RE: Werewolf XIII - Gunfire at Dusty Gulch - Day 2 ends Friday, July 13, at 11.59 PM PDT
Glace said:
I don't know why I am on the possible scum list, I guess I said something stupid that I didn't realize =/.
No, I can safely say that this is not the case. Though I will say that you are probably the weakest link I've got. At this point, I feel better about the others than you, if that's any consolation.
King Arceus said:
What did I ever do to get on the list?
When the whole thing was going on with the usergroup problems, I explained to everyone why I (and by extension, you) was obviously town. It seemed like a foolproof clearing, but then I realized that we're really not the same. See, I can prove I had a conversation with DNA about setting up the new wolf forum in which I said that if I drew wolf I would do it anyway. The fact that DNA had issues setting it up proves that I didn't get wolf (because if I had, he wouldn't have had issues).
The difference here is that you don't have that option because it never happened. When I told DNA to ask a super mod who wasn't playing, I actually mentioned Celebi since he was the first one who came to mind. It is entirely possible that you drew wolf and DNA had CMP set the mod forum up anyway regardless of whether or not he actually did it. DNA told me he asked CMP to do it, and that's the truth. But was it necessary? I don't know.
Of course, I couldn't very well point this out because if you somehow got lynched and turned out to be scum, that would be a huge red flag that I was lying, too, and I don't think I'd be able to get myself out of a bind like that. Now that Cinesra has definitively proved that I'm town, I feel a lot safer coming forward about this.
All this said, you haven't done or said anything particularly scummy. I just can't help but think that if you _were_ scum and saw my reasoning for why I was town, you'd be a fool not to try and use the same defense because it's pretty much bulletproof.
tl;dr I can't vouch for you as town because your defense was my defense which was rendered moot by Cinesra's inspection of me.
Nengeni said:
That is my point. I can target someone and tell how many times they've used a night role. Hence why I was a little suspicious.
I haven't read anything else, so I'll respond to anything the next time I can post.
That's what I thought. Just wanted some confirmation, thanks.
Adding Bisharp37 to scum list because he's a gen 5 fanboy and hates any region not named Unova, clearly this is the mindset of pure scum
ShadowLugia may have a protection role, but scum had one last game too. Just because he has a protection role absolutely does not mean he's town, and we should keep this in mind for the future. Not saying he's scum for sure, but I am saying that he shouldn't be absolved of guilt just because he has a protection role.
Puff just seems to want to cast blame anywhere and everywhere. He also tried to draw focus away from finding Vigilantes and put all our attention on TheGuy's enemy. While it's true that he is a danger to the town, the Vigilantes are just as big a threat and should not be ignored.
"but pmj ur stuff is weak bro" Yeah well this is Day 2, deal with it. If I live long enough to refine this list, I will. Take from my analyses what you will; we're closing in on the deadline and still have no suspects.
Now that Nengeni has confirmed my suspicions, I'm curious as to what a town player could possibly do with the knowledge of how many times a night ability has been used. Scum could easily use that to pinpoint seers, doctors, or any important town role (one that can be used every night as opposed to only once or twice). So he's on the list too.
Despite what I just said, I think that as weak as our knowledge is, Puff is still my strongest link for lynch today. I don't want to be like scumbag HypnoticLuxray and vote once the entire game after living until Day 9, so:
Vote: Puff
