Finished Mafia XXXVII: Celever's School Grades ~ Game Over!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah, but what else am I supposed to do? Let myself get lynched for what I see as stupid reasons? I guess I could try to ignore it, but then someone's just gonna be like "Oh, why didn't you comment, she's scummy because she didn't comment". I'm a typically self-aware person.
You're at something like L-6 and you're making a big scene of it not even 24 hours into the day.

It's a problem that you're panicking this much without much provocation.
 
I guess I am. I just don't like being called out for stupid reasons, like how mentioning exiting RVS ended up getting me a vote. >_<"
 
They is town. I thought that'd be clear. Also, if I were scum, why would I just say something like that out in the open? Even I would know better, and I always seem to look scummy. I wouldn't want to dig my hole deeper.

Mistakes happen. A slip is a slip.

I mean, you and Camoclone have plausible reasoning, so I just went with it.

But there was barely any reasoning.
 
You're dodging the question.

What makes the reasoning plausible?

When you commented about not voting = scum, it makes sense because if scum doesn't vote it can potentially increase their "innocence" because they were not apart of the lynching of another town member.

Then Robin replies about scum hunting without being obvious. Doesn't commenting that you ARE scum hunting already make it obvious enough?

Robin also seems dodgy of Camoclone for whatever reason too.

@Robin Aisaga please elaborate about the stuff you posted on page 9 :)
 
The key thing is I would like to see elaboration from Robin as they were kind of contradicting/unclear.

Well, it's unclear what's unclear... -__- What do you want elaborated? The first couple of statements I noted were just matters that may be considered slightly curious. My reasoning shouldn't be too hard to follow. And what's ''went with it'' supposed to mean? I don't recall any lead or evidence that says ''Robin Aisaga is scum'' I explained the part about scum hunting because I was asked. I would have prefered if I didn't had to.
 
Jesi's acting very similar to how she acted in the last game she'd played. However, I expect her to learn from her mistakes (e.g stating that the RVS is over, which is exactly what happened last game she played and she was also called for it), especially after almost every time someone accused her she said she will learn for the next time. So this might be her trying to act like she played last game as town, and use ATE ("I always end up looking scummy").

@PikaMasterJesi - What do you think about the points on Robin?
 
Well, it's unclear what's unclear... -__- What do you want elaborated? The first couple of statements I noted were just matters that may be considered slightly curious. My reasoning shouldn't be too hard to follow. And what's ''went with it'' supposed to mean? I don't recall any lead or evidence that says ''Robin Aisaga is scum'' I explained the part about scum hunting because I was asked. I would have prefered if I didn't had to.

Nobody ever had solid evidence to say you are scum (or anyone else for that matter).

You can respond to Camoclone's post about the freaking out part, rather than ignoring him.

You can also explain how you can scum hunt without being obvious because that doesn't really make sense (especially when you also post that publicly).

But at least you aren't completely ignoring the thread.

##UNVOTE for now.

@Reinforce would you like to join the conversation too! :)
 
@PikaMasterJesi - What do you think about the points on Robin?
There's not really much to go off of, but I think they're interesting. Gonna try to write a small case in this post.

@double o squirtle

Well, there isn't much to discuss about in this early phase. There are only a few things I find worth noting:

- Squirtle Squad is hinting towards a weak role, it's still very early for that.
- Palutena has a rather curious first post..?
- BBninjas and Jesi are toying with the new players.
- Camoclone and Ice Espeon leave just two comments, (un)vote and then leave.

I'm probably not voting anyone today either.
Like PP said, not voting hinders town. Without town votes, scum could easily make the lynch whatever they want. Are you waiting to hammer on the last day, and are just saying this to avoid suspicion? Also, "not much to discuss"? @Robin Aisaga, what are your thoughts on the votes on and behaviours of Inferno and TSM?

I will scumhunt but I don't like to make it too obvious. And let's be honest, the chances of there being a good and convincing case during the first day is not something to expect. That's why I said I'm 'probably' not going to vote.

Oh and hey Camoclone, welcome back. Thanks for the convincing case and stuff.
I said this before: Not obviously scumhunting does town no good. The town needs every possible lead they can get. I can also taste the sarcasm so strongly from here. You seem very annoyed in this line. I do also think Camo would've elaborated more than he did, though, so that's a little strange...
In addition to this, you sound like you're reluctant to scumhunt. Possible tell?

Well, it's unclear what's unclear... -__- What do you want elaborated? The first couple of statements I noted were just matters that may be considered slightly curious. My reasoning shouldn't be too hard to follow. And what's ''went with it'' supposed to mean? I don't recall any lead or evidence that says ''Robin Aisaga is scum'' I explained the part about scum hunting because I was asked. I would have prefered if I didn't had to.
Reading this post, I don't think you read this:
@Robin Aisaga please elaborate about the stuff you posted on page 9 :)
You dodged his question here. What evidence do you have from those points I have conveniently quoted at the top of this post? Why are those relevant? Why should we be looking further into those instead of you, or TSM, or me? Are they scumtells?

Right now, I'm feeling unsure about my vote on TSM. Switching it for now.
##Unvote
##Vote: Robin Aisaga

Please answer the questions I've presented to you.
 
There's not really much to go off of, but I think they're interesting. Gonna try to write a small case in this post.

You dodged his question here. What evidence do you have from those points I have conveniently quoted at the top of this post? Why are those relevant? Why should we be looking further into those instead of you, or TSM, or me? Are they scumtells?

Right now, I'm feeling unsure about my vote on TSM. Switching it for now.
##Unvote
##Vote: Robin Aisaga

Please answer the questions I've presented to you.

I explicitly explained how PP's Reasoning is logical and why I voted in the post you quoted??? Or am I missing something?
 
That was before I started analyzing Robin. TSM may still be a good option, but right now I want to see what Robin says after what I've seen.
 
I don't know TSM's alignment. I'm just firm on my current read. Gonna keep an eye on Robin though.


I don't think this is helpful to town. They need every lead, and if it doesn't look like you're scumhunting, you could get under fire for it.

I noticed the "They" need every lead and thought the same thing, but the part I'm actually suss on is the "you could get under fire for it" to me it seems like she's warning her fellow scum buddy to start scum hunting or he'll get called out for it.

Yeah, but what else am I supposed to do? Let myself get lynched for what I see as stupid reasons? I guess I could try to ignore it, but then someone's just gonna be like "Oh, why didn't you comment, she's scummy because she didn't comment". I'm a typically self-aware person.
Self aware is bad, but if I recall, in all the games I've seen of Jesi she's been this Same way so there's not much to gain from this.

Why is that? You were very confident he is scummy.
This!

##vote: @PikaMasterJesi
 
Here how about you analyse this @PikaMasterJesi :

##VOTE: PikaMasterJesi

I gotta sleep now, maybe you could use some of that so called patience, something that's very rare among Werewolf players...

Also in the meantime you could present your last two questions as actual questions, or perhaps make alternatives with less gibberish :p
 
Mind sharing your reasons behind the vote?

I may go into more detail later, but the main reason is that Jesi looks out of characte in this game. Jesi also talks as if she's not part of Town. And Jesi votes any target she's presented with :/ Now I really gotta sleep, long day ahead. Yes I got to work on sunday, love my life.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top