Finished Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Game Over! A winner is PMJ and RogueChomp

[SoldiersSpirit]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

Triple post, OH MY *Peaches*

RogueChomp

Was one of your roles specifically rolecop? Did you get camoclones win condition in your results as well?

Yes it's role cop, but I can only use it every 2 nights, just like priest and role block.

Omg I can't wait for the answer to my other question! So what exactly was the result of camoclones role, letter for letter in the correct order. Dont quote but I need the exact wording of his role. Was it Vanilla Townie?

 

[SoldiersSpirit]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

I stated it was sheninjas game and he replied after that? If it was a different game than nvm everything I said Kecleon lol.

Roguechomp, the results you got back was Vanilla Townie correct? This is imoortant so go back to your inbox and let me us know exactly what it said for his role.

yes, he's is DEFINITELY vannila townie.

So your result from last night was worded like this...

Vanilla townie

So something along the lines of Camoclone was found out to be Vanilla Townie?

 

[Teal]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

Wrong again...I have enough evidence:
DNA is cult with: PMJ or James
Roguechomp: Indie but he helps the town
SS: Town

How is that evidence?

 

[WanderingWolf]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

To you:

I am scum, DNA is scum, PMJ is scum, DNA I safe, RogueChomp is safe and SS is safe.

And yet, you have no evidence for ANY of them... _-_

Wrong again...I have enough evidence:
DNA is cult with: PMJ or James
Roguechomp: Indie but he helps the town
SS: Town

... What? So your evidence for us being scum/cult/town is that we are all scum/cult/town.

OMG, PERFECTEST LOGIC EVAR!!!!1!

Seriously... I lost a few thousand brain cells by reading your comment.

 

[RogueChomp]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

yes, he's is DEFINITELY vannila townie.

So your result from last night was worded like this...

Vanilla townie

So something along the lines of Camoclone was found out to be Vanilla Townie?

Yes.

 

[SoldiersSpirit]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

So your result from last night was worded like this...

Vanilla townie

So something along the lines of Camoclone was found out to be Vanilla Townie?

Yes.

Kk noted, everyone stay tuned, will need to pm astra about semantics.

 

[Haunted Water]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

If DNA is in a cult, why would he be going so aggressively after twist? I'll be looking at that relationship. If it changes.... I'll immediately jump on DNA. If he is cult leader, his attitude would change towards twist. HOWEVER, I'm quit suspicious of him right now, so I'm not afraid to start driving away at him if need be.

 

[Haunted Water]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

Wait, Soldier, can you prove to us you're town? I'm not comfortable taking advice and giving up the Town Leadership role to someone who I don't even know if they are town or not. I'd follow camoclone's word before I follow your word.

 

[WanderingWolf]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

Wait, Soldier, can you prove to us you're town? I'm not comfortable taking advice and giving up the Town Leadership role to someone who I don't even know if they are town or not. I'd follow camoclone's word before I follow your word.

Why? Camoclones word is basically this:

I think you're scum, so you're scum.

Its almost like this:

*holds up paper* Oh, hi. You may have noticed this delicious piece of cake in my hand.
Oh, no no no, its a delicious piece of cake, not a piece of paper.
*turn paper over, showing 'This is a piece of cake.'* See. My evidence is this. It says that its a piece of cake, SO IT IS!

 

[Camoclone]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

Wait, Soldier, can you prove to us you're town? I'm not comfortable taking advice and giving up the Town Leadership role to someone who I don't even know if they are town or not. I'd follow camoclone's word before I follow your word.

Why? Camoclones word is basically this:

I think you're scum, so you're scum.

Its almost like this:

*holds up paper* Oh, hi. You may have noticed this delicious piece of cake in my hand.
Oh, no no no, its a delicious piece of cake, not a piece of paper.
*turn paper over, showing 'This is a piece of cake.'* See. My evidence is this. It says that its a piece of cake, SO IT IS!

