RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3
Do we have limit on how many mission we could skip?
WanderingWolf said:
Do we have limit on how many mission we could skip?
Finished The Resistance Game 1 - Spies Win
- Thread starter Celever
- Start date
- Status
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3
At least I'm actually trying to put some pressure on people for the sake of a doomed resistance.
DracLord, no we do not. If the tenth leader was to be cancelled, then it would rerun back to PMJ.
At least I'm actually trying to put some pressure on people for the sake of a doomed resistance.
DracLord, no we do not. If the tenth leader was to be cancelled, then it would rerun back to PMJ.
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3
I'm saying no, mainly because GM Draclord says yes. I'm almost sure GM Draclord is a spy and the fact he agrees to it makes me think there's a spy on board. I trust WanderingWolf, PMJ, and TheGuy (maybe; his spy claims confuse me). I don't know about Kecleon-X and rev3rsor. I trust Keeper of Night too, so he needs to be on the mission with 6 people (we need ALL non-spies to be on board for the mission with 6 to succeed). I don't trust Porygon-X. I expect he's responsible for failing the second mission.
I'm saying no, mainly because GM Draclord says yes. I'm almost sure GM Draclord is a spy and the fact he agrees to it makes me think there's a spy on board. I trust WanderingWolf, PMJ, and TheGuy (maybe; his spy claims confuse me). I don't know about Kecleon-X and rev3rsor. I trust Keeper of Night too, so he needs to be on the mission with 6 people (we need ALL non-spies to be on board for the mission with 6 to succeed). I don't trust Porygon-X. I expect he's responsible for failing the second mission.
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3
I feel that Kecleon and Rev3rsor are both too inactive to actually fail the mission, even if they were spies. Hence why I chose them. I don't trust Keeper, hence why I didn't choose him. And Porygon is an obvious choice to be outside the group.
I feel that Kecleon and Rev3rsor are both too inactive to actually fail the mission, even if they were spies. Hence why I chose them. I don't trust Keeper, hence why I didn't choose him. And Porygon is an obvious choice to be outside the group.
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3
Why do you think im a spy... I said no the the last mission because i think the spy is in there.. Mainly i say yes is we can just say no all the time since the team would still be 6...
Drohn said:
Why do you think im a spy... I said no the the last mission because i think the spy is in there.. Mainly i say yes is we can just say no all the time since the team would still be 6...
PMJ
Silhouette Gloom of the Sundown Lands
Forum Head
Articles Head
Elite Member
Advanced Member
Member
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3
The spies can't work together (read as: talk to each other privately), so they're on their own to fail the mission and score their team a point. It's first to three, remember, and the resistance already has a point. Sacking the first mission gains trust. Sacking the second mission does the team no favors.
What I'm saying is that I believe only one spy was on the 4-man mission, instead of multiple spies voting differently.
I think the four spies are Keeper of Night, GM DracLord, rev3rsor, and Machamp the Champion. Here's why:
Keeper suggested a six-man party of him, Drohn, Kecleon, WW, Machamp, and TheGuy. Of course he votes yes because it's his party. He's not gonna vote no. That's not really scummy. It's how everyone else votes that makes me think Keeper is scum.
Keeper noticed that there was a suspicious lack of yes votes, which you would think meant all six resistance members were on it. I almost believed him, except when I was trying to find out who the four people he left out was, I couldn't think of the fourth. Naturally it was because I'd forgotten to count myself.
Bear with me. Keeper already mentioned he thought Porygon failed the four-man mission we all went on, which means that he thought me and Drohn were town (pardon the lingo but you get it). So why didn't Keeper put me into his party? If you're putting together a party of six people, wouldn't you want to populate it with the people you think are town? I chose myself because I'm town and I wanted to maximally influence the mission's chances of success. If Keeper thought I was town he had no reason to not choose me for his mission.
I think if rev3rsor had voted, he would have voted yes to Keeper's party.
I think Machamp is scum because I think Keeper is scum. Machamp has stressed how Keeper seems more trustworthy than anyone else, which makes no sense at all, especially considering Machamp has not posted any reason why he thinks Keeper is town. His refusal of Keeper's setup makes zero sense because the only difference Machamp's suggested team differed from Keeper's actual team was that I wasn't on it (Kecleon and WW were two players who hadn't gone on a mission yet) and TheGuy was. But he didn't mention anything about TheGuy in his post, just that Porygon was scum. Okay, thanks for mentioning something no one was talking about.
When WW suggested his team, Machamp still said no because he stressed having Keeper on it. The reason for this, I just figured out, is because he's trying to push that Porygon is scum because he was the "new guy" on the mission that failed. He's being cast as a scapegoat and the resistance is eating it up.
GM DracLord is either scum or the worst player ever. He rejected the party because odds are there's a spy on it. Well no duh there's probably a spy on it. The odds of us guessing right (all six resistance members in the party)? Ain't pretty. So yeah, it's a safe play. Or is it? I think you'd actually want to vote yes -because- there's probably a spy on it, and there's nothing you can do about it, which brings me to WW's nomination. Right out of the gate, Drac votes yes, with the dumbest reasoning ever (can't afford to skip another round [btw: untrue, we literally have all the time in the world to decide on a party], and no new info). Well, if there has been no new info, then why did you vote yes to this party????
