Finished Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Nerds Win

Status
Not open for further replies.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 7 End 01/03/2012 8AM GMT+8

oyeah1988 said:
Correction, there is only 1 Jock left. How do I know this?
look here At that time, B_C said there were half of the jocks remaining. If the nerds killed 1, we lynched 1 and then you double it (opposite of halving), you get a total of 4.
Now onto business. I have no clue where to go from here. Take that from me as you will.
Click to expand...

Again, the above post, is a total assumption.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 9 End 01/21/2012 8AM GMT+8

I thought we had already agreed that Hatman was the last jock... ._. Either way, I see no reason to lynch him, as jocks haven't killed since the leader died. We might as well leave him be as an obstacle to the real threat, nerds.

At this point I believe that Gale is the one with the role that locks all the doors, and I also have a possible hunch as to who might be a nerd. More on this later (possibly, it depends what happens.)
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 9 End 01/21/2012 8AM GMT+8

Meaty said:
I thought we had already agreed that Hatman was the last jock... ._. Either way, I see no reason to lynch him, as jocks haven't killed since the leader died. We might as well leave him be as an obstacle to the real threat, nerds.

At this point I believe that Gale is the one with the role that locks all the doors, and I also have a possible hunch as to who might be a nerd. More on this later (possibly, it depends what happens.)
Click to expand...

On the bold point, Meaty is 120% Incorrect. (The extra 20 is because he's that much cooler. *slapped*)
Also, could I hear your testimony on who you think is a nerd (You know why...), and why you think Gale locks the doors?
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 9 End 01/21/2012 8AM GMT+8

Honestly I was just guessing that Gale locks doors since you said his role was important and we wanted him alive. But now I remember that you said we needed to finish him eventually, so, uh.... yeah that wasn't smart. As to that other thing, I'm not comfortable throwing accusations around just yet.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 9 End 01/21/2012 8AM GMT+8

Wow. That was a fast day yesterday, I never got time to post. Yeah, uh, I was wondering where the vote on Blue Thunder came from....We are sure Oyeah is on our side, right?
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 9 End 01/21/2012 8AM GMT+8

Hold it. Yes I am, although that'll depend on what side YOU are on... :p j/k 100% Neutral here.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 9 End 01/21/2012 8AM GMT+8

Oyeah never saw or claimed to have seen BT, so it's not like he purposely screwed us over. He just made a somewhat logical theory but it was wrong....
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 9 End 01/21/2012 8AM GMT+8

Yeah.... I wasn't accusing him, just wondering.

I got nothing, anyone have any ideas?
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 9 End 01/21/2012 8AM GMT+8

I just rememberd that TDL lost his abilities... If I'm correct on his role this isn't very good thing... :/ But yeah my assumptions aren't always so good. I'm also waiting for more people to post. :/
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 9 End 01/21/2012 8AM GMT+8

We don't really even have any leads today, do we? I mean, Hatman needs to be killed or else we can't win (all wolves have to be eliminated for the town to win if I recall correctly). I say we take the lynch on him.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 9 End 01/21/2012 8AM GMT+8

Also, if I was a jock (which I'm not) that would just mean that the nerds would be one step closer to winning. Remember that they need to have all jocks dead too, you know, and since the jocks power is gone, they pose no threat. And there is no clearer proof than oyeah stating that I'm not a jock, we all know what his role is, so if he used it on me, then he definitely knows that I'm not a jock.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 9 End 01/21/2012 8AM GMT+8

Wrong. I honestly don't know what Imakuni is. I do, however, know who is the final Jock, (that is, if my guess of 4 jocks is correct.) What we need is to keep that person alive, but lynch him at the end. As long as that person is still alive, the Nerds cannot win.

Meaty, please, who do you think we should go after? Our time is limited. We need anything to help us win.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 9 End 01/21/2012 8AM GMT+8

Well... Not to throw him under the bus here(oh wait I guess I do mean to), but at this point...

I strongly believe that ESP is a nerd... :eek: So many things are just disturbing me.... Sure, he's a known, experienced smart player that we don't want to waste. But that also makes him a potentially big threat. A smart player being a nerd (possibly leader) would also explain why the nerds are doing so well this game. Just right now he seemed eager to point a finger and get rid of a likely jock, and avoid attention elsewhere. He completely ignored my possible lead. If I recall, ESP has done this before. Another point: If ESP is such a good player, why hasn't he been targetted yet??? If he ever has(I don't think he has), it was most likely by jocks. I know he wasn't targetted since the jock leader died, except by that indie role. This whole game he has been acting just slightly suspicious to me, and he always seems to want to go after people quickly, focusing attention on them, and he's always voting against jocks. I suggest that you look back at some posts and judge for yourself.

