Finished Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Game Over! A winner is PMJ and RogueChomp
- Thread starter Professor Palutena
- Start date
- Status
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 3 ends Saturday, October 12 at 12pm MST
Any game on PB that has items, to date, has had all thieves be town-aligned. To my knowledge, there hasn't been a wolf-aligned thief here.
Doesn't mean there isn't one, but it's not that likely. But SS put that out there in the open so I could confirm what he said was the truth. It was his choice to say it, and it was easily verified.
Any game on PB that has items, to date, has had all thieves be town-aligned. To my knowledge, there hasn't been a wolf-aligned thief here.
Doesn't mean there isn't one, but it's not that likely. But SS put that out there in the open so I could confirm what he said was the truth. It was his choice to say it, and it was easily verified.
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 3 ends Saturday, October 12 at 12pm MST
You're cruel >_<
Yea, that makes me even more inclined to believe your scum EAGLE.
Eagle4 should be lynched tomorrow. More votes on Twisted Turtwig would be nice as well..
Teal said:
You're cruel >_<
Yea, that makes me even more inclined to believe your scum EAGLE.
Eagle4 should be lynched tomorrow. More votes on Twisted Turtwig would be nice as well..
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 3 ends Saturday, October 12 at 12pm MST
I completely forgot about that, I just wanted to put something out there and picked the wrong person.
##Unban: DNA
It seems as though we don't have a lot of leads, but quite a bit of hunches. I lean towards both TT's (Toots and Twisted), and wouldn't be angry if we decided to lynch one of the two at the end of the day.
I completely forgot about that, I just wanted to put something out there and picked the wrong person.
##Unban: DNA
It seems as though we don't have a lot of leads, but quite a bit of hunches. I lean towards both TT's (Toots and Twisted), and wouldn't be angry if we decided to lynch one of the two at the end of the day.
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 3 ends Saturday, October 12 at 12pm MST
nah Eagle should be lynched today he's almost confo-scum, then we can tie him to other players.
##LETSLYNCHSCUM: Eagle4
Also we should try to figure out WHY camoclone was killed. I think that will help us.
There's seemingly no reason for his death, being confo-TV/VT, but it probably has to do with him calling the scum team. Either he hit most of the scum or none of the scum with his call, so WIFOM begins...
OR OR OR, James is scum and just got really pissed off at camoclone.
nah Eagle should be lynched today he's almost confo-scum, then we can tie him to other players.
##LETSLYNCHSCUM: Eagle4
Also we should try to figure out WHY camoclone was killed. I think that will help us.
There's seemingly no reason for his death, being confo-TV/VT, but it probably has to do with him calling the scum team. Either he hit most of the scum or none of the scum with his call, so WIFOM begins...
OR OR OR, James is scum and just got really pissed off at camoclone.
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 3 ends Saturday, October 12 at 12pm MST
um how am i anywhere near confo-scum?
I stated that it was dumb to post about giving your items away to other users in public due to the fact that there will most likely be a thief (in all the mafia games i've played in with items, there are mafia thiefs, which are really common on Smogon). That's not scummy whatsoever lol.
um how am i anywhere near confo-scum?
I stated that it was dumb to post about giving your items away to other users in public due to the fact that there will most likely be a thief (in all the mafia games i've played in with items, there are mafia thiefs, which are really common on Smogon). That's not scummy whatsoever lol.
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 3 ends Saturday, October 12 at 12pm MST
If I was really pissed off at Camoclone, in chat, I simply would have verbally assaulted him. But I didn't. I honestly only cared about his playstyle. If I was wolf, I wouldn't be stupid enough to go and say 'Lets NK camo, because I HATE him.'
Because I know, there would be repercussions, one being people calling me out like you have.
Also, Teal, shut your face. We all still have 2 more days.
If I was really pissed off at Camoclone, in chat, I simply would have verbally assaulted him. But I didn't. I honestly only cared about his playstyle. If I was wolf, I wouldn't be stupid enough to go and say 'Lets NK camo, because I HATE him.'
Because I know, there would be repercussions, one being people calling me out like you have.
Also, Teal, shut your face. We all still have 2 more days.
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 3 ends Saturday, October 12 at 12pm MST
But at the beginning of the game... You posted that logic states that we should all ask for stuff publicly.
Eagle4 said:
But at the beginning of the game... You posted that logic states that we should all ask for stuff publicly.
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 3 ends Saturday, October 12 at 12pm MST
I said that if a person is looking for a specific item, then they should claim that publically. The theoretical thief can't then steal the item from the user who claimed publically as he doesn't have the item yet. What SS has done is state that DNA has a village-helping item which will then notify the theoretical thief that they should target DNA.
I said that if a person is looking for a specific item, then they should claim that publically. The theoretical thief can't then steal the item from the user who claimed publically as he doesn't have the item yet. What SS has done is state that DNA has a village-helping item which will then notify the theoretical thief that they should target DNA.
