My tiebreakers got WRECKED by drops; my provincials finish might have actually been _better_ if my high rated opponents didn't drop, as I ended up around the middle of the 4-3s instead of near the top. They really ought to adopt a more serious rating system.
Also, crm, that's about right - they get a free in from somewhere then just hold their rating. I know players like that, and there are times where I wonder just what goes on behind the scenes in competitive pokemon...more than is currently being talked about, that's for sure.