RE: Werewolf XVI: A New Melee. Day 1 ends March 30 at 8 PM CST.
Woah. A lot happened since I last checked this thread.
Astra's flavor text seems to indicate that he is an indie. In addiiton, he claims that he left a role out of his role reveal and left out his final smash as well...but then revealed the latter when prompted? Maybe because he needed more time to revise his final smash? The final smash doesn't initially seem like something that would need hiding-it doesn't really benefit either the wolves or town very much (and it could hurt or help either, depending on the skill of the player who gets the good roles) which is odd for two reasons. One because its a supposedly town smash that doesn't directly help the town at all and may hurt it. Two because since this final smash is so mediocre, Astra should have no reason to cut it out of his role reveal. Also, priest role is a rather obvious one to claim if you don't want to be lynched because its generally considered a "power role". also has a period at the end of his win con, obv scum or indie I consider him very suspicious.
I recall the first ww game that cornbread played in. He played the noob role exceedingly well, getting seer and dropping hints so subtle that the wolves never noticed. Unfortunately, they were so subtle that even after he died and was revealed to be seer no townies went through his posts and went, "OH HEY SEER THOUGHT THIS GUY WAS SCUM, MAYBE HE WAS RIGHT?" What I'm trying to say is that you shouldn't underestimate cornbread just because his spelling and grammar are atrocious and he looks like he's new to this. I can understand the though behind his "rules", and perhaps he posted them without properly considering who would actually benefit from them...but as I said before, I think cornbread tries to make people think he's worse than he is. I don't think its worth using our lynch on him when we have other options though, but he's still suspicious imo.
Luckyfire has gotten a little less suspicious in my mind, if only because there are now better choices to lynch. She is still somewhat suspicious to me, but honestly that flavor text radiates the distinct writing style of PMJ and doesn't look anything like what Luckyfire would write. Still better than a No Lynch because we get to see if she told the truth about her role, but imo we can do a lot better than No Lynch now.
I'm not sure why anyone else has been voted for, and for the most part they haven't been. Based on the reasons in this post, it is my opinion that Astra is our best lynch for the day.
Vote: Astra
I do love getting to vote in excessively obnoxious colors that hurt even my eyes.
