks you should decide NOW (especially those who have been asleep the whole time), I just hope this doesn't take the full 36 hours, because that seems kind of silly.

Be sure we won't. The most may be the next 18 hours.
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

Don't listen to Celever, Platinums. I really liked your story (much more then I liked Celever's, which I did read).
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

Oh wait I just realized something. I thought that MTC was on my team and that our Pokémon was Giratina for a second and I got seriously confused. I actually read it and it was pretty darn great. I kinda wish the Pokémon were named, but whatever. Sorry for any disrespect... :/
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

do the Pokemon HAVE to be named

it doesn't detract anything away from the story
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

Eron said:
And... we're still deciding because we don't want to kick Devin, he's new, it's not his fault. So we're deciding who.

The mercy is greatly appreciated ;-;!! Although if you can't think any reason to boot anyone else, obviously pick me.
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

Celever said:
Oh wait I just realized something. I thought that MTC was on my team and that our Pokémon was Giratina for a second and I got seriously confused. I actually read it and it was pretty darn great. I kinda wish the Pokémon were named, but whatever. Sorry for any disrespect... :/

So basically, you thought we wrote about the wrong Pokemon? lol.

Just submitted my vote.
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

/me sits and watches as people make their choice

wNrSqWE.gif
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

I have already submitted my vote. A lot of hours ago.
 
RE: The Challenge: Season 5

Then you need to get onto the gif posting train, man! Enjoy the ride~

Ie6kfwM.gif
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top