Finished Werewolf XXIX: Melee - Finished!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Again, I want to know why you think finding a scum is a waste of time.

If someone claimed to be his mason partner, then we would now know that person is scum. That is not a waste of time. We do now know that his scum buddies wouldn't have done this, true, but we did not know this yesterday. That in itself does not make it a waste of time.
 
At this point I'm not sure if simisands is being obtuse on purpose for some reason or if he legitimately is not reading our posts.
 
Are you not reading my posts? I've been asking you to explain, because I don't understand what you're getting at.
 
We have already explained and are tired of re-explaining. I give up.
 
Camoclone said:
FYI It is past RVS. And it doesn't work if you tell them it is a random vote.
Click to expand...

Fair enough.

simsands said:
Again, I want to know why you think finding a scum is a waste of time.

If someone claimed to be his mason partner, then we would now know that person is scum. That is not a waste of time. We do now know that his scum buddies wouldn't have done this, true, but we did not know this yesterday. That in itself does not make it a waste of time.
Click to expand...

They're trying to say is that even with the slip, he would of most likely not given that information up. The reason this is because if he was lynched and came back scum (which he did,) then you'd have a solid lead to another mafia member. GM would most likely not have went that far and instead chose to take the hit for the team. Besides, that could of been played as a double edged condition. What if GM posted a town's name? Now you'd been out of two townies in no time flat. So why not jump on GM since it's more than likely that we wont get any information. Besides, if we didn't lynch him, we would of been at risk for lynch a sure townie and be down two people.
 
SilverSilent said:
They're trying to say is that even with the slip, he would of most likely not given that information up. The reason this is because if he was lynched and came back scum (which he did,) then you'd have a solid lead to another mafia member. GM would most likely not have went that far and instead chose to take the hit for the team. Besides, that could of been played as a double edged condition. What if GM posted a town's name? Now you'd been out of two townies in no time flat. So why not jump on GM since it's more than likely that we wont get any information. Besides, if we didn't lynch him, we would of been at risk for lynch a sure townie and be down two people.
Click to expand...

I think I mentioned what if GM posted a townie earlier. Anyway, point taken.
 
I think the scum team was probably too busy facepalming at their teammate's slip to care one way or another about how fast the lynch went.
 
Hey! I'm here! Been flat out all day...

Well @simsands you are easily my biggest scum read right now... Everything in the last few pages has certainly added to this!
Though you aren't quite playing how you did last game which is interesting...

My question is, why did Drac not just claim??
When he was lynched, his one post of defence was as if he didn't really care?

It was like a big stab in the dark. his defence was so weak! No role claim whatsoever! Does this suggest anything about scum safe claims? or did Drac give up because his claim didn't have a QT?

##vote: simsands
 
Ok, I've been trying to keep up with everyone this day period but I'm lost. I was very suspicious on EM during D1 so I am going to place my vote there for now.

##VOTE SQUIRTLESQUAD

Although SS is going to obviously play differently to him, I still think EM was scum.
 
Slow down pineapple! I'm not EM! As has been mentioned by everybody else previously...

Also does anyone have any thoughts on SilverSilents comment that he left on @bbninjas profile post?

Bb posted about being killed really early in the game and SS2 posted "There, There... etc..."

Now whilst this isn't outside communication, does this suggest anything about his alignment??

I know when TGK posted on my wall last game about killing me N1 in PMJ's game, I posted "No hard feelings" because I knew as the scum team that I was fully intending to murder him brutally that night.

Just saying!
 
These are who I think are scums so far:

Yeowie - Bandwagon twice without doing anything else to contribute. Similar to his play style from last game where he was scum and not similar at all to the game before that when he was town.
simsands - I already said why I think he looks scummy.
double o squirtle - Ignores the votes on him. Didn't vote for the obvious lead we had on GM.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top