Oh, that's right, because it's got your scumpal rev3rsor on it. Also, he said yes to a mission that I was nominated for despite posting that if the last mission that I was on failed (which it did), he would no longer trust me.
I think rev3rsor is scum because I'm not. Drac voted no to Keeper's setup but yes to WW's. The players that neither setup has in common: Machamp and Kecleon (Keeper's), and me and rev3rsor (WW's). Remember, last round he went with the safe option, but note how he changed his tune after Keeper mentioned how the spies should be working together. Thanks for outing your scumpartner.
So those are my ideas. At this point I don't care if I'm wrong because this theory is dope. Also I reject WW's nomination.
The spies can't work together (read as: talk to each other privately), so they're on their own to fail the mission and score their team a point. It's first to three, remember, and the resistance already has a point. Sacking the first mission gains trust. Sacking the second mission does the team no favors.
What I'm saying is that I believe only one spy was on the 4-man mission, instead of multiple spies voting differently.
I think the four spies are Keeper of Night, GM DracLord, rev3rsor, and Machamp the Champion. Here's why:
Keeper suggested a six-man party of him, Drohn, Kecleon, WW, Machamp, and TheGuy. Of course he votes yes because it's his party. He's not gonna vote no. That's not really scummy. It's how everyone else votes that makes me think Keeper is scum.
Keeper noticed that there was a suspicious lack of yes votes, which you would think meant all six resistance members were on it. I almost believed him, except when I was trying to find out who the four people he left out was, I couldn't think of the fourth. Naturally it was because I'd forgotten to count myself.
Bear with me. Keeper already mentioned he thought Porygon failed the four-man mission we all went on, which means that he thought me and Drohn were town (pardon the lingo but you get it). So why didn't Keeper put me into his party? If you're putting together a party of six people, wouldn't you want to populate it with the people you think are town? I chose myself because I'm town and I wanted to maximally influence the mission's chances of success. If Keeper thought I was town he had no reason to not choose me for his mission.
I think if rev3rsor had voted, he would have voted yes to Keeper's party.
I think Machamp is scum because I think Keeper is scum. Machamp has stressed how Keeper seems more trustworthy than anyone else, which makes no sense at all, especially considering Machamp has not posted any reason why he thinks Keeper is town. His refusal of Keeper's setup makes zero sense because the only difference Machamp's suggested team differed from Keeper's actual team was that I wasn't on it (Kecleon and WW were two players who hadn't gone on a mission yet) and TheGuy was. But he didn't mention anything about TheGuy in his post, just that Porygon was scum. Okay, thanks for mentioning something no one was talking about.
When WW suggested his team, Machamp still said no because he stressed having Keeper on it. The reason for this, I just figured out, is because he's trying to push that Porygon is scum because he was the "new guy" on the mission that failed. He's being cast as a scapegoat and the resistance is eating it up.
GM DracLord is either scum or the worst player ever. He rejected the party because odds are there's a spy on it. Well no duh there's probably a spy on it. The odds of us guessing right (all six resistance members in the party)? Ain't pretty. So yeah, it's a safe play. Or is it? I think you'd actually want to vote yes -because- there's probably a spy on it, and there's nothing you can do about it, which brings me to WW's nomination. Right out of the gate, Drac votes yes, with the dumbest reasoning ever (can't afford to skip another round [btw: untrue, we literally have all the time in the world to decide on a party], and no new info). Well, if there has been no new info, then why did you vote yes to this party????
Oh, that's right, because it's got your scumpal rev3rsor on it. Also, he said yes to a mission that I was nominated for despite posting that if the last mission that I was on failed (which it did), he would no longer trust me.
I think rev3rsor is scum because I'm not. Drac voted no to Keeper's setup but yes to WW's. The players that neither setup has in common: Machamp and Kecleon (Keeper's), and me and rev3rsor (WW's). Remember, last round he went with the safe option, but note how he changed his tune after Keeper mentioned how the spies should be working together. Thanks for outing your scumpartner.
So those are my ideas. At this point I don't care if I'm wrong because this theory is dope. Also I reject WW's nomination.
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3
Both of my earlier reasoning was based on the fact that i though we could not skip a certain no of mission like one of the game i watched online.. If that wasn't the case my reasoning and answer would probably be different. Basicly i choose the answer more on a sequence of yes then no rather then seeing the team as a whole. Since i have no idea
Both of my earlier reasoning was based on the fact that i though we could not skip a certain no of mission like one of the game i watched online.. If that wasn't the case my reasoning and answer would probably be different. Basicly i choose the answer more on a sequence of yes then no rather then seeing the team as a whole. Since i have no idea
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3
I KNEW IT!
PMJ said:
I KNEW IT!
