Finished Mafia XXXV: Pokemon Card GB3: Team GR's Last Stand

Status
Not open for further replies.
I did this in Mafia 33 and no one really made a big deal about it. However, my role then worked differently so it could be different here.
The main reason that no one really went after you (the way I saw it) was because you were new. Morda's fairly experienced so it's different here.
 
Here's Morda's ISO.
Isn't tagging kinda like telling someone to come and see things? Maybe react to that? I think Excal only reacted to that. And that makes Jesi a liar by saying, who could this be?

@quakingpunch73 Don't have time to defend yourself? It seems like you are just ignoring that post?
Here, Morda echoes what several members have already said.
Edit: ##vote: PikaMasterJesi
And then tacks on a bandwagon at the end.
##unvote PikaMasterJesi
From the first pages i read quakingpunch is now the suspect? I am still reading the rest of the pages.
After reading, he sees that Jesi isn't the main target for and unvotes her.
The reading part itself will take about 20 minutes. Now at page 13. But I have to eat first so in about an hour I can finally post again.
This post isn't too relevant.
In the quote above you could do math. So that is obviously lying or am I wrong and can't i do math?

This could be a card effect.
I made a superlong post (for me) but i noticed a lot of people already said the things I wanted to say, and I don't understand the part where camo jumps in and votes Jesi. Can someone explain that? Ouch, my head hurts from all the thinking. :(
Afterwords, he says that he has things to say, but deletes it because everyone else had already said it. Never refrain from contributing, as anything helps. You could have noticed something we haven't. Deleting or refusing to share your thoughts comes off as scummy.

And for those reasons, I've voted Morda.

I like how Jesi hasn't contributed at all even though she's posted more than anyone else. I also like how when she makes a statement she attempts to cover any way that she thinks we will think she's scummy.
I feel like this sums up Jesi decently. She's scummy, but not my first target today.
 
Quick response to Celever before I reread the scattered case.

Fishing out responses is a bit different. Scouting for poor responses by applying fake pressure is alright in the early game, but actively trying to make a player slip up by giving them an awkward post to respond to is manipulative. I don't think that KX not responding to one or two of your points is scummy as it is something which all players do from time to time if they are awkward points to respond to, or simply because they didn't think they were important to respond to. Personally I think the parts of your case which you are claiming are your strongest points are your weakest. Not playing optimally doesn't mean that the player is scum, and it usually means the inverse. Your case boils down to "with hindsight, this would have been a bit better", and that's not a case. I said this in my last post and you didn't respond to it, even where you addressed me calling your case terrible a bit further down your post -- does this make you scum? Because that's the main reason why you think KX is scum. Maybe I wasn't super clear enough for you but... neither were you.
Well I disagree about being manipulative... but looking at the case again, it sorta is a lot of hindsight. :/

And town keep their options open too, it's not just a scum thing to do. KX is always somewhat enigmatic in this regard.
Really? I guess that I don't do that much, at least consciously.

Seriously, the main part of my post is that your case boils down to "his play wasn't optimal" as well as you being manipulative with how you framed your case. You didn't answer one of the main points of my post, therefore you are scum, yes? That's your logic on KX, so it should work here too.

What are you even holding out on now? The stuff about Excal? The part of your case is the worst part. There is no fathomable response, and I don't know what you're expecting from him.

Was he actually posting in this time, though? You're acting like the guy on snapchat who gets annoyed at someone for ignoring them when they haven't even opened their snap -- I'm pretty sure he just wasn't around, or that he didn't see a major reason to fill us in on his suspicions. It's fair enough.

But your strong stuff appeared to be your weaker stuff. If KX didn't have enough time and/or willpower to respond to everything in your post, I would have also responded to the stuff he did. I don't think there is a response he can give about Excal because he didn't do anything wrong in the situation.
And this is all makes a lot of sense...

Yup, I'm gonna drop that case. ##UNVOTE: King X
 
Can someone explain how scattered's questioning this game is any different to is past games? I recall him doing a lot of questioning, but not all of it will always be particularly contributional.

Otherwise, I think the defense is awful. While, yes, some of Camo's "translations" are twisting scattered's words, but not all of it. He has some good points. Active lurking (loosely) and bangwagoning in particular. I think this is the only post where scattered defends without going on about "twisting", but it doesn't feel like he's defending against the case as a whole.

And for those reasons, I've voted Morda.
How are these things different to how morda normally plays?
 
Can someone explain how scattered's questioning this game is any different to is past games? I recall him doing a lot of questioning, but not all of it will always be particularly contributional.
It's questioning without contributing anything himself.
 
Here's Morda's ISO.
I do have to agree that morda's behavior so far has been...questionable, although his playstyle here is very reminiscent of how he was in Grima's Rebirth. I also have to agree on your point about him deleting his thoughts on whatever it was, as it hasn't really stopped anyone else in doing the same.

With scattered I see where his questioning seems to have no contributional factor to them, but I feel like it could be caused by the inactivity happening and with suspects being kinda low due to the same reason.
 
Hey TGK instead of trying to make a new, incredibly weak case without commenting on why it is needed, could you share your thoughts on scattered please?

Like if scattered flips scum you should be next, that play was awful.
 
Fine, whatever.

##UNVOTE: Mordacazir
##VOTE: Scattered Mind

Camo's case is solid and Scattered hasn't been contributing as much as previous games, which is extremely unusual.
 
GM Drac got subbed out.

##UNVOTE
##VOTE: thegrovylekid

OMFG that was backpedal of the millenium. What even. And a bandwagon, since you provided no reasoning. xD
No, Drac subbed IN for excal.

Knew this would happen. Anything I could post would actually just have been called out for echoing camo, so there was really nothing I can do. That's what happens when you're always called out as scummy, everyone!
 
No, Drac subbed IN for excal.

Knew this would happen. Anything I could post would actually just have been called out for echoing camo, so there was really nothing I can do. That's what happens when you're always called out as scummy, everyone!
You can't brush it off as meta "I'm always scummy" because I took great care to remain objective with you. This is the first time I've really commented on you this game. Echoing is fine, it's not a major scumtell unless it's all you do. It's more important to see what parts of the case you signify as being the most important to you.

So uh, go do that.
 
Fine, whatever.

##UNVOTE: Mordacazir
##VOTE: Scattered Mind

Camo's case is solid and Scattered hasn't been contributing as much as previous games, which is extremely unusual.

That was faaaar too quick to comply to Celever's "command". ##VOTE: TGK
 
Firstly like a usual day 1, Not much of the discussion will be relevant to me so I cant interpret much since I dont know what was on aura mind when he made all the previous post so a fair warning dont judge my action based on his.

I djust nt remember if tgk is always like this or he just seem rather pushy today.. I would have vote for that reason but that would show me as wagoning
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top