That's not my logic...Do I need to hold your hand James? I will if I must...

 

[DNA]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

Is this going to be a repeat of last game where camoclone is policy lynched for being a complete idiot?

You have no evidence for any of your claims and you change your mind more often than a politician. There is absolutely no reason to listen to anything you say, and it's incredibly annoying.
If you have anything worthwhile to say, then you should just say it, WITHOUT triple-posting.

I'm cult with PMJ or James? First, why PMJ? If I were cult, I would definitely NOT call out someone of my alignment. This means at most 1 of us is cult. At most 1. This also includes 0. In fact, it should be fairly obvious to everyone by now that neither PMJ nor I are members of this cult.

Secondly, why James? Seriously, why James? We have had absolutely no ties or relation to each other this game. You are just digging yourself deeper the more you talk.

 

[WanderingWolf]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

Why? Camoclones word is basically this:

I think you're scum, so you're scum.

Its almost like this:

*holds up paper* Oh, hi. You may have noticed this delicious piece of cake in my hand.
Oh, no no no, its a delicious piece of cake, not a piece of paper.
*turn paper over, showing 'This is a piece of cake.'* See. My evidence is this. It says that its a piece of cake, SO IT IS!

That's not my logic...Do I need to hold your hand James? I will if I must...

Yes, mum. Can I also get a lollipop at the story, mummy?

Seriously, LOOK AT YOUR CLAIMS! Explain what you're saying, and why you're saying it... I actually though we had gone over this post-game after Greatest Idea... Apparantly not.

 

[Professor Palutena]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

Is this going to be a repeat of last game where camoclone is policy lynched for being a complete idiot?

Seriously, kill it with the insults or I'll sub you out.

 

[Camoclone]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

Is this going to be a repeat of last game where camoclone is policy lynched for being a complete idiot?

This shows that you would love to lynch a confo-town. What is wrong with you?


Also please just quit it with insulting me. I understand you don't like me but this is ridiculous. K thx!

 

[Camoclone]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

That's not my logic...Do I need to hold your hand James? I will if I must...

Yes, mum. Can I also get a lollipop at the story, mummy?

Seriously, LOOK AT YOUR CLAIMS! Explain what you're saying, and why you're saying it... I actually though we had gone over this post-game after Greatest Idea... Apparantly not.

I kind of assumed that you were able to comprehend thing for yourself. However since you insist:
DNA is cult because:
>He claims for little to no reason putting himself on the line. If he was a true town PR he wouldn't do that.
>He claims everything about his role which he shouldn't do. For example if I was DNA's role then I would claim:
I can prevent people from changing alignments instead of "I will know it if you change alignments later".
>DNA just happened to target PMJ and so did a recruiter... DNA and PMJ seem to be good friends so why not recruit your friend when a cult... A cult would have been able to use his ability yesterday.
>DNA is making NO attempt whatsoever to scum hunt or contribute making him seem like and indie or wolf. However DNA is NOT a wolf. He is either town or an indie.
>DNA wants to lynch the randomest of people...Who are not the least it scummy and one of which is confo-town.
>DNA insists on playing this game "his way" which I could respect and would not see as a indie without all the other stuff.


Case on James later. Also by the way I will not tell you why I think people are town due to that only helping the wolves.

 

[TwistedTurtwig]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

Why? Camoclones word is basically this:

I think you're scum, so you're scum.

Its almost like this:

*holds up paper* Oh, hi. You may have noticed this delicious piece of cake in my hand.
Oh, no no no, its a delicious piece of cake, not a piece of paper.
*turn paper over, showing 'This is a piece of cake.'* See. My evidence is this. It says that its a piece of cake, SO IT IS!

*likes*

And I think that a few people have been mixing up TokyoToots and I, since both of our names can be shortened to TT. DNA has been referring to me as the logic-defying one who always pulls scum, not TokyoToots. TokyoToots is just a new guy. We should definitely have some way to differentiate us in the future, so that there are no mix ups.

