Finished Werewolf XX: Seleno City

[RaichuGirl]

RE: Werewolf XX: Seleno City - Day 5 ends Saturday March 1 at 11 AM EST

Just a hunch, but when we had the most votes for CJ, and he wasn't lynched, the wolves could have thought he was lynchproof and because of that gone after him with the nightkill.

I don't think so. See:

A side note, to clear anything up, I decided at the beginning of the day that if the number of players modkilled was greater than or equal to 5, then there would be no lynch for the day, to make things a bit more fair.

Oh yeah, I didn't see that.

I don't know why the wolves would go after CJ even if they feared his role. He was almost definitely going to be lynched today, it doesn't make sense that they'd waste a kill on him.

I suppose TheGuy is our best bet now, I'm interested to see what he posts; he seems to be keeping quiet for now.

 

[alex]

RE: Werewolf XX: Seleno City - Day 5 ends Saturday March 1 at 11 AM EST

Vote: TheGuy

Say something.

 

[TheGuy]

RE: Werewolf XX: Seleno City - Day 5 ends Saturday March 1 at 11 AM EST

Just got on for the first time today and I wish I had a way to confirm my role, however I unfortunately don't. Considering I'm not PR though, I'll claim. If anyone sends me an item I can see who sent it to me, and when I die the next night phase is skipped.

I wouldn't say that CJ thought I was confirmed wolf or else he would have said, "Vote TheGuy" or "TheGuy is Wolf" instead of asking ya'll to ask me questions. I'd also say that since CJ used his graffiti on me that would mean that he doesn't know any scum members and he's suspicious list can't necessarily be trusted in terms of whose scum, although if you're on the list and and listed as Town that does lend credibility to you.

Other than that, the only thing I have to say is that I've been playing the way that I always play.

 

[lovandra]

RE: Werewolf XX: Seleno City - Day 5 ends Saturday March 1 at 11 AM EST

What is PR?

He said 'interogate theguy', so I will ask. Who did people before who pass items to you and what are them?

This maybe important, CJ can see our 'abilities', maybe someone can use informations gotten by you. Maybe....

You still will be in suspicious' list by some people though.

 

[Kecleon-X]

RE: Werewolf XX: Seleno City - Day 5 ends Saturday March 1 at 11 AM EST

I don't know why the wolves would go after CJ even if they feared his role. He was almost definitely going to be lynched today, it doesn't make sense that they'd waste a kill on him.

I do agree; what the wolves did was rather crazy. Any experienced alpha would have waited for the whole thing to play out, and as such, buying them an entire day, so that could mean the wolves have a newb in charge?

Lovandra: PR means Power Role. Power Roles are basically powerful abilities that help the town. Think: Seer (the guy who sees people's alignments), Priest (the guy who can protect people from the nightly kill) and other roles that aid the town.

 

[GM DracLord]

RE: Werewolf XX: Seleno City - Day 5 ends Saturday March 1 at 11 AM EST

My own opinion:
For me GM DracLord is look most like a wolf. His posts shown how he keeping spaces with others, not reveal any information at all, except information that most people already known. Ohhh, except for the teddy bear, which is also clueless.

Plus, his post that is trigger suspicious to Jackal, on the first place. And he never post after that, which is make him more suspicious to me.

I can't open another tab on my iPad, but for now I agree with the lynch on GM Draclord.

1. If you notice I'm keeping space in most of the post either because I'm rather occupied with my studies or I don't have anything to add to any argument happening.

2. I don't reveal information as I don't gain them. My role isn't exactly scavaging for answer. I don't even know if there work as I don't see the result. .

3. The teddy bear issue is that by some luck it fall to my hand but is useless to me. the only other clue i know about the teddy bear is that it may have some use to a specific person. I don't want to reveal that person as I ain't confident if that person is a wolf or town. Risk of handing the bear to a wolf and the wolf get power upgrade

4. And about CJ, I only intended to get some discussion going by my post. Didn't think it will lead away so far. I reluctant to share after that post either from Reason 1 or because I'm not sure if any comment that I was writing will lead to suspicion towards me. So I choose to keep silent.

