Finished Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Game Over! A winner is PMJ and RogueChomp

[Haunted Water]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

Let's go.

I have a townread on Tokyo. I have an item that can be combined with another item, and so does he. He offered to pass me his half. Why would a wolf give a townie a beneficial effect instead of wanting it to themselves?

Maybe he wants you to think that. Being two-faced is a weapon for the scum to utilize.

 

[Poseidon]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

Let's go.

I have a townread on Tokyo. I have an item that can be combined with another item, and so does he. He offered to pass me his half. Why would a wolf give a townie a beneficial effect instead of wanting it to themselves?

Maybe he wants you to think that. Being two-faced is a weapon for the scum to utilize.

You think someone who is in their first game would be able to pull that off? Nah.

 

[SoldiersSpirit]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

Vablakes, so you're saying eagle needs and item that combines with another and you have half of something as well as Tokyotoots? Yea, I'm not buying it. I actually believe Eagle.

@Astra I have a question. Say I pm a player saying hey I think kecleon is scum and I believe you're town, im a townie with a very useful role and I think you're town too so yea.

But that said player then quotes that post to post in game thread and changes what I say. Is that illegal just want to clear before I pm anyone lol.

 

[WanderingWolf]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

@Astra I have a question. Say I pm a player saying hey I think kecleon is scum and I believe you're town, im a townie with a very useful role and I think you're town too so yea.

But that said player then quotes that post to post in game thread and changes what I say. Is that illegal just want to clear before I pm anyone lol.

You know you just alerted everyone that you have a useful role... -.-

 

[sillykyle]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

Please note that the new lynch rules are not in effect yet, they will be starting day 2. Hmm...

What?

Takes 13 votes to lynch. If you fail to meet this quota, a random town allied player will be killed with the powers of random.org.

Note: Voting rules will change tomorrow to the following. I would've brought them up today but it slipped my mind while doing votals and its not really fair to change them so close to the deadline. If a change is not mentioned, nothing has changed.

Pretty sure this means the voting requirement is stricter today. Unless that's what you meant...

 

[PMJ]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

You know you just alerted everyone that you have a useful role... -.-

He would have if everyone was not allowed to lie about their role. He mentioned he was paranoid, hint hint, which could mean he's the paranoid gun owner (anyone who visits him, anyone, gets shot and killed). Or paranoid cop. Or neither.

My thoughts on d1:

- DNA's insistence that tt is scum--again--is certainly odd since I know my boy DNA to be a man of science, and to be falling so hard for the gambler's fallacy is definitely unlike him. Maybe DNA also has some sort of investigative ability that either confirms or highly suggests that tt is scum, and that's why DNA is tunneling him so hard.

- I had to read grant's wall of text like 8 times before I understood it. And I'm still not sure I do. SheNinja, why do you believe grant is sk based off of what he said?

- I don't understand the wagon on TokyoToots. Can someone explain what the deal is?

I need to go to school, bye

 

[SoldiersSpirit]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

@Astra I have a question. Say I pm a player saying hey I think kecleon is scum and I believe you're town, im a townie with a very useful role and I think you're town too so yea.

But that said player then quotes that post to post in game thread and changes what I say. Is that illegal just want to clear before I pm anyone lol.

You know you just alerted everyone that you have a useful role... -.-

It was an example, question still stands though!

James, Tokyotoots is newbscum plain and simple. Look at the one post of sheeping and the post in the night chat blindly following everyone. By that, if tokyo flips scum, rogue and DNA are cleared not to be scum. I could've said cleared townies but rogue is def indie so yea. DNA is soft cleared at the moment.

 

[Poseidon]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

Vablakes, so you're saying eagle needs and item that combines with another and you have half of something as well as Tokyotoots? Yea, I'm not buying it. I actually believe Eagle.

@Astra I have a question. Say I pm a player saying hey I think kecleon is scum and I believe you're town, im a townie with a very useful role and I think you're town too so yea.

But that said player then quotes that post to post in game thread and changes what I say. Is that illegal just want to clear before I pm anyone lol.

I'll tell you right now that there are at least 3 different items that can combine, if not more.

