Finished Werewolf XXX: Future in Stasis - GAME OVER! Town Wins! Now w/ Postgame analysis!

Status
Not open for further replies.
If he didn't think he was expecting suspicions why would he not "nightmare"?
He had less necessity to do so. It might also have drawbacks if used successfully, which is common with indies who have win condition roles they can use every night.
 
People make assumptions. I'd call his role a special-doctor if he is telling the truth.
No, it's a special safeguard if anything. Doctors exclusively protect kills, whereas safeguards protect from other roles.

Of course, safeguards are surprisingly uncommon on this site, so RF might not have known the distinction. Hmm...
 
No, it's a special safeguard if anything. Doctors exclusively protect kills, whereas safeguards protect from other roles.

Of course, safeguards are surprisingly uncommon on this site, so RF might not have known the distinction. Hmm...

It's a hybrid of doctor and safeguard. Nightmare most likely kills the user so it can be seen as both if I understand it correctly.

Anyways, it is most likely not a slip because the ability could be seen as confusing as it has both elements of doctor and safe guard.
 
No. It implies he is relatively inexperienced. It seems exactly what he'd do if he is telling the truth.
It also is exactly what he would do if he's faking the situation, and the latter is far makes much more sense, because for the former to be true Reinforce would have also had to make the same mistake.
It's a hybrid of doctor and safeguard. Nightmare most likely kills the user so it can be seen as both if I understand it correctly.

Anyways, it is most likely not a slip because the ability could be seen as confusing as it has both elements of doctor and safe guard.
If it protects a lethal action it's a doctor. If it protect a non-lethal action it's a safeguard. Personally I think Nightmare makes the most sense as a silencer of some sort, which makes the flavour odd to me. The flavour of the Nightmare block in the update also talks about someone being on the verge of sleeping and waking back up, which doesn't slot in with Drowzee's claimed ability.
 
It also is exactly what he would do if he's faking the situation, and the latter is far makes much more sense, because for the former to be true Reinforce would have also had to make the same mistake.
No he wouldn't slip and say doctor.
 
The flavour of the Nightmare block in the update also talks about someone being on the verge of sleeping and waking back up, which doesn't slot in with Drowzee's claimed ability.
Flavor is very weak. Never go based off flavor.
 
It also is exactly what he would do if he's faking the situation, and the latter is far makes much more sense, because for the former to be true Reinforce would have also had to make the same mistake.

If it protects a lethal action it's a doctor. If it protect a non-lethal action it's a safeguard. Personally I think Nightmare makes the most sense as a silencer of some sort, which makes the flavour odd to me. The flavour of the Nightmare block in the update also talks about someone being on the verge of sleeping and waking back up, which doesn't slot in with Drowzee's claimed ability.

I realize this, but I say that due to the fact of we don't know what Nightmare does. Hence why I said it could be hybrid, though most likely not in reality.
 
Why not? It makes a lot of sense for him to make the mistake since a safeguard hasn't been present in a game since he's been playing on this site IIRC.

That's the point, he may not the experience to sort out Safe Guard type roles. In all honesty this could be seen as a doctor role as you don't know what Nightmare does. For all we may know, Nightmares could be what kills. This isn't likely but you have to realize, he may not have the experience to realize that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top