Finished Werewolf XXIX: Melee - Finished!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Going purely by the vote, Vom and PMJ seem the most scummy to me right now. I'll leave this here, and will be back tomorrow.

##VOTE: Vom
 
I don't believe it was a joke but I guess sometimes jokes don't transfer through the keyboard. You attempting to stop me from making progress early in D1 doesn't buy you town cred in my mind.
 
About the reporter, aren't we at dawn in D2? I mean, he could have just wrote "see you tomorrow" to avoid confusion, I guess. But based on the fact he can give us info, it wouldn't hurt that he checks s_m and see what he finds.

simsands said:
I am almost able to say that I believe Luispipe8 to be confotown at this point. I seriously doubt that GM would throw a random vote for his scum buddy at the start of the first day. Could of course be wrong about this.
Click to expand...

Ehm...

Camoclone said:
A lot of scum players do it a lot of the time but GM doesn't strike me as the kind of player who would do that. Luis is leaning town for sure.
Click to expand...

Yeah, GM is one to avoid that type of things. I was about to say "meh, it's a common tactic", but a) It was basically hinting "I could be scum" (lol) and b) Camo beat me to it. :p

Now, Camo has a really good point on double o' squirtle (sad the new ones are usually the ones in the spotlight, right?), so:

##Vote:double o squirtle
 
scattered mind said:
No. I was trying to stop you from spamming illogical cases which leads to nowhere so other can actually post logical cases. You have made no progress with your posts on D1.
Click to expand...
Actually every single game it works. People say it doesn't but often they themselves are the ones who get caught. After all look at you. It caught us a good lead in you.
 
Vom said:
Why?
Click to expand...

Ah, right, I suppose that I needed to repeat myself for that to have been as clear as it was in my head.

I suspect Vom because he was arguing against not immediately voting GM. In this case, this was a scummy move, in my book.
 
Squirtle Squad said:
Heyyy!!! Im in this game now :)
Wish I had been subbed in for Sock! would have been a much better role than I got....

So the reporter said they would see us at Day 3's Dawn??? Seeings as its Day 2... Did they make a mistake? or is something happening Day 3?

@SilverSilent (Mr Cautious Voter) You never voted for Drac? Again though like last game with Luis is this simply cos you're hesitant? Looks suss regardless!

@simsands made a comment at the start of the game that I immediately read as scum... Ill have to flick back after work today and see what it was..
Click to expand...

There was no need for me to vote for him as everyone else already jumped on to lynching him. I also stated that I did support the lynch and I was simply looking for lynch reasons for D2.
 
I wanted to see what bbninjas was on about, but now that he's gone, (and town, too) I'm looking at double o squirtle. He's got random sort of behaviour and I'm sure it's not because of super laggy internet, in case the excuse is made. His responses seem delayed in a way that seems like he wants to keep attention away from certain scumbuddies, imo.

##VOTE double o squirtle

Come on, give us some information. Why?
 
@scattered mind Because one, I have university and it's not easy to say anything, and two, there was really nothing of note when I first posted in D1... and anything that could have been of note later on was disregarded by GM's accident. It was a rather quick D1, too.

Since I'm leaving pretty soon, I'll try to see if I can put together a post after I get back.

Oh, and seriously, you should all stop falling for Camo. He never gets results, you're the ones giving them to him, so you can stop saying his playstyle is bad. It's simply sick for a game in such a forum. I told the same to Jeremy last game.
 
I kind of saw this coming honestly, I'm really curious on what bbninja's had in terms of information. Oh well, no use in pondering over it now. Anyway, #Vote: Yeowie

Random voting go. Also,
simsands said:
Going purely by the vote, Vom and PMJ seem the most scummy to me right now. I'll leave this here, and will be back tomorrow.

##VOTE: Vom
Click to expand...

PMJ acted like this last time he was town so I still believe them to be town.

If anything it makes you look a little suspicious in my opinion.
 
Is @simisands really arguing that we should have left GM alive longer so that he could have poured wine all over the town? Honestly, there is almost no point to letting almost-confirmed scum stay alive longer. What did you expect him to "slip"; another sideboard screenshot? He was as good as dead and anything he would have said would only have been WIFOM to mess with the town. I'm not going to vote you for this because it's just poor play and not actually scummy, but seriously.
 
##VOTE: double o squirtle

I see no reason not too follow this, however...

simsands said:
Going purely by the vote, Vom and PMJ seem the most scummy to me right now. I'll leave this here, and will be back tomorrow.

##VOTE: Vom
Click to expand...
Weren't you also flippy on Drac's lynch yesterday? Why do Vom and PMJ seem so scummy to you?
 
Simisand originally voted for Drac but unvoted because he felt we were lynching him too quickly.
 
Athena said:
Is @simisands really arguing that we should have left GM alive longer so that he could have poured wine all over the town? Honestly, there is almost no point to letting almost-confirmed scum stay alive longer. What did you expect him to "slip"; another sideboard screenshot? He was as good as dead and anything he would have said would only have been WIFOM to mess with the town. I'm not going to vote you for this because it's just poor play and not actually scummy, but seriously.
Click to expand...

Knowing what we know today, I can't say what he could've slipped. Considering his ability, his scum buddies would obviously not reveal as mason to save him. We did not know this yesterday, though. However, if GM had an ability that they wanted to keep, this wouldn't have been way too unthinkable. Also, if GM had said the name of the inactive person he was talking about, I would be ready to consider that person town. I believe that he would give us the name of an innocent inactive who wouldn't be able to deny it, to make that person look scummy the next day.

Camoclone said:
PMJ only acts like this as town (see last game). I suspect that he is town this game as well.
Click to expand...

SilverSilent said:
PMJ acted like this last time he was town so I still believe them to be town.

If anything it makes you look a little suspicious in my opinion.
Click to expand...

Which is why I chose to vote Vom over PMJ. Any other questions?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top