Most of the active players have learnt to scumhunt as scum, so I was wondering who you’re most suspicious of out of those who scumhunt?
How do you plan on doing that? It would require a watcher/tracker claim (not recommended) or possibly a Dragon Slayer, since it appears that the Dragon Slayers have a self-watch directed towards fellow Dragon Slayers.
Clarifying, I meant his actions in the thread, interactions. Speaking of which...
I think he saw bb close to being lynched at some point and wanted to put his vote there and push him over, and possibly hang him. There's no other reason.
No reason at all. This actually makes me think he was being coached in a scumchat to not put his vote on someone like bb so suddenly, and so he moved it abruptly. This is of course very reachy but it's all I can make out.
FL, if you're reading this. I cannot emphasize this enough, always always ALWAYS give reasons! Every action you do needs to have a reason, and by withholding that reason you are willfully going against the town, and that is scummy.
- Ability which aren't able to be use in Night 0 are specifically mentioned in that ability or if I have personally PM the person.
Oops! I was kind of busy with stuff for Big Brother 3 towards the end of Day 1, and kept viewing the thread in short bursts, but didn't have enough time to really make a post or even place a vote. I would have voted Gekki though for that lie.
Yup, I know, but people who don't scumhunt are more likely to be scum in my opinion. If you are Town, you must look for people who seem suspicious, it's the only way fot the Town to eliminate Mafia and there is no reason for not doing it.
I do agree with this.
Look at FL. He clearly didn't.
If someone did Track FL last night or N0, though, keep in mind that whoever FL targeted is almost confirmed town.
Well, as I metioned, I took a quick read on the whole Day 1. I didn't find any of the most active players suspicious, by this I'm referring to Quaking, Lorde, NP and BB. I see their efforts to find out who is scum and all of them have logical arguments.
FL wasn’t active though.
Aqua’s behaviour is different imo, as I don’t think he would have voted me had he realised we were not playing trials. That does remind me, though, that I had intended on bringing up something I thought was scummy about him.
I already mentioned this back http://www.pokebeach.com/forums/threads/mafia-xlvii-the-new-era-fairy-tail.145486/page-9#post-2917260’]here[/url], and was actually waiting for a response which we never got.
Drac, did Morda notify you he was going to be away? Because he is less active than Lorde and Quaking but you didn't mention him in the above lists...
I personally think Nick is a bit more scummy than TLS at the moment. I do think he should have known how to play better, from the events of last game, and TLS is a completely new player. Unfortunately, reads are pretty shaky at this point in this point in the game, so I'm not too confident in Nick flipping scum.
Agreeing, but because Nick is giving away signs of knowing a bit how to play, but still held a grudge as a read.
I agree with previous players, Nick is more scummy than TLS, I think I warned him about posting fluff here. TLS hasn't done much of anything in thread besides speculate about a stolen vote. While that isn't helping, it fits the recent newbie mentality that's blatantly fixed on survival over actually helping the town. So I'm still neutral on him.
Ladies and gentlemen it looks like we're building a case. I may do an ISO on him later, for now I'm a bit busy. Ideally I wish there was more from him to make more steady judgements, but there isn't, and we haven't heard many other names tossed around.