Just a few of my thoughts on the game:
- TokyoToots has been acting very suspiciously. It could be because he's new, I'm leaning more towards him being scum. His out of the blue vote for Roguechomp was definitely strange.
- Yay, DNA finally came to his senses! (Although I'd actually love to be a wolf just to break the laws of probability a bit more.)
- The Roguechomp bandwagon seems senseless to me; I feel like most people were jumping on it just because of the confusions about lynching rules.
- SS and CC are being.... their usual selves. You know, I understand that they come from a hardcore WW community, where the majority of players play like they do, but as Kecleon-X has pointed out, such agressiveness has jeopardized the game before. On Pokebeach, it's a lot more casual, from what I've seen, so it's no surprise there's such an aversion to their playstyles.

Also, I'd like to just put it out there that at the beginning of the game, Camoclone started a QT with players he thought were better than everyone else. Smooth move, Camo. Because all of the good players are clearly never scum. Not much has happened in it, to be honest, but I feel like everyone needs to know this kind of stuff. Take this however you please: http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/6ZMVni6XJa3

Oh, and I fully expect myself to be added to Camo's "scum list" for this by his next post, but I wouldn't expect any less.

 

[DNA]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

This shows that you would love to lynch a confo-town. What is wrong with you?

This is new. Where on earth is this confirmation that you're talking about?

>He claims for little to no reason putting himself on the line. If he was a true town PR he wouldn't do that.

I rarely survive games here. I find the best strategy for me is to give the town as much information as I can before finally being taken out. If you think that's the mark of a scumbag, then...that's your opinion.

>DNA just happened to target PMJ and so did a recruiter... DNA and PMJ seem to be good friends so why not recruit your friend when a cult... A cult would have been able to use his ability yesterday.

I've explained myself about this. PMJ mentioned something in the role confirmation phase about alignment changes. I investigated him on a hunch (with my ability) and was given that result. This was when I assumed players could change their own alignments. And my hunch has paid off. PMJ hasn't been recruited.

In fact, I don't even think anyone would have discussed anything about any kind of cult if I hadn't spoken up. The cult leader would have been content to remain in the shadows and steadily fulfill his wincon. But now that I have publicly revealed the existence of a player(s) being able to change alignments of others...well, don't you think if I were cult I would have kept my mouth shut?

>DNA is making NO attempt whatsoever to scum hunt or contribute making him seem like and indie or wolf. However DNA is NOT a wolf. He is either town or an indie.

I go based off of hints I receive during the night. That was the hint I was given, and now I'm sharing it with you guys. You can read people's posts and try to point out scum, but I find role info (day or night) is the best way to play the game. After all, it's straight from the GM. There's no way it's false.

>DNA wants to lynch the randomest of people...Who are not the least it scummy and one of which is confo-town.

I don't think anyone is confo-town at this point in the game.

- Yay, DNA finally came to his senses! (Although I'd actually love to be a wolf just to break the laws of probability a bit more.)

You suck, TT <3

 

[Teal]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

RogueChomp says he inspected camo and camo is VT.

 

[Camoclone]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

This more than anything proves my point... Anyone town aligned would have at least skimmed the last 2-3 pages.

 

[sillykyle]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

##UNBANDWAGON: RogueChomp Scumbag Astra lying about the time left... :[

To you:

I am scum, DNA is scum, PMJ is scum, DNA I safe, RogueChomp is safe and SS is safe.

And yet, you have no evidence for ANY of them... _-_

Wrong again...I have enough evidence:
DNA is cult with: PMJ or James
Roguechomp: Indie but he helps the town
SS: Town

Evidence... I don't think that word means what you think it means. DNA is absolutely right, your claims have 0 logic backing them up. And he didn't say "GAIZ LYNCH CAMO HES AGRESIVE LUL", he said you're going to turn everyone against you d1 again and screw the town over. Again.