 

[DNA]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

- DNA's insistence that tt is scum--again--is certainly odd since I know my boy DNA to be a man of science, and to be falling so hard for the gambler's fallacy is definitely unlike him. Maybe DNA also has some sort of investigative ability that either confirms or highly suggests that tt is scum, and that's why DNA is tunneling him so hard.

No, I just hate TT drawing scum every freaking game. It gives logic a giant middle finger and it annoys me. I know none of you are going to believe me. I have no evidence within this game that TT is scum or even non-town. I am just sick and tired of him giving everyone the slip each game.

@RogueChomp: You stated your win condition is for all cult members to be eliminated. Do you have an ability that can help you accomplish this end? say, to target a player once each night, and either kill or un-convert that player?

I honestly believe RC at this point, because for him to come clean now about it is a gigantic risk. I believe I will give him the benefit of the doubt.

Which means Tokyotoots is topclass scumbag cultlover?

 

[Kecleon-X]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

Keckleon, why does it bother you so much that im playing aggro? If im playing aggro? Only person that shouldn't like aggro play is scum. So what if the town sees it as scummy, why is that a bad thing? If someone has a reason to vote for me I won't be able to stop them lol, all I can do is hope that this town will be able to look back at my pists and really analyze them whether im town, indie, cultish or scum. Unfortunately, I haven't seen very many ppl go back and look at wagons or significant posts and piece the puzzle together. That's why town lost sheninjas game.

I don't like people playing aggro because of last game when Camoclone was lynched due to his aggroness. That action pretty much sealed the town loss because they lost a Seer Mason as well as revealing the other half-seer when he was trying to lead the bandwagon against Camo. That action in turn revealed where the Doctor was, and all of them went down in flames shortly thereafter. I don't want that to happen again this game, that's all. Just ask Camoclone; I've already spoken to him about the same thing earlier this game over Skype.

I personally think that playing aggro is harmful to town morale, as well, but that's just my opinion.

But one thing is really bothering me about you. You seem to be really excessive in your aggroness. I mean, I had an opinion opposite to yours and you flamed me for it, James also had an opinion that was opposite to yours and you flamed him for it, as well as being standoffish nearly every post. I don't know if this is a scumhunting tactic or not, but I really think that you're not being helpful when you do this. In fact it just inflames things, which is one of the reasons why Camoclone was lynched in the previous game.

 

[Professor Palutena]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

Balls I have the wrong day of the week in my mind.

Day ends in 48 hours because i'm a dorking derp.

DNA: 1 (camoclone, James86134)
grantm1999: 1 (SheNinja, RogueChomp)
RogueChomp: 8 (grantm1999, Teal, Sir Taco, TheGuy, TokyoToots, sillykyle, James86134, Keeper of Night) L-5
TwistedTurtwig: 1 (TheGuy, DNA)
Sir Taco: 0 (TheGuy)
PMJ: 0 (DNA, eagle4, Teal, TheGuy, Red Rain)
TokyoToots: 2 (SoldiersSpirit, Four Arms)

Voteless Scrubs: RogueChomp, TwistedTurtwig, Eagle4, Porygon-X, Kecleon-X, RaichuGirl, Some Loser, LuckyFire, Shocker, Blui

It takes 13 votes to lynch. Today only, if that number is not reached, a random down allied player will be killed.

 

[DNA]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

Day ends in 48 hours because i'm a dorking derp.

It takes 13 votes to lynch. Today only, if that number is not reached, a random down allied player will be killed.

You're a dorking derp? Please, tell me more.

 

[Teal]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

I know this can be seen as an extremely scummy move, but I want the priest/protector to contact me in case they decide to trust me.

 

[SoldiersSpirit]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

Me being aggro if that's what you think, should be the least of your concerns lol. I'm not that aggro right now, ask anyone about how I was in one day in sheninjas game, ill even quote info for you if need be. What exactly did I flame you for? What opinion did I have and you opposed it? Quote me or it didn't happen.

Just because I pick out things here and there from do people whom im engaged with doesn't mean im flaming them.

Me getting lynched is not a problem and won't lose the game for my faction. Camoclones lynch DID NOT lose the game for anyone. In fact, if you want to bring up in-game tactics from other games, I can bring up many things that shouldn't have or should have happened.

