Still subjective. Of the 31 posts you quoted there, less than a third of them quote on quote "focus on EM". I think there was also plenty of valid reasons to post about EM. Getting confo-townies to post can also be an extremely townie thing to do.
Not really. Active lurking isn't a sign of "lazy town", it just means that they have restricted time. When you don't have a lot of time, you prioritise what you talk about. This is why he might have commented on some topics a lot and others less so.
You haven't really talked about mord this game according to my notes. This doesn't mean you're scum, it just means you felt there were more pressing topics to post about. Same logic applies to Luis.
Piggybacking can also just be saying your opinion but later. It depends how much reasoning they also provide and other variables. You have to take into account that these games aren't necessarily live.
Nono, a lot really isn't an overstatement. I could do it with you, me, Camo, scattered, Prof P, KX, Vracken, mord and Jabber for sure because I've already got decent notes on all those players, and I'm always scummy :U. I could definitely do more, too.
And the more a player posts, the more material you can use against them. No one has a perfect game. Everyone does lots of minor scumtells each game, which is why I don't give your case a lot of credit. All you did is list a bunch of subjective theories and minor scumtells, which mean very little.
