Finished Mafia XXXVIII: Battle for the Republic (Congratulations Darth Sidious!)

Status
Not open for further replies.
I seem to have trouble keeping up the thread while posting, so I'll just stop reading, and start posting. If my comment does not make sense because of a later post, that would be me not reading that post yet.


No, only if there's no alternative/until we get a good lead on someone. Does that make sense?

Yes, it does.

I also apologize for being a little inactive, my stance on Rainy hasn't changed thus I will vote for him, be careful not to hammer if you want to continue discussion. In my opinion the amount of posts shouldn't be taken too much in account. I think that the argument that BBninjas is playing scummy because he posts a lot is nonsense. I don't see him trying to control the situation or something like that. Looking back at SceptileMaster's last post made me suspicious. He ''just'' wants to lynch Rainy and that doesn't sit right with me. He just left after making that post.

Actually, that TSM play really reminds me his play style last game where he was scum.. and Rainy is scummy imo for saying bb talks too much, but that is scummier than TSM, I think.

##UNVOTE:
##VOTE:TSM


If I can't get a lynch on TSM, I'll vote for Jesi. I legitimately think rainy isn't scum.

Why? Because he is a new player?

After sleeping on it followed by reading through the thread again, Rainy's reading more lost new townie to me. My main gripe with him was that he wasn't responding to any questions, but he is now and his responses don't seem scummy.

##UNVOTE: Rainyman123

gonna read back and cast a vote for who I think the scummiest player is.

What about TSM?

And at @Professor Palutena im not Excalibur you're what you mean by quote me role pm but I'll tell you I'm a good guy. Kid fist-yo i think. (I know who he is) but I'm not sure we can quote our role pm.

That's a little suspicious. It's like you were guided to say that to gain new town cred. Why do you think that you can't do that? The game rules says you can quote.

The puff says I am kid fist-yo. I couldn't quite put it in quotes as it already was but

Kid Fist-yo (Kit Fisto)

Alignment: Republic (Jedi)

A newly promoted member to the Jedi Council, your Force abilities at delving into the minds of others are fearsome. Due to this, Mace Windu asked you to accompany him to the Council to bring the Separatists to justice.

Active Ability: Jedi Mind Trick
Using the Force you are able to convince others to do whatever you'd make them do. Every Night Period you may PM me to 2 names. Any Active Ability used by the first name will be redirected to the second.

Win Condition: All anti-Republic aligned players are eliminated.

My character.

ok. Redirector.. What was your interest to "at least stay until night 2"?

I don't get this post?

I just forgot to put quotes. Keep scrolling down, I fixed it.
 
However, this part here almost makes it sound like bb's trying to use this lynch to clear Jesi's name.. Depending on Rainy's flip, I may want to look into these two.
To clarify, if Rainy flips scum I think Jesi is more likely scum. If Rainy flips town I think Jesi is more likely town.

Because i wanna friggin play the game to at least night 1.
That doesn't really answer my question... >___>

I'm trying to figure why you are so confident that posting your role means you're town. The thing is, there is such things as safeclaims. It sounds like you didn't know these exist, and hence why you were confused when people didn't unvote you after you posted your role. It sounds like you didn't read the rules properly from your past questions, so if you didn't know about safeclaims, then I think you're town. (Unless you're very good at playing dumb.)

So your vote on him is largely an OMGUS to an extent?
No, and you should know that's not what I was getting at.

Rainy's actions are explained easily as new town. As far as I'm aware, this isn't TSM's first game so this doesn't apply to him. He should know better.
TSM isn't the sharpest tool in the shed, so basically I don't think he would know better.

No not really. I didn't vote for him because of the root for scum thing in which he voted for me. I did it because I thought he was scummy at the time for reasons I now forget. However I'm not even voting him now.
I did not vote you because of the "root for scum" thing. I already said that. Also, didn't you say that you voted me because I post a lot?

This looks like some slight buddying to me. TSM has only played one game, and it was as scum. We don't know his town meta at all, so saying it's the same just makes the case better. His lynch could provide good information too, especially on you.
##VOTE: TheSceptileMaster
See my response above to PP. And, yes, it can give good information now since all the discussion surrounding TSM and rainy; I agree.

This also looks strange to me. Jesi is aggressive, but she is also pretty non-committal at times. Sitting on the fence fits her early game meta a lot.
Are you sure? I could be wrong, but I'm pretty sure I'm not. :/

@Lord o da rings @TheSceptileMaster @scattered mind @bbninjas @Robin Aisaga

Do you guys have any reason for voting on Rainy besides the Policy Lynch, which Rainy has shown he's actually tried to improve upon.
Jumping all over the place (improves, then goes back to how he was), and more recently, contradicting himself on why he says he voted for someone.

----

Ugh, I'm not too sure right now. I'm not going to go with my gut and continue voting for rainy; instead I'm going to trust the judgement of PP on this one. ##UNVOTE; ##VOTE: TSM.
 
Actually, that TSM play really reminds me his play style last game where he was scum.. and Rainy is scummy imo for saying bb talks too much, but that is scummier than TSM, I think.

##UNVOTE:
##VOTE:TSM

Did TSM park his vote and "really want" the lynch to happen in this last game?
 
That's a little suspicious. It's like you were guided to say that to gain new town cred. Why do you think that you can't do that? The game rules says you can quote.
I'll chalk it up to you not reading, but rainy's displayed quite the ignorance of game rules to the point where I don't think he read the OP. He wasn't even sure how many votes he could cast.
 
Aside from that, TSM is gaining spotlight. I think the case just revolves around him parking his vote on rainy? Sounds very standard TSM to me, so I don't think it indicates alignment.

TSM only played one game.. where he was scum...
 
I know it sounds weird, but from what I would imagine town TSM to be like based on what I've seen him post, the stuff he was doing seems pretty standard. If that makes sense.
But since we only know his scum meta, it's only standard for his scum meta.
 
But since we only know his scum meta, it's only standard for his scum meta.
Based on what I've seen him post elsewhere on the site too. How is his play this game similar to his play this last game? I only payed half-attention to this last game after getting killed N1, so I may be missing something.
 
Based on what I've seen him post elsewhere on the site too. How is his play this game similar to his play this last game? I only payed half-attention to this last game after getting killed N1, so I may be missing something.
Half-attention is more than I paid.

Scattered, could you fill us in please?
 
TSM used to come in once in a lifetime, echo one of the popular cases or vote for one of them, and then disappear for another long period. Also, it may be worth noting that he was often absent from the scumchat, appearing once in a while.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top