Finished Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Nerds Win

Status
Not open for further replies.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

superpokemon67 said:
What hatman said. I don't really see any evidence that ISB is a jock/nerd. If you could post some qoutes, that would be nice, because I have no idea why ISB could be considered a nerd/jock. Did I miss something? I agree with Dark Void too. I'm not really following this lynch.
Click to expand...

I can't remember (or find) the post I was thinking of, but ISB sounded like he knew the role of a specific person, and...

...you know what

Unvote: ISB

that was dumb of me

I would vote TDL for the lynch, but at the same time I am not fully convinced of the suspicion about him.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

I dunno DNA... the way that ISB reacted to being accused honestly didn't seem all that... innocent or credible to me.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

ISB said:
Gee thanks DNA >:[

Just letting you know, you're wasting your time trying to lynch me. Unless you really want to kill a neutral :/
Click to expand...

I honeslty don't like anything about this post.

But it's still a stretch to acuse because of one post.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

Meaty said:
I dunno DNA... the way that ISB reacted to being accused honestly didn't seem all that... innocent or credible to me.
Click to expand...
I know, but that still doesn't equate to a reason for killing him.
If the pressure is on, I will revote.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

Unvote: ISB

You know, I actually feel like for once we should try our luck with the random lynch....
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

Given how people are feeling right now since there are no leads whatsoever, we may not have a choice.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

I don't get the reason to lynch TDL, could someone explain?
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

As you're well aware, TDL has to sing song lyrics as part of his role. However with the lynching of Storm Blade, a neutral who could become a jock defector, we think that since TDL is reciting song lyrics, his role might be something along the lines of "band teacher" and theoretically a neutral who could become a nerd defector.

It's an okay theory, but I don't see much going for it.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

DNA said:
As you're well aware, TDL has to sing song lyrics as part of his role. However with the lynching of Storm Blade, a neutral who could become a jock defector, we think that since TDL is reciting song lyrics, his role might be something along the lines of "band teacher" and theoretically a neutral who could become a nerd defector.

It's an okay theory, but I don't see much going for it.
Click to expand...

I actually think that Blah is the nerd defector. I mean, Storm Blade was the only one who tried to defend him, maybe because they're in cahoots together? And why else would you defend Blah's theories anyway?

I dunno, just my 2 cents. I don't think TDL's role would have an extra 'give-away' part of his role (Storm Blade didn't have one, so I doubt TDL would have one too). The theory that he's a band teacher, or even just a band kid is sound though (cwutididthur)
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

lol It was MY theory, Hat.

oyeah1988 said:
Actually DNA we only have until tomorrow @ 7PM EST. Risky is 13 hours ahead of EST.
As such, I have my own theory. TDL posted lyrics to a song by Cake. If there are teachers in this game, couldn't TDL be a band teacher who could defect to a geek (Just like Storm Blade could defect to the jocks?) ("Band geeks" is the reference I am making) I shall not vote yet, but I would like to hear your guy's thoughts.
Click to expand...

Also fixed the quote.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

Keep in mind, if we're going to use Storm Blade's role as a blanket-statement for TDL, a Nerd has to die before TDL can join the dark-side. I don't know if that's happened yet or not (I'll leave that to you guys), but if it hasn't, then there is nothing to debate.

At this point it seems as if we have no choice but to accept the random lynch. One day left and there are no plausible leads. Maybe we get lucky and lynch a Nerd/Jock... maybe not.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

Hatman said:
I actually think that Blah is the nerd defector. I mean, Storm Blade was the only one who tried to defend him, maybe because they're in cahoots together? And why else would you defend Blah's theories anyway?

I dunno, just my 2 cents. I don't think TDL's role would have an extra 'give-away' part of his role (Storm Blade didn't have one, so I doubt TDL would have one too). The theory that he's a band teacher, or even just a band kid is sound though (cwutididthur)
Click to expand...

You know, I think there might be some weight to hatman's theory here. We all generally assumed blah's a neutral, but the teachers are neutrals until a nerd/jock dies.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

http://www.pokebeach.com/forums/thr...nd-12-6-2011-8am-gmt-8?pid=2169283#pid2169283
http://www.pokebeach.com/forums/thr...nd-12-6-2011-8am-gmt-8?pid=2169050#pid2169050

I have to admit. I never noticed, until now, but Superpokemon67 and Hat keep agreeing with each other. Perhaps they could be on the same team? Hmm. Unless someone, like DNA or meaty can convince me otherwise, I will actually vote.

Vote: Superpokemon67

Main reason: Just like DNA, it's mostly a hunch. I do have evidence, though, as in those links I posted above.

Also, on the subject, IF hatman and SP67 are in cahoots with each other, then this post has a whole new meaning! Notice where it says "ISB, Hatman and/or Tpot are townies." SP67 just attempted to give an alibi for Hatman. Again, you guy's thoughts? R
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

DNA said:
As you're well aware, TDL has to sing song lyrics as part of his role. However with the lynching of Storm Blade, a neutral who could become a jock defector, we think that since TDL is reciting song lyrics, his role might be something along the lines of "band teacher" and theoretically a neutral who could become a nerd defector.

It's an okay theory, but I don't see much going for it.
Click to expand...

Yeah, that lynch would be nearly random as well...could be something to consider later.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

Well, I don't think I can convince you one way or the other about a hunch, so I have nothing to say against you.

And, checking the time... let's see, it's just after 9am in my time zone. And based on time zone differences, Day 4 is going to end at 4pm in my time zone. That is about 7 hours. So in 7 hours we either need to amass enough votes, or accept the random lynch.

I'm going to be at class at 4pm (most likely), so I'm going to cast a vote now,

vote: superpokemon67

I have a feeling that was the post I was looking for, but accidentally voted ISB instead of this guy.
And by the time I get back, stuff will have happened. Maybe.

Or we face random lynch.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

vote: superpokemon67
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

gah, I'm so tired of having no leads, and having to just take what other people say as word, but whatever.

Unvote: ISB
Vote: superpokemon67

We still would have to know that Hatman was a nerd or a jock to be all too suspicious, but we could lose a very valuable player to the random lynch and I'm not willing to take that risk.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

1) What the heck is a defector?

2) Unvote: ISB
Vote: superpokemon67
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

I'm away for school and a bandwagon starts against me? I'm just agreeing with hatman's theory, and I think it's something we should look into.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 4 End 12/6/2011 8AM GMT+8

As DNA would say, I'm going to say flat out that I'm not the nerd defector, even though that can't really be proved. What even is a nerd defector? I honestly don't know.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top