Finished Mafia XXXVIII: Battle for the Republic (Congratulations Darth Sidious!)

Status
Not open for further replies.
And no I'm not trying to use a role as scum if so I would've put something else up there.
just realized this coulda been put a different way, I mean if I were mafia I'd use a random role that I don't even know of, if not, I'll use mine.
 
I'd also like to clarify that my "top scum reads" aren't exactly strong this game. They're about 60% scum, 40% town. It may not appear that way, but that's just how play.

I just had another look at Rainy's posts, and there is a bit of an improvement curve going on: Not Contributing ----> Reasonless Votes that aren't RVS ----> Sheeping without reasons ----> Giving reasons. However, there are confusing stuff like this randomly thrown about that cause him to jump all over my scumdar. And anyone that jumps all over my scumdar is scummy. This is my biggest problem with him.

I'll also just make it clear why I voted for Rainy in the first place. Rainyman made this completely out-of-the-blue vote on myself that basically didn't make sense. It was not because of the "rooting for scum" thing.
So your vote on him is largely an OMGUS to an extent?


I don't really get what you're trying to say here. If TSM is doing the same stuff as rainy, and if you read rainy as town, then why is TSM scum?
Rainy's actions are explained easily as new town. As far as I'm aware, this isn't TSM's first game so this doesn't apply to him. He should know better.

Also, am I the only one who found this part of Rainy's claim odd?
I actually hadn't saw this so thanks for bringing it up.

It's peculiar because it has no reason to be there. Assuming scum have safe claims (which is standard practices), rainy has no reason to edit his role PM.

3. Edit the name to Kid Fist-yo.
Why did you do this?
 
So your vote on him is largely an OMGUS to an extent?



Rainy's actions are explained easily as new town. As far as I'm aware, this isn't TSM's first game so this doesn't apply to him. He should know better.


I actually hadn't saw this so thanks for bringing it up.

It's peculiar because it has no reason to be there. Assuming scum have safe claims (which is standard practices), rainy has no reason to edit his role PM.


Why did you do this?
because o thought it was funny :D
 
So your vote on him is largely an OMGUS to an extent?



Rainy's actions are explained easily as new town. As far as I'm aware, this isn't TSM's first game so this doesn't apply to him. He should know better.


I actually hadn't saw this so thanks for bringing it up.

It's peculiar because it has no reason to be there. Assuming scum have safe claims (which is standard practices), rainy has no reason to edit his role PM.


Why did you do this?
No not really. I didn't vote for him because of the root for scum thing in which he voted for me. I did it because I thought he was scummy at the time for reasons I now forget. However I'm not even voting him now.
 
Raniy's claim is edited, but knowing how he plays the rest of the game, it's not that scummy. And after seeing what Prof P said, I'm not sold on his lynch right now. The policy lynch argument is stupid (since he said he was going to try to help), and him not learning can be interpreted as a sign of newness. @rainyman123 If we leave you to tomorrow, you need to learn from your mistakes and listen to us. You also need to cut the AtE and not use WIFOMy reasoning to say you are "obviously" town. I'm only leaving you because you vowed to improve and you are playing to your meta. Get scum hunting.
##UNVOTE: Rainyman123
Aside from that, TSM is gaining spotlight. I think the case just revolves around him parking his vote on rainy? Sounds very standard TSM to me, so I don't think it indicates alignment.
This looks like some slight buddying to me. TSM has only played one game, and it was as scum. We don't know his town meta at all, so saying it's the same just makes the case better. His lynch could provide good information too, especially on you.
##VOTE: TheSceptileMaster
Jesi is scummy, but she is normally scummy. However, I'd say she's been doing certain things a bit out of the norm (i.e. sitting on the fence).
This also looks strange to me. Jesi is aggressive, but she is also pretty non-committal at times. Sitting on the fence fits her early game meta a lot.
 
Okay, I wasn't expecting a claim this early.
Kid Fist-yo (Kit Fisto)

Alignment: Republic (Jedi)

A newly promoted member to the Jedi Council, your Force abilities at delving into the minds of others are fearsome. Due to this, Mace Windu asked you to accompany him to the Council to bring the Separatists to justice.

Active Ability: Jedi Mind Trick
Using the Force you are able to convince others to do whatever you'd make them do. Every Night Period you may PM me to 2 names. Any Active Ability used by the first name will be redirected to the second.

