Finished Mafia XXXVII: Celever's School Grades ~ Game Over!

Status
Not open for further replies.
TheAnticipationEevee said:
I believe Robin is at L-2 now?
Click to expand...
You'd be correct.

TheAnticipationEevee said:
You altered the words of the ability to save yourself from a lynch. Please explain @Robin Aisaga
Click to expand...
My theory's that as scum, Robin was afraid of getting lynched Day 1, so as a last-ditch attempt, he used his Night 0 results to pin PP as scum, which worked. Could no one else tell that wasn't Celever's writing? No host in their right mind would confirm someone's neighbour to be scum, and Celever has helped host games before, including the last one (^v^). I only jumped on that train because there was no saving PP, and even he wanted out.

Like I said last day, why would Robin have an ability that shows him other abilities? What use would town have for an ability like this? They would only need to know alignments, not abilities.
 
PikaMasterJesi said:
You'd be correct.


My theory's that as scum, Robin was afraid of getting lynched Day 1, so as a last-ditch attempt, he used his Night 0 results to pin PP as scum, which worked. Could no one else tell that wasn't Celever's writing? No host in their right mind would confirm someone's neighbour to be scum, and Celever has helped host games before, including the last one (^v^). I only jumped on that train because there was no saving PP, and even he wanted out.

Like I said last day, why would Robin have an ability that shows him other abilities? What use would town have for an ability like this? They would only need to know alignments, not abilities.
Click to expand...

I did notice that PP and Robin posted the ability with different wordings, so one of them clearly had to be lying. However, both of them lied ? (They both changed the "may" to a "must"?)
 
PikaMasterJesi said:
You'd be correct.


My theory's that as scum, Robin was afraid of getting lynched Day 1, so as a last-ditch attempt, he used his Night 0 results to pin PP as scum, which worked. Could no one else tell that wasn't Celever's writing? No host in their right mind would confirm someone's neighbour to be scum, and Celever has helped host games before, including the last one (^v^). I only jumped on that train because there was no saving PP, and even he wanted out.

Like I said last day, why would Robin have an ability that shows him other abilities? What use would town have for an ability like this? They would only need to know alignments, not abilities.
Click to expand...
While it is unlikely and doesn't make much sense to have a neighborixer confirm scum it wouldn't be something unheard off.

Role cops are fairly common on both town and scum.
 
TheAnticipationEevee said:
I did notice that PP and Robin posted the ability with different wordings, so one of them clearly had to be lying. However, both of them lied ? (They both changed the "may" to a "must"?)
Click to expand...

What do you mean "you did notice" it was because of the differences in their ability claims that PP was lynched in the first place...
This is dumbtelling.

Camoclone said:
Oh shoot. There goes my vote for today.
Click to expand...
Firstly you used punctuation so you lied? Or just stuffed up...
secondly only one vote today??
 
Probably just echoing everyone at this point, but Robin Aisaga needs to explain or he's getting lynched under LaL. I really would like to see this resolved before moving on to other possible suspect scum.
 
Squirtle Squad said:
What do you mean "you did notice" it was because of the differences in their ability claims that PP was lynched in the first place...
This is dumbtelling.


Firstly you used punctuation so you lied? Or just stuffed up...
secondly only one vote today??
Click to expand...

I noticed before the lynch, (and I think I posted about it too, but just got ignored?) that PP and Robin posted Gaydar, and had slightly different wordings. PP's had "however" in the last clause if I am not mistakened.

I thought PP was lynched because he and Robin doubled claimed abilities on each other and based on the wording of their (now proven false) ability, one of them had to be scum.

They are both lying as everyone knows now though. Im confused why PP also changed the wording from "may be scum to will be scum"?
 
##VOTE: Robin Aisaga

Either Celever lied or you didn't inherit Gaydar at all. Splain, Lucy.
 
Okay stop guys, please, please hear me out.


I didn't want Professor Palutena to be lynched... We could've been partners. Wether he was scum or town he could help me out. And now you're thinking. Oh my, Robin is a huge liar! And I am, you could lynch me solely for that. However there was a possibility that has not been considered yesterday and this possibility is the truth. I'm town just like Palutena. I have the exact same ability as Palutena, I never received it through another ability. I was under the impression that Palutena could be scum. My lynch was almost about to happen. I knew I was town, so what choice did I have but to let Professor Palutena be a victim first? He could've been scum. I will show you my entire claim even though that may result in my night kill. Instead of ending the day quickly, we should look for other leads. Do we really want to lynch another town member after our last loss? That would hurt town a lot. Don't let the scum influence you. They surely are the ones that want to make my lynch happen as soon as possible. You could say things escalated day one, but PLEASE don't be responsible for lynching another town. The info below is all you're going to get from my dead, and that certainly won't help us progress.

You are Drama.

Celever wanted to take drama as one of his subjects, but his school cancelled it in his year because they’re jerks. Regardless, theatre is an amazing artform and one which is criminally undervalued in modern day society. You need to prove society wrong!

Active: Gaydar
Drama is a stereotypically “gay” activity, and though stereotypes are usually totally wrong, in this case you really are fabulous. Being gay in school is a minefield, and you’ve been separated from the only other gay in school! Every night, including night 0, until you find your partner, please PM Celever “Night X -- Ask [user1] if they’re gay”. If you correctly identify your partner, a mason chat will be initiated between you. Your partner may be a part of the mafia team, however.

Active: All Eyes On Me
Gurl you’re fabulous and you’re gonna make all them basics know it! At night you may PM Celever “Night X -- Give an Oscar-winning performance for [user1]”. user1 will be so fixated on your heart-wrenching drama they will totally forget about visiting their original target to use their night action. However, this will result in them using their ability on you instead. This does not affect the nightkill, as murderers are heartless and don’t care about true talent.

Win Condition: Eliminate all subjects who endeavour to stop Celever getting back into 6th Form.
 
OK, why does everyone want the day to end so soon? Even if Robin is most probably scum, there are more than one scum, so we should use the day to try and find leads for D3. If you are going to lynch Robin now, you go to D3 with empty hands.

@TheSceptileMaster , I see you posted so that means you are still playing. Then why do you ignore my question?
 
Knowing Celever, you probably are town, but I still want to lynch you. I'm not prepared to take that chance.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top