In the meantime, Vote: ESP

As for you, ESP, I'd like to hear your defense.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 9 End 01/21/2012 8AM GMT+8

Meaty said:
Just right now he seemed eager to point a finger and get rid of a likely jock, and avoid attention elsewhere.
Why not just kill him now? We're pretty sure he is a jock because the Jock Leader basically pointed his finger at all of the jocks. We have to kill him at sometime to win, and if we get one that we know now, we can spend the next night looking for a nerd to kill. And either way, even though there aren't too many of us left, there are still likely a small number of nerds. I'd rather give the seer a chance to check out a nerd so we don't kill one of the few remaining townies with our lynch.

Another point: If ESP is such a good player, why hasn't he been targetted yet???
Actually, I had a knife thrown at me on like night 7 (here) and that didn't work. I luckily got saved.

This whole game he has been acting just slightly suspicious to me, and he always seems to want to go after people quickly.
This is how I act every game if anyone can remember. It has gotten me into trouble before, but it's the best way to play in my opinion. Nothing happens during the day, and since our seer is alive, we know that we can get a lead on someone, or at least find out that someone is on our side.

and he's always voting against jocks.
Because we need to kill all jocks to win the game? If we had leads against nerds, I'd kill them too. Just go ahead and tell me if you've got one, I'd be more than happy to hear it and vote against them too. Other than the "lead" you have on me because I'm obviously not going to vote against myself.
Click to expand...

I basically felt like I covered all of your points. Basically, I like to be as sure as possible before taking a lynch, especially now that we know who the seer is. But, if I have to, I'll side with the town if killing someone we're not sure of is the only option besides the random lynch which can kill our seer or even our priest.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 9 End 01/21/2012 8AM GMT+8

Okay, well, I think ESP could be suspicious. However, he does make a valid point. We should vote off Imakuni?/Hatman. We have evidence for him being a jock, and if we don't vote him, we increase the chance we kill a townie.

Sorry, Imakuni?/Hatman:

Vote: Imakuni?
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 9 End 01/21/2012 8AM GMT+8

God Sakes, Hatman is NOT A JOCK! I KNOW WHO THE LAST ONE IS, AND IT ISN'T HATMAN. On the ESP Front, however, you could say great minds think alike. Take that as you will, but for the time being:
Vote: ESP
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 9 End 01/21/2012 8AM GMT+8

Ughh... Then why is everyone going on about Hatman being a jock?

Fine...

Unvote: Hatman

I still dont see any conclusive evidence for Esp, so I'm not going to vote yet.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 9 End 01/21/2012 8AM GMT+8

First off, only ESP was going on about Imakuni? being a jock. Secondly, ESP, You're not using logic. The jocks are one more obstacle for the nerds to win. Sure, we could lynch the final jock now and save a night, but why? It is impossible for the lone remaining jock to win. With that in mind, your logic is absolutely horribly flawed. Since lynching the remaining jock now will have a 0% chance of helping the town win, the fact that you are trying to do so makes you extremely suspicious.

Vote: ESP

Also, the guy who tried to kill you, ESP, was either a townie or an indie, so it doesn't prove anything about your alliance.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 9 End 01/21/2012 8AM GMT+8

Dark Void said:
It is impossible for the lone remaining jock to win. With that in mind, your logic is absolutely horribly flawed. Since lynching the remaining jock now will have a 0% chance of helping the town win, the fact that you are trying to do so makes you extremely suspicious.
Click to expand...

Lynching the remaining jock is MANDATORY for the town to win. And, no, it is not impossible for the remaining jock to win. If all of the townies and nerds are killed, the jock wins. The win for all townies can not be fulfilled until all wolves, jocks or nerds, are dead. Since we don't know for sure any of the nerds, I thought we'd just take the quick and easy kill on a jock. Guess you guys don't look at things the same way I do.

I never even voted for who I think the last jock is and you guys are all over me for it. Why aren't you after TDL at all who actually proposed the theory?

And oyeah, how do you know for sure Hatman/Imakuni? isn't a jock? If you haven't actually seered him, it's all speculation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top