Drac usually doesn't usually make super informative posts, and honestly, the posts he's made this game seem to lean more towards town to me. I don't think he's ever been a wolf before, so I'm not actually sure how he would act as one.

5. True. I'm not really a person of giving information. Same as no.2 .

6. I do appreciate your trust.

7. That's true. never been a wolf. but probably won't act any different if being a loner wolf. That what I show when I don't have information about others (other than any post which I may not remember after a while)

 

[GM DracLord]

RE: Werewolf XX: Seleno City - Day 5 ends Saturday March 1 at 11 AM EST

Excuse the Double Posting of the same thing.. Problem with the Reply button

 

[Celever]

RE: Werewolf XX: Seleno City - Day 5 ends Saturday March 1 at 11 AM EST

I've had an idea about how the kill may have happened: What if the town has a redirector? He may have been absolutely convinced that the CJ was werewolf. If this happened he could out himself, theoretically. We have the doctor, right?

Like I have said before, today we should [v]Lynch Eron[/v] because he is pretty clear newb scum, and even CJ said that Eron was almost certainly scum. I also fancy the idea of MTC being scum, as he conveniently unvoted near the end of the day. While I understand that this may be a townie thing to do, how would he know he wan't scum? One post? That's not good enough reasoning for me, but of course he would know that CJ was not telling the truth if he was scum. I can't remember who the other one was, but his reasoning was particularly scummy for me...

 

[GM DracLord]

RE: Werewolf XX: Seleno City - Day 5 ends Saturday March 1 at 11 AM EST

If what you guys analyze of Eron is that. It pretty sure make sense.. Rather scummy aren't I voting with purely that reason. Right now I will follow the vote trend unless something proves otherwise.

Vote : Eron

If let say there's is a redirector.. how does that work

 

[Professor Palutena]

RE: Werewolf XX: Seleno City - Day 5 ends Saturday March 1 at 11 AM EST

I've still got those incriminating pictures. Coo coo.

Guy, with your role and slipping night when you die, is it only night death that can skip the phase, or would lynching you handle this as well?

Because I'm wondering if lynching you would be a good idea if it stops scum from night killing. Coo coo

 

[Celever]

RE: Werewolf XX: Seleno City - Day 5 ends Saturday March 1 at 11 AM EST

If what you guys analyze of Eron is that. It pretty sure make sense.. Rather scummy aren't I voting with purely that reason. Right now I will follow the vote trend unless something proves otherwise.

Vote : Eron

If let say there's is a redirector.. how does that work

Sorry, didn't check for a pokebeach variation of the word. Redirector is where person A targets person B like normal, but person C, the Redirector, forces person A to instead target person D. In this case, A is the werewolf, B is a random, C is the Redirector and D is CJ.

Also I kind of want a lynch on MTC... Possibly MORE than on Eron, especially as MTC is pushing for an Eron lynch. Idk your guys thoughts on this though?

 

[rev3rsor]

RE: Werewolf XX: Seleno City - Day 5 ends Saturday March 1 at 11 AM EST

Here's a post for activity. I've pretty much just woken up and I've kinda caught up on what's going on I think.
I'll be back later. Sorry for being a little inactive in general though; I try to catch up on here as often as I can.

 

[alex]

RE: Werewolf XX: Seleno City - Day 5 ends Saturday March 1 at 11 AM EST

I say we lynch TheGuy. If he's lying, we lynch a wolf. If he isn't, it doesn't even matter, because of his ability to skip the night phase.

 

[grantm1999]

RE: Werewolf XX: Seleno City - Day 5 ends Saturday March 1 at 11 AM EST

3. The teddy bear issue is that by some luck it fall to my hand but is useless to me. the only other clue i know about the teddy bear is that it may have some use to a specific person. I don't want to reveal that person as I ain't confident if that person is a wolf or town. Risk of handing the bear to a wolf and the wolf get power upgrade

Problem with this is that the wolves probably have an item thief.