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3
I trust Keeper as much as I trust you and Drohn, because I think he/you/Drohn would've failed the first mission if he was a spy. I already said my reason was that I think Porygon put you 3 back on the mission because you're all Resistance, and there's no risk of 2 spies putting in a fail. If it turns out Porygon isn't a spy, Keeper is probably the spy out of you 4, but I'm pretty sure it's Porygon. Why are you pointing out that I didn't talk about TheGuy when I also didn't talk about WW and Kecleon? All 3 of them have never been on a mission before, so we basically had no info on them at that point.
Reads on all players:
Me- I seered him, and say he was Resistance, so he's clear.
PMJ- Very resistance. For reasons I've already said.
Drohn- Very resistance. For reasons I've already said.
Keeper of Night- Resistance. For reasons I've already said, but I see PMJ's point about him wanting the original 3 plus Porygon is a pretty solid one. Wouldn't be too surprised if he was a spy.
TheGuy- Slight resistance. The way he responded to WW being suspicious of him was fairly resistance like, and nothing about him has struck me as spy... yet.
Kecleon-X- Neutral. He's been really inactive, which could be a spy tactic, but he's not the most active player in any game, so it may mean nothing.
GM Draclord- Neutral. PMJ does have a point about him, but Drac often doesn't pay all that match attention, so I really have no idea what he is.
rev3rsor- Neutral. I can't even find where he changed his attitude, or where he said he didn't trust PMJ. He's been really inactive, so I can't really get a good lead on him.
WanderingWolf- Slight spy. He's been distrusting people based off of not much evidence, and that's about it. I wouldn't really be surprised if he was resistance, but for now I'm gonna go with spy.
Porygon-X- Spy. For reasons I've already said.
PMJ said:
I trust Keeper as much as I trust you and Drohn, because I think he/you/Drohn would've failed the first mission if he was a spy. I already said my reason was that I think Porygon put you 3 back on the mission because you're all Resistance, and there's no risk of 2 spies putting in a fail. If it turns out Porygon isn't a spy, Keeper is probably the spy out of you 4, but I'm pretty sure it's Porygon. Why are you pointing out that I didn't talk about TheGuy when I also didn't talk about WW and Kecleon? All 3 of them have never been on a mission before, so we basically had no info on them at that point.
Reads on all players:
Me- I seered him, and say he was Resistance, so he's clear.
PMJ- Very resistance. For reasons I've already said.
Drohn- Very resistance. For reasons I've already said.
Keeper of Night- Resistance. For reasons I've already said, but I see PMJ's point about him wanting the original 3 plus Porygon is a pretty solid one. Wouldn't be too surprised if he was a spy.
TheGuy- Slight resistance. The way he responded to WW being suspicious of him was fairly resistance like, and nothing about him has struck me as spy... yet.
Kecleon-X- Neutral. He's been really inactive, which could be a spy tactic, but he's not the most active player in any game, so it may mean nothing.
GM Draclord- Neutral. PMJ does have a point about him, but Drac often doesn't pay all that match attention, so I really have no idea what he is.
rev3rsor- Neutral. I can't even find where he changed his attitude, or where he said he didn't trust PMJ. He's been really inactive, so I can't really get a good lead on him.
WanderingWolf- Slight spy. He's been distrusting people based off of not much evidence, and that's about it. I wouldn't really be surprised if he was resistance, but for now I'm gonna go with spy.
Porygon-X- Spy. For reasons I've already said.
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3
Admittedly yes I have been inactive, because I've never played before and I don't really know what to say.
@WW somewhere above, even if I don't post in the thread I try to keep up with all important activity stuff, if I was on the team (whether I was spy or not).
Looking at everyone else on this team, this seems like a fairly good team. I realise there isn't anything I can say to show that I'm resistance but based on everyone else I'm going to vote yes.
Admittedly yes I have been inactive, because I've never played before and I don't really know what to say.
@WW somewhere above, even if I don't post in the thread I try to keep up with all important activity stuff, if I was on the team (whether I was spy or not).
Looking at everyone else on this team, this seems like a fairly good team. I realise there isn't anything I can say to show that I'm resistance but based on everyone else I'm going to vote yes.
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3
Ha.
I'll also vote no to the mission. I don't trust WW and Rev has been awfully quiet.
WanderingWolf said:
Ha.
I'll also vote no to the mission. I don't trust WW and Rev has been awfully quiet.
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3
If you were not a spy I think you would be a bit more skeptical to let this team go. If one of the 6 people is a spy it's a loss already. Right now I think rev3rsor, GM Draclord, and Porygon-X are spies. I don't know about the 4th.. All non-spies please vote "no"; I'm almost certain there is at least one spy on board here.
rev3rsor said:
If you were not a spy I think you would be a bit more skeptical to let this team go. If one of the 6 people is a spy it's a loss already. Right now I think rev3rsor, GM Draclord, and Porygon-X are spies. I don't know about the 4th.. All non-spies please vote "no"; I'm almost certain there is at least one spy on board here.
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3
Am I allowed to change my vote? If possible, I'd like to vote no as well. Simply because Keeper votes no.
Am I allowed to change my vote? If possible, I'd like to vote no as well. Simply because Keeper votes no.
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3
I had already said that I thought it was either Porygon or you. Of course you'd expect to be put on future missions if the first one you were on was a success. I know it wasn't me and I doubt it was Drohn.
- Status