Finished Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Game Over! A winner is PMJ and RogueChomp

Status
Not open for further replies.
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 5 ends Saturday, October 26 at 12PM/Noon MST

sillykyle said:
Um, how exactly does claiming help? We're fighting a cult, which means people can just send their original roles even if they've been recruited.
Click to expand...

To be fair, I'll have to agree on this one. In a game where their roles can change at any time, it makes it rather pointless late game.

Just striking an opposing opinion to get things out there, and I do not necessarily believe this wholeheartedly, but guys, what if PMJ is actually the recruiter and he's wrapping us around his finger thus sealing the win for the cult? He tells us not to kill him because he's our only hope, then we don't lynch him until it is too late when he's already amassed too many members. He's someone who claims to be unrecruitable by the cult, yes? That could mean that he's already cult, considering the fact you can't join something you're already a part of. Just saying, but I recommend that those who send in their roles should believe his claim wholeheartedly. I still am most likely going to be sending mine in, but still, I wouldn't do that until you're certain. Just a few thoughts I had on the matter.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 5 ends Saturday, October 26 at 12PM/Noon MST

Omg im not sending anyone else pms about my role. I'm a Town Vanilla which I have said repeatedly and have proved repeatedly when camoclone flipped Town Vanilla not VT like you all thought.

I clearly said there was a difference and there is, yet people keep asking me to claim. Its not hard to comprehend from my playstyle and my posts. James, ive answered your question with "it's in the game and you are the only one asking the question about me being so sure on Eagle and the answer is right in front of you". Sure I could tell you now but all it tells me is that youre either not paying attention, dont remember, cant play the game for yourself, or all of the above.

Ill be V/LA till Monday and if this doesn't count towards PMJ.s wanting roles pm'd to him, then you can shoot me. Later...
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 5 ends Saturday, October 26 at 12PM/Noon MST

Kecleon-X said:
Just striking an opposing opinion to get things out there, and I do not necessarily believe this wholeheartedly, but guys, what if PMJ is actually the recruiter and he's wrapping us around his finger thus sealing the win for the cult? He tells us not to kill him because he's our only hope, then we don't lynch him until it is too late when he's already amassed too many members. He's someone who claims to be unrecruitable by the cult, yes? That could mean that he's already cult, considering the fact you can't join something you're already a part of. Just saying, but I recommend that those who send in their roles should believe his claim wholeheartedly. I still am most likely going to be sending mine in, but still, I wouldn't do that until you're certain. Just a few thoughts I had on the matter.
Click to expand...
Man, if that were true it would be the most amazing win in PBWerewolf history. Just kidding, cult wins are never amazing.

Tell you guys what. I'm pretty sure I know who's getting shot tonight, but I won't say it publicly. This way, if I really were cult leader and not SK, I can't just claim credit the next day for a kill I didn't perform. During the night, I'll send a private message to someone revealing who I am going to shoot, and then the next day that person can verify it.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 5 ends Saturday, October 26 at 12PM/Noon MST

Unfortunately, that can easily be struck down....
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 5 ends Saturday, October 26 at 12PM/Noon MST

wee wee university

Tomorrow I will have time to read and post. And now back to writing my five page essay that I of freaking course am writing on the last day possible. \o/

AND I WANT TO PLAY DUAL DESTINIES TOO YOU KNOW! T__T ffffff
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 5 ends Saturday, October 26 at 12PM/Noon MST

Red Rain said:
Unfortunately, that can easily be struck down....
Click to expand...

How so?
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 5 ends Saturday, October 26 at 12PM/Noon MST

Well it's a really tough choice between TheGuy and that other lynch candidate, but I'm going to have to go with the first option.

##OBLITERATE: TheGuy
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 5 ends Saturday, October 26 at 12PM/Noon MST

well, somebody can come back and say that the one who you told is cult. voila, struck down.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 5 ends Saturday, October 26 at 12PM/Noon MST

Then treat me as cult, PMJ. As kecleon laid out, you could very easily be cult. If you are and everyone trusts you, we just lose.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 5 ends Saturday, October 26 at 12PM/Noon MST

All right then. I'll just go about my business.