Also, when did we learn this about guy's role?
Remember who originally started the eron wagon guys. With that,
VOTE: ERON

 

[Professor Palutena]

RE: Werewolf XX: Seleno City - Day 5 ends Saturday March 1 at 11 AM EST

Why is there role speculation about a redirector? Coo coo

 

[Kecleon-X]

RE: Werewolf XX: Seleno City - Day 5 ends Saturday March 1 at 11 AM EST

I say we lynch TheGuy. If he's lying, we lynch a wolf. If he isn't, it doesn't even matter, because of his ability to skip the night phase.

Yes, but that could both lose us a townie and buy us nothing but a day wasted. I disagree with lynching him until we know for certain whether or not he's a wolf.

 

[alex]

RE: Werewolf XX: Seleno City - Day 5 ends Saturday March 1 at 11 AM EST

I say we lynch TheGuy. If he's lying, we lynch a wolf. If he isn't, it doesn't even matter, because of his ability to skip the night phase.

Yes, but that could both lose us a townie and buy us nothing but a day wasted. I disagree with lynching him until we know for certain whether or not he's a wolf.

We lynch TheGuy: Possible town death, Possible wolf death

We don't lynch TheGuy: Possible wolf death, possible town death, certain town death.

There is 0 drawback to lynching TheGuy especially with there being the big possibility of him being a wolf, or at least get info from his death.

 

[Professor Palutena]

RE: Werewolf XX: Seleno City - Day 5 ends Saturday March 1 at 11 AM EST

I say we lynch TheGuy. If he's lying, we lynch a wolf. If he isn't, it doesn't even matter, because of his ability to skip the night phase.

Yes, but that could both lose us a townie and buy us nothing but a day wasted. I disagree with lynching him until we know for certain whether or not he's a wolf.

With this logic, why lynch anyone then?

The only way we know for certain who is a wolf is if they flip wolf on death. Otherwise it's a total guessing game. Coo coo

 

[Machamp The Champion]

RE: Werewolf XX: Seleno City - Day 5 ends Saturday March 1 at 11 AM EST

Also I kind of want a lynch on MTC... Possibly MORE than on Eron, especially as MTC is pushing for an Eron lynch. Idk your guys thoughts on this though?

I wasn't pushing for an Eron lynch. In fact, I think he's more likely town than wolf. His posts seem like he's trying to help. A nub wolf would probably lay much lower than Eron is. Now that you mention it, I can see why a wolf would unvote Jackal at the last minute, like alex and I did, but obviously I know that's something a townie could do, because I did it. My reasons for unvoting him are the same as they were previously, and I still stand by them. alex has come across more town like to me in general.

Problem with this is that the wolves probably have an item thief.

James was an Item Cop/Thief.

Why is there role speculation about a redirector? Coo coo

Celever thought the reason Jackal died was because a redirector hit the alpha and redirected the kill towards Jackal, because they thought they were a wolf.

I agree that there's basically no reason we shouldn't lynch TheGuy. We should still discuss on who we should lynch tomorrow, since we probably won't have any night actions between then and now. Right now, I'm not totally sure who we should lynch after words, and I have to leave soon, so I don't have time to go back and look.

 

[Celever]

RE: Werewolf XX: Seleno City - Day 5 ends Saturday March 1 at 11 AM EST

Wait, I knew that I knew this role from somewhere. In epicmafia, there is a role called the light keeper. When he is lynched there is no night phase, but the entire town goes anonymous. He IS sided with the town though.

Also why are you guys lynching theguy? CJ told us to interrogate him because he saw his role, but like MTC said James was the item thief. The mafia having two item-related roles? I don't think so... The inky way this is going to turn out is we lynch theguy, the day ends quicker, some people get mod killed and then we have another day with little to no leads, but 1 or more villagers down. I can see very few assets in this plan tbh...