For example, camoclones final reads were spot on no? Did the town go back and look at hi posts then analyze from their? Nope, mistake number 1. I posted for 1 day and my mason partner was revealed as well, if he doesnt die, why doesn't town listen to machamps opinion? They didn't not too mention I had majority of the remaining scum pegged as well in one post, did anyone analyze that? Nope. Town lost because the late game town play was bad. If you don't want to acredit it to that then its because of what 3-4 town modkills?

If you wish, i'll be more than happy to talk semantics and game theory with you post game. I think this meta needs more of it to evolve gameplay. I.e. thinking there is notning to go off of day 1.

As it is right now, there's still some people who are quiet. 1 is probably a lurking wolf and will meet the minimum posting. Other than that, I'm not buying it that toots is not newbscum. Even if toots is town we get info which is beneficial.

 

[Eagle4]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

I know this can be seen as an extremely scummy move, but I want the priest/protector to contact me in case they decide to trust me.

Regarding this, can the priest/protector/bodyguard not contact Teal as it is just not worth the risk, since Teal isn't confirmed village

That is all.

 

[RogueChomp]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

No DNA, none of my abilities can unconvert or kill.

Well, I have no choice now. I'm probably going to be night killed if I live through this catastrophe.
My abilities help the town. One of my abilities is that I have a choice of three abilities- Role cop, role block, and priest. I used Role Cop last night on camoclone, and I can confirm he IS vanilla townie. I can't use role cop for two nights now, so that the ability can "charge". Same with the other two, once I use them, I have to wait two nights.

Believe me or don't, it's not my decision anymore. If I had to vote for someone ##ANNIHILATE: TOKYOTOOTS

 

[WanderingWolf]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

No one noticed this:

Today only, if that number is not reached, a random down allied player will be killed.

Meaning someone used a role for today, which led to a random townie dying if they didn't use the lynch.
I think the main possibility for this is because:
Town can't do No Lynch, and the town is very confused on Day 1.

So, today's info:

Cult Stuff:
- DNA supposedly has a role which lets him see if someone switches alignment, and allows him to stop the process.
- PMJ was tracked by DNA last night.
- DNA is using Gambler's Fallacy, which is completely out of character
- There is a cult, consisting of one person called the 'Cult Leader'
- RogueChomp's win-con is to eliminate all of the cult.

Suspicions:
- DNA thinks that Twisted is scum
- Camoclone thinks myself and DNA are scum
- Soldier thinks Myself and Kecleon are scum, and is passionate that Toots is scum
- Many think that RogueChomp is the person that should be lynched today


Affiliation:
- Soldier and Four Arms are voting the same person
- Soldier believes that the cult leader, and two scum are in the group of:
• Grant1999
• Teal
• Sir Taco
• TheGuy
• TokyoToots
• sillykyle
• James86134
• Keeper Of Night
- Kecleon and myself are on the radar because we are confused about SS and TokyoToots
- PMJ and DNA are under scrutiny for being friendly towards each other each game

This is the info that I can remember about the game... Although I'm about as observant as a bat in this game, so yeah...

-----

So, I'm going to focus a bit on SS's group of Cult Leader and Scum:

• Grant1999
• Teal
• Sir Taco
• TheGuy
• TokyoToots
• sillykyle
• James86134
• Keeper Of Night

Out of 8 people, Soldier already believes three are aligned against the town. Since he thoroughly believes that TokyoToots is scum, it crosses Toots off the list and narrows it down to two people against the town out of seven.

So, SS, since you're the best player here, care to elaborate.

-----

Also, Red Rain, read the thread. You randomly posting stuff that both does--

Wait. Has Red Rain only made two posts?

 

[Eagle4]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

I may have forgotten this or just have dismissed this, but what is the reasoning for voting TokyoToots again?

 

[DNA]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

Fine, you know what? I know none of you guys will ever join the TT wagon at this point, so I'll go do something productive.

##UNVOTE: twistedturtwig

##VOTE: TokyoToots

 

[DNA]

RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 1 ends Saturday Sept. 28 at 12pm MST

@Eagle4: TokyoToots voted for roguechomp basically out of nowhere once RC declared what his wincon was. He didn't have much reasoning for it either. Actually, he didn't have any.

That is the same reason why my vote is now on him.