Finished The Resistance Game 1 - Spies Win

Status
Not open for further replies.
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3

Keeper of Night said:
The faulty logic behind that being we could both have sent succeed assuming the other would vote fail.
Click to expand...

When I play in real life and I'm a spy in a mission with another times I will, a majority of the time, succeed the mission. It's not uncommon for spies to send in to succeed the mission like that. They'd rather have the small chance that the mission succeeds than both of them be revealed.

Kecleon - You're hung up on yourself and dismissing that you might be scummy. I more or less always act upon intuition. Your question was who I thought were the the spies and I more than answered your question by elaborating (even though it may admittedly be small) by including you as undecided and the others as resistance.
 
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3

TheGuy said:
Keeper of Night said:
The faulty logic behind that being we could both have sent succeed assuming the other would vote fail.
Click to expand...

When I play in real life and I'm a spy in a mission with another times I will, a majority of the time, succeed the mission. It's not uncommon for spies to send in to succeed the mission like that. They'd rather have the small chance that the mission succeeds than both of them be revealed.

Agreed. This is not an uncommon thing to have happen.

Kecleon - You're hung up on yourself and dismissing that you might be scummy. I more or less always act upon intuition. Your question was who I thought were the the spies and I more than answered your question by elaborating (even though it may admittedly be small) by including you as undecided and the others as resistance.

All right. I'll bite on that logic. But you are wrong about one thing, though: I never asked you who you thought the spies were. I actually asked you this:
Kecleon-X said:
TheGuy, why do you think that I'm a spy, and why do you so desperately want to be on a mission that could afford to not have a town on it, seeing as there is only five people going?
Click to expand...

Could you answer these questions in particular, please?
Click to expand...
 
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3

I'm sorry - I mixed up your post with MTC's.

First of all I don't think you're a spy but I believe its probable just based on your posts. I'm sorry that you're not going to get a better answer and you really should have one.

In regards to why I voted no. Yes, we can afford not to have one town on the mission but I feel more safe knowing that I'm on the mission. At some point someone is going to have to fold to not having themselves on the mission but personally I don't want to do it.
 
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3

Just a reminder that this game is still going, and that Kecleon needs to submit a move. I realize you're trying to talk to people, but this is taking a long time and I'd like this game to continue moving. This goes for everyone Kecleon is trying to question as well.
 
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3

Okay, guys -- I've gathered a bit of reads on the likes of you guys, and I've deduced that TheGuy is rather scummy from what I can tell. I've posted enough to give anyone a solid read one way or another, and the fact that he says "I dunno" makes me think he's just trying to cast some doubt on me by saying that I'm scum with no logic other than a gut feeling. Secondly, I haven't a clue on where it was that MTC asked him to send in his scumreads, so it's rather odd that he stated that he got my several posts mixed up with a post that I can't even find. I will exclude him from this mission on this basis, and I will go ahead and place my picks for this mission so far:

Yours truly (Kecleon-X), Porygon-X, Drohn (was on PMJ's first mission, which, if PMJ was a Spy, it would be ludicrous to put a fellow spy on the first mission), WanderingWolf (I truly think he was joking -- it's even something I would say, and actually do say sometimes when I meet with friends to play), and then someone else whom I am unsure of.

But there are three people I want to know their opinions on the recent happenings and their personal opinions on their own innocence before I finish this mission statement:

Keeper of Night, rev3rsor, GM Draclord

All three of you, please state why you are town and your current scumreads. I do not want this last mission to fail due to some erroneous judgement in character on my part, so this is rather crucial.
 
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3

All three of you, please state why you are town and your current scumreads. I do not want this last mission to fail due to some erroneous judgement in character on my part, so this is rather crucial.
Click to expand...
I've already been over this point several times. There is absolutely no way of knowing who to trust, or who to listen to.

I stand by what I said before, we're all just listening to each other's opinions. It is impossible for us to win with no facts to go off of. For all we know, you could be bad, and there is nothing you can say that can confirm or deny that belief.

I am town. You can all choose to believe me or not, but this game is going on forever heading nowhere fast.
 
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3

I think with WW and Porygon on the mission, there's too high of a chance for there to be a spy on this mission. I do think Kecleon is probably Resistance. He's going through a lot of trouble to try and find the best team, even if I don't agree with his opinions.

Also, I'm making a 2 week limit for you to pick this endeavor (or whatever it is) and another week to vote success or fail, and a 1 week limit for future endeavors. After the time limit is reached, it will move onto the next player. Players don't have much of an incentive to keep things going if there's no time limit, and this could take forever if one isn't implemented. Celever, if you don't think this is a good idea, or would like the time limits should be longer or shorter, let me know, but for now I want this game to move faster.

EDIT: This endeavor started on June 4th, so it will end on the 18th.
 
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3

Sorry, I haven't thought too much about this since I've been distracted by other things happening, but I'll give my opinion on stuff now.
I still find it a bit suspicious that WW would've just posted that he was failing the mission, but I doubt a spy would do something as obvious as 'oh i'm a spy i'm gonna fail it'.
As I've said before this is my first time playing this game so I don't really know any strategy, and more specifically, how to spot if anyone else is a spy or not. My only real defense is to say that I'm like werewolf's newbie town, because quite frankly I am. There's nothing else, really, that I can say.
 
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3

I been quite lost since i end of may due to my studies and final exam.. Frankly i still am a bit lost

Theres no way that i can prove im a town other then i know i'm not a resistance.. Since i never been in any mission theres no way to test my impact on missin failuer based on if im in a particular mission

My scumread is nada since like i said. Im quite lost
 
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3

You mean you're not a spy? Resistance are the good guys...
 
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3

rev3rsor said:
You mean you're not a spy? Resistance are the good guys...
Click to expand...


Now i'm confused.. it been a while since i read (focusly) the thread to be honest. hell i even forget the names and my previous observation. Thats what you get when you involved in a game that were moving slow.. you kinda loose focus
 
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3

Kecleon-X has 24 hours to submit a team for this endeavour. Should he fail to do so this round will skip to the next player. Kecleon-X has been PM'd to alert him of this

Thank You
 
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3

Porygon-X, Yours Truly (Kecleon-X), Drohn, WanderingWolf and rev3rsor

This mission, should you choose to accept it, should work. But if not, my bad.

This post will self-destruct in ten seconds.

(Mission: Impossible joke)
 
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3

NO
(Just making sure Celever doesn't miss it.) :D :p <3​

I'm still sure Porygon-X is a spy. So this is a no-go. I also don't trust rev3rsor or WanderingWolf.
 
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3

Yeah, no.
Not only is Porygon on this, but I don't trust you or Rev either.
At the very least, we should know Porygon failed the second mission.
 
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3

Apart from the fact that you guys don't trust me, I'm still suspicious of Porygon-X and WW. So no.
 
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 4

No (Remember to color your votes.)

Almost all of my main suspects are on this mission, so I can't imagine this getting approved.

Also the title still says round 3. I'll change now it because I'm impatient. lol
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top