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 3 ends Saturday, October 12 at 12pm MST
... You do realise its almost the same thing, just set back a bit.
Example:
Lets say the the person asking is Ay, the person with the item is Bee, and the thief is Cee.
Ay asks for the item on Day 1. The thief knows this and wants the item. Bee (assuming he/she's town) gives Ay the item Night 1. Then, if it helps Ay, Ay keeps it. And then on Night 2, Cee steals it and Ay decided to keep it because it benefited her. In the end, the thief ends up with it.
The scenario you're pointing out is:
Ay is already given the item, and Bee publicly states this (which wouldn't have mattered, because by now, Bee is out of the situation). Cee steals it Night 3, and then Cee ends up with it.
Eagle4 said:
... You do realise its almost the same thing, just set back a bit.
Example:
Lets say the the person asking is Ay, the person with the item is Bee, and the thief is Cee.
Ay asks for the item on Day 1. The thief knows this and wants the item. Bee (assuming he/she's town) gives Ay the item Night 1. Then, if it helps Ay, Ay keeps it. And then on Night 2, Cee steals it and Ay decided to keep it because it benefited her. In the end, the thief ends up with it.
The scenario you're pointing out is:
Ay is already given the item, and Bee publicly states this (which wouldn't have mattered, because by now, Bee is out of the situation). Cee steals it Night 3, and then Cee ends up with it.
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 3 ends Saturday, October 12 at 12pm MST
No, because by "needing an item", it's moreso about if your role states that you need a particular item which could potentially unlock a role for them, using the item up. If all else fails, a safeguard can be used to protect the person with the item, but it's still bad what SS did.
No, because by "needing an item", it's moreso about if your role states that you need a particular item which could potentially unlock a role for them, using the item up. If all else fails, a safeguard can be used to protect the person with the item, but it's still bad what SS did.
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 3 ends Saturday, October 12 at 12pm MST
I'm not defending Eagle4 here, but he is by no means 'almost confo-scum'.
camoclone was killed because the wolves know we would never lynch him, making it a higher probability we would lynch a wolf if he were alive.
grantm1999 said:
I'm not defending Eagle4 here, but he is by no means 'almost confo-scum'.
camoclone was killed because the wolves know we would never lynch him, making it a higher probability we would lynch a wolf if he were alive.
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 3 ends Saturday, October 12 at 12pm MST
Then wouldn't the item just be used up in both scenarios...
Whatever. I'm not going to argue about something I know barely anything about.
Then wouldn't the item just be used up in both scenarios...
Whatever. I'm not going to argue about something I know barely anything about.
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 3 ends Saturday, October 12 at 12pm MST
Well, if it was in a WoT (wall of text), then I think that it would be easy to skip over it accidentally. I do this occasionally, as once when I was reading "The Hound of the Baskervilles", I was reading a conversation between Watson and another man, then I accidentally skipped a paragraph and BANG, Holmes is shouting on how someone was guilty because of paint being wet.
Thanks. I guess I was missing something. >.>
SoldiersSpirit said:
Well, if it was in a WoT (wall of text), then I think that it would be easy to skip over it accidentally. I do this occasionally, as once when I was reading "The Hound of the Baskervilles", I was reading a conversation between Watson and another man, then I accidentally skipped a paragraph and BANG, Holmes is shouting on how someone was guilty because of paint being wet.
Blui said:
Thanks. I guess I was missing something. >.>
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 3 ends Saturday, October 12 at 12pm MST
For the town, it's not bad at all. In my position since im just a regular person now, I can be stronger with the knowledge at hand. On one hand, the wolves kill me...town loses nothing and they can look back at my posts to get more info. On the other hand, I know a handful of confirmed townies that I can now use for PoE and the town will eventually win.
In my eyes, its a win win. Thief stealing that item doesn't do anything but help the culists which we have to bank on luck for a seer to hit the leader of we hit the leader...
More and more though, it's like you're the mafia thief. I'm with grant...
##UNVOTE: TwistedTurtwig
##HULK SMASH: Eagle4
Yea I can t bold from my phone
Eagle4 said:
For the town, it's not bad at all. In my position since im just a regular person now, I can be stronger with the knowledge at hand. On one hand, the wolves kill me...town loses nothing and they can look back at my posts to get more info. On the other hand, I know a handful of confirmed townies that I can now use for PoE and the town will eventually win.
In my eyes, its a win win. Thief stealing that item doesn't do anything but help the culists which we have to bank on luck for a seer to hit the leader of we hit the leader...
More and more though, it's like you're the mafia thief. I'm with grant...
##UNVOTE: TwistedTurtwig
##HULK SMASH: Eagle4
Yea I can t bold from my phone
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 3 ends Saturday, October 12 at 12pm MST
There could be a Cult-Aligned thief, however.DNA said:
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 3 ends Saturday, October 12 at 12pm MST
Don't players recruited into the cult keep their
abilities or just become vanilla cult or something?
Don't players recruited into the cult keep their
abilities or just become vanilla cult or something?
- Status