Silentslayer said:I don't want a type that messes with other pokemon type
I just want a new type like Jhoto introduced Steel and Dark without altering Kanto's pokemon.
Just a new type with new Pokemons
safariblade said:Because the current types are already balanced enough. If we added new types now, the ratio of Pokemon of each type would be dumb. We have like, what? 250 water types or something? And then we will add 10 new pokemon of a type? That's silly. And changing a previous pokemon and adding a type doesn't help either, it just complicates things and will make trading pokemon to 6th Gen weird. I haven't even mentioned moves yet. We would have to add a ton of new type moves or change 'roar', 'uproar', 'metal sound', etc to sound-type or whatever and once again it doesn't make any sense and it would confuse things and mess with which moves get STAB, etc, etc, the whole thing would be a huge mess. Pokemon is not going to want to deal with that and I don't blame them.
So what? So you want everything to stay the same? Pokémon get and lose moves every generation. What's wrong with changing STAB moves, types of existing Pokémon etc.? We have seen it happen before anyway.safariblade said:Because the current types are already balanced enough. If we added new types now, the ratio of Pokemon of each type would be dumb. We have like, what? 250 water types or something? And then we will add 10 new pokemon of a type? That's silly. And changing a previous pokemon and adding a type doesn't help either, it just complicates things and will make trading pokemon to 6th Gen weird. I haven't even mentioned moves yet. We would have to add a ton of new type moves or change 'roar', 'uproar', 'metal sound', etc to sound-type or whatever and once again it doesn't make any sense and it would confuse things and mess with which moves get STAB, etc, etc, the whole thing would be a huge mess. Pokemon is not going to want to deal with that and I don't blame them.
Teal said:So what? So you want everything to stay the same? Pokémon get and lose moves every generation. What's wrong with changing STAB moves, types of existing Pokémon etc.? We have seen it happen before anyway.
Uuuuh, like, what? Like an old sticker says that Exploud is Normal type instead of "Sound"? Oh no! You think GameFreak seriously cares about something like that if they really want to introduce a new type?MistahFuji said:given all the work that would be involved at this stage with every single bit of Pokemon merchandise (not just the vgs obviously)
It's going to be changed and affected by the new generation anyway in many forms:MistahFuji said:how competitive play would be affected.
GameFreak has changed sprites midgeneration, sometimes even three times. Is that not also "a lot of extra hassle needlessly"? That's a really weak (invalid) argument.MistahFuji said:It's a lot of extra hassle to put on themselves needlessly.
Teal said:Uuuuh, like, what? Like an old sticker says that Exploud is Normal type instead of "Sound"? Oh no! You think GameFreak seriously cares about something like that if they really want to introduce a new type?MistahFuji said:given all the work that would be involved at this stage with every single bit of Pokemon merchandise (not just the vgs obviously)
It's going to be changed and affected by the new generation anyway in many forms:MistahFuji said:how competitive play would be affected.
- New Pokémon
- New type combinations
- New moves
- New mechanics?
- New items
New types? Type changes? Why not? They need to balance everything anyway.
GameFreak has changed sprites midgeneration, sometimes even three times. Is that not also "a lot of extra hassle needlessly"? That's a really weak (invalid) argument.MistahFuji said:It's a lot of extra hassle to put on themselves needlessly.
I'm not saying that there will be a new type, but ruling it out is pretty stupid.
Btw. the TCG just introduced Dragon-type in 2012.
safariblade said:Because the current types are already balanced enough. If we added new types now, the ratio of Pokemon of each type would be dumb. We have like, what? 250 water types or something? And then we will add 10 new pokemon of a type? That's silly. And changing a previous pokemon and adding a type doesn't help either, it just complicates things and will make trading pokemon to 6th Gen weird. I haven't even mentioned moves yet. We would have to add a ton of new type moves or change 'roar', 'uproar', 'metal sound', etc to sound-type or whatever and once again it doesn't make any sense and it would confuse things and mess with which moves get STAB, etc, etc, the whole thing would be a huge mess. Pokemon is not going to want to deal with that and I don't blame them.