Win Condition: All anti-Republic aligned players are eliminated.
I've looked back at this, and I think the "PM me to 2 names" part is a little strange. However, the grammar seems to match up with SS's for the most part (at least going off memory).
3. Edit the name to Kid Fist-yo.
Why did you do this?
because o thought it was funny :D
Uhh...
1) You don't outright state that you edited a claim...
2) Well, being funny just makes your situation worse. I'm not even sure what to say.

TSM's vote park and insistence on a policy lynch is pretty strange, especially since he hasn't contributed since he placed that vote (and yes, I know this has been said already.)

##Unvote (just in case)
##Vote: TheSceptileMaster
Why haven't you contributed? Do you still think Rainy is the best lynch? If not, then who do you think should be lynched?

Only post I'm gonna be able to make tonight, as I've got a giant school project due tomorrow and I'm not finished it. >_<"
 
1) You don't outright state that you edited a claim...
I did call him out on it already.

We just need two more votes (or an unvote from Rainy onto TSM) to change the lynch, IIRC. That's not counting any possible vote weight modifiers.

Unless, of course, TSM puts up an adequate defence. I'll reiterate that Rainy has been actively trying to improve so a policy lynch isn't a good reason.
 
Okay, I wasn't expecting a claim this early.

I've looked back at this, and I think the "PM me to 2 names" part is a little strange. However, the grammar seems to match up with SS's for the most part (at least going off memory).



Uhh...
1) You don't outright state that you edited a claim...
2) Well, being funny just makes your situation worse. I'm not even sure what to say.

TSM's vote park and insistence on a policy lynch is pretty strange, especially since he hasn't contributed since he placed that vote (and yes, I know this has been said already.)

##Unvote (just in case)
##Vote: TheSceptileMaster
Why haven't you contributed? Do you still think Rainy is the best lynch? If not, then who do you think should be lynched?

Only post I'm gonna be able to make tonight, as I've got a giant school project due tomorrow and I'm not finished it. >_<"
hope you do good on that test! Gonna agree that "PM to me to 2 names is a little strange" not saying that o wrote it, I copy+paste. However, I think he meant it "pm to me up to 2 names". Just a little Grammar Hammer for those of you who get the reference
 
Anyone who's vote parked on Rainy right now is seriously scummy and should be lynched tomorrow unless they provide a good explanation.

Especially if they've been Vote Parked for more than a day and don't post here.
 
Anyone who's vote parked on Rainy right now is seriously scummy and should be lynched tomorrow unless they provide a good explanation.

Especially if they've been Vote Parked for more than a day and don't post here.
Or to be specific, @Lord o da rings @TheSceptileMaster @Robin Aisaga and @scattered mind. Cmon guys be active! Agreeing with grovyle here I think it's pretty scummydyummy that you haven't posted in awile and still have your votes sitting on me. And I only weight like no that much :D. Sceptilemaster I'd understand why you would keep your vote on me but to the others post! I know there are other of you who have posted, but these three have just voted and did nothing. If you wanna win, post!
 
cause him to jump all over my scumdar
how much did you buy this scumdar for? How do I "jump around" on it? I feel it's anything like a regular radar, it must be broken. But please explain how your scumdar works. I want to know why you think I'm the best lynch candidtate even after everything said.
 
Day 1 Vote Count:

rainyman123 6 (NinjaPenguin, lord o da rings, TheSceptileMaster, scattered mind, bbninjas, PikaMasterJesi, thegrovylekid, Robin Aisaga)
scattered mind 0 (simsands, )
Scorched Feathers 1 (quakingpunch73, )
Vracken 0 (Robin Aisaga, )
NinjaPenguin 0 (TheSceptileMaster, PikaMasterJesi, )
Lord o da rings 0 (thegrovylekid, bbninjas, thegrovylekid)
PikaMasterJesi 0 (Jabberwock, bbninjas, rainyman 123)
Jabberwock 1 (bbninjas, simsands)
bbninjas 1 (Jabberwock, rainyman123)
thegrovylekid 0 (rainyman123, Vracken)
Blakers 0 (thegrovylekid, )
TheSceptileMaster 6 (Professor Palutena, Vracken, rainyman123, thegrovylekid, NinjaPenguin, PikaMasterJesi)

There are 16 players still alive therefore 9 votes are required to lynch.

Current Lynch candidate(s) bolded. Both @rainyman123 and @TheSceptileMaster are at L-3.

In the event of a tie a randomiser will determine the lynch.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top