You guys lynch whoever you like; I'll support any wagon since I dgaf who gets lynched.

Actually please by all means try to lynch me, then prepare bottles so I can bottle your tears when I live and you guys feel like morons.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 5 ends Saturday, October 26 at 12PM/Noon MST

Actually, lynching PMJ isn't a bad move right now. If he doesn't die, his claim is confirmed and we can trust him. If he dies, he was lying.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 5 ends Saturday, October 26 at 12PM/Noon MST

James, ive answered your question with "it's in the game and you are the only one asking the question about me being so sure on Eagle and the answer is right in front of you". Sure I could tell you now but all it tells me is that youre either not paying attention, dont remember, cant play the game for yourself, or all of the above.
Click to expand...

Oh, ok. I'll just go and read 1100+ posts to find reasons on why you found Eagle scummy, when you could have just told me, because you obviously remember.

Seriously. You expect me to spend 3 hours reading the entire thread when you can just tell me? Now I know why Kecleon was getting angered by you earlier.

If I wasn't paying attention, I would have voted PMJ, completely ignored the fact that he was SK, said that TheGuy and Twisted are obviously townie, Camoclone is a great werewolf player etc etc.

Do you remember all 1100+ posts in this thread with such great detail that you can recall them all with the wording each player used?

No. I cannot play the game myself. Even though I am. Its not that difficult to post your reasoning against someone again, just for clarification

OOH, OHH. ALL OF THE ABOVE. ONE OF EVERYTHING, THE ENTIRE SHOP. THE WHOLE UNIVERSE.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 5 ends Saturday, October 26 at 12PM/Noon MST

Being completely honest, my Town reads fall only to me, James, and... I wanna say ST. I could be mistaken and got that mixed up, but the latter are the only I'm sure on Town. After thinking about, James isn't doing anything relatively scummy imo. I have no idea what I was thinking earlier.
Grant is looking incredibly scummy, and nearly every post just confirms my belief in that ever so slightly.
##BURN: grantm1990
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 5 ends Saturday, October 26 at 12PM/Noon MST

Sir Taco said:
Actually, lynching PMJ isn't a bad move right now. If he doesn't die, his claim is confirmed and we can trust him. If he dies, he was lying.
Click to expand...

If I get lynched I will start shooting everyone on my wagon, cult be damned.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 5 ends Saturday, October 26 at 12PM/Noon MST

Yes, I'm so scummy in a game
WITH NO SCUM.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 5 ends Saturday, October 26 at 12PM/Noon MST

Also cultists don't want to hammer cult.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 5 ends Saturday, October 26 at 12PM/Noon MST

Sir Taco said:
Actually, lynching PMJ isn't a bad move right now. If he doesn't die, his claim is confirmed and we can trust him. If he dies, he was lying.
Click to expand...

This makes a lot of sense. And since it's better than the other option (Lynching me, whom I know is not cult), I could go for that, not only does it seem to clear someone we want to put our trust into, but also doesn't risk killing anyone helpful. Now if only PMJ wasn't crazy.

##Checkmate: PMJ

When I flip VT, remember that Sir Taco is probably not cult leader.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 5 ends Saturday, October 26 at 12PM/Noon MST

And thus, why you appear to be scummy, or culty, or whatever you like.
grantm1999 said:
Yes, I'm so scummy in a game
WITH NO SCUM.
Click to expand...

TRANSLATION: With no scum, but with a cult acting as scum. I'm sure you made extra notes about that for your pre-made defense.

grantm1999 said:
Also cultists don't want to hammer cult.
Click to expand...

TRANSLATION: Please try to kill PMJ; if you succeed, we can win. If you don't, we now know we should try to use regular scum tactics and attempt to blend in and influence the lynch vote to lynch more Town.


Now you see that he's using regular scum defenses. Not to mention he's been scarce throughout he game without good reason to be.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top