Finished Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Nerds Win

Status
Not open for further replies.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

Storm Blade was also the only one to notice that PMJ could kill people besides Meaty, making PMJ somewhat dangerous. The only reason the Jocks would have tried to kill PMJ is that if the jocks thought PMJ was dangerous. That evidence right there makes Storm Blade a jock because the jocks wouldn't have thought of PMJ as dangerous otherwise. Combine that with bandwagoning against me and not having very many posts and you have yourself a lead.

However, I'm not going to vote yet. I don't want to bandwagon against yet another neutral. There's also someone else who is becoming more and more suspicious but I'm going to gather all the evidence I have before I say something...
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

Thanks Dark Void! I understand the situation better now.

As of now I, too, am not really sure what to do. I agree that lynching Blah is probably better than triggering a random lynch, and so far I don't know enough about Stormblade to have an opinion. Has he, to our knowledge, made any slip-ups in the game so far?
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

Check out post 557 on this thread (I would quote it but the quote thing is glitching for me) He posted it after we were discussing why the jocks would want to lynch PMJ. Unless it's just a really good guess, this is huge evidence that Storm Blade could be a jock. See my previous posts for more info.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

ESP said:
So, here's what I'm gonna say.

We have less than 2 days to vote. Barely enough people are active to get lynches in. We have only really 2 options in my opinion:
1.) Random Lynch. Someone important whom we don't know (the seer) or someone we do know (Meaty, the priest) could be killed.
2.) We vote off someone, such as Blah, who has tried numerous times to vote to lynch someone with little to no evidence. This tactic is just as bad as a random lynch, and will eventually force us into losing a key player.

I'm standing by my vote for Blah unless someone magically finds a better option (which I am not seeing right now).
Click to expand...

My plan for today is to read as much as possible before I go to bed tonight so I don't do anything stupid or overlook previously revealed evidence.

If I need to vote now for some reason, I'll gladly do it, but I want to read everything before I do.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

Vote: Stormblade

I think this is our best option at the moment. Unlike blah237, it is quite possible that Stormblade is a jock/nerd. I know we want to lynch blah237 because his logic might get an important player killed, but really as long as we don't listen to him too much there's no harm in him being alive. I'd rather try to accomplish something by lynching someone who seems to be a wolf.

PMJ pretty much said it all already, but Stormblade remained quiet earlier on, quickly bandwagonned to blah237 with no apparent reason except for hoping to lynch someone other than himself, and he does seem to actually think PMJ is dangerous. He even tried to stretch PMJ's ability to be able to pick off others, possible those who he knows not to be in his own faction.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

Here is what I was thinking when I posted:
I thought PMJ's ability let him kill one person off who was suspicious of him. Then the jocks tried to kill him off last night. I thought why would the jocks try to kill him if the only person who was suspicious of him was Meaty. That is why I went back through the posts to see who else was suspicious.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

...it's rather weird to go back into the thread to post everyone who was potentially suspicious of PMJ day 1. Without going too much into my reasoning, since if I did so, I would potentially put myself in danger,

Vote: Storm Blade

...for reasons stated above, plus my own opinions on the matter as well.

sorry, eevee; nothing personal ;;
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

Vote: Storm Blade

Sorry. There is only room for one sb around here.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

Meaty said:
Vote: Stormblade

I think this is our best option at the moment. Unlike blah237, it is quite possible that Stormblade is a jock/nerd. I know we want to lynch blah237 because his logic might get an important player killed, but really as long as we don't listen to him too much there's no harm in him being alive. I'd rather try to accomplish something by lynching someone who seems to be a wolf.

PMJ pretty much said it all already, but Stormblade remained quiet earlier on, quickly bandwagonned to blah237 with no apparent reason except for hoping to lynch someone other than himself, and he does seem to actually think PMJ is dangerous. He even tried to stretch PMJ's ability to be able to pick off others, possible those who he knows not to be in his own faction.
Click to expand...
I will actually agree here. Of course, PMJ is dangerous... to the Jock and Nerd factions. First off I must Unvote: Blah237. His logic did unfortunately cost us two useful players, but I'd truly rather lose a Jock/Nerd than lose a Neutral. Next, for the reasons Meaty posted, I shall Vote: Storm Blade. Unless he can give us a valid response with evidence stating why he shouldn't be lynched, my vote will stand.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

Vote: Storm Blade

Why does everyone else always beat me to posting logic. Stupid 6 hour session of Skyward Sword grumblegrumble
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

Sorry. There is only toom for one sb around here.
Click to expand...
your reason is lame
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

After reading over the posts i agree with meaty's logic also, but firat Unvote:Blah237 then Vote:storm blade
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

Vote: Stormblade

I'm not really sure what else to do at this point. We don't have enough evidence for anyone else.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

And so the table's have turned.

Vote: Storm Blade
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

*Ahem* Why does everyone continue to not notice these things? There's three votes for me now. Only ESP and Storm Blade still have votes against me. One of them wants me dead, and that one wants me dead FAST. I have bad feeling that Storm Blade is not the one who wants to kill me...

I'm going to gather all of my evidence and post it after I eat dinner. I think I may actually be on to something this time and it's not just random. I'll see what you guys think after I post the info.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

Urk. A bandwagon again.

I kind of feel that Storm Blade was just trying to help, and he already posted his reasoning for doing what he did... there isn't much more he can defend himself with. But, since what he did COULD be defined as suspicious and our only other lynch option is Blah (who I really don't think we should lynch), I'm going to have to hop on this (as much as I don't like it. But there really isn't any other choice).

Vote: Storm Blade
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

Alright, here we go. It's reasoning time. I apologize ahead of time for the lack of quotes in this post, quotes kind of glitch up my computer when I try to use too many of them.

Let's start by getting straight to the point. Vote: ESP

Now for the reasons. Remember all the way back when I though ESP was suspicious for saying he wasn't going to kill Lenny and then Lenny was killed? Now, that seemed ridiculous at the time. It was a total shot in the dark.

Now, in the current day, ESP is the first one to vote for me. Nothing super suspicious about that, there has to be a first to vote for everyone right?

After that, ESP notices that someone has a double vote. "It has to be ISB, Hatman, or Teapot", he says. Well, now it's only possible for ESP or Storm Blade to have the double vote. And since ESP noticed it in the first place, it can't be him...right?

This is where my brain clicked. ESP was the first to mention the double vote thing, so as to make every one else think he couldn't have the double vote. Normally that would seem ridiculous because ESP would have never done that. HOWEVER, ESP used THE EXACT SAME TACTIC against Lenny. He said he wasn't going to kill him, and then (I think he) did.

But if this is all true, why would ESP want to kill ME so badly? I haven't proven to be anything special or dangerous. But I was the first one to bring up the point about ESP possibly being a wolf. Now, because of that, he wants me dead before I can say anything else against him, and he wants me dead NOW. That's why he used whatever his double vote ability was against me.

Alright, that's it. Let me know what you guys think. The evidence seems really solid to me, so point out any flaws in my logic there might be that I didn't think of.
 
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8

OR...it's because that when ESP voted, he voted along with DNA (and I think Storm Blade), and Cakers said that there were only 3 votes. The double vote hint didn't come around until after myself, Hatman, and Teapot voted.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top