So, just took a quick skim over simsand's earlier posts, and it reminded me that a lot of his early play was fairly passive (asking questions) and didn't really comment on major things that are happening. It pinged my scumdar then, but I didn't really bring it up cause it can be a legitimate scum-hunting depending on their play during Day 3 and 4. Since simsands was pushing for lynches then, I'm going to put down their passive questioning to scumhunting as oppose to "trying to look like town".
That really only leaves the aggressive push on Robin when the other wagon was on scum, for me. I don't think that's enough to lynch someone on its own, especially since simsands could still be right on Robin (although I don't think Robin is scum). The other thing that pings my scumdar is the fact that there isn't really anything that simsands has done that is particularly townie (iirc), which is strange. But still not enough for a lynch.
##VOTE: PikaMasterJesi She's my other scumread for a number of points already mentioned by Vracken and a few others. Jesi was defending rainy for a bit until they voted them while not think they were scummy (strange in its own right). quaking was also defending rainy in a similar way, and while not a major thing, it's more important considering the other scummy stuff. There's also this, which could be scumbuddying. Jesi aslo tends to not attach herself to wagons yet subtly push them this game, which is standard scum play. I'll have to find the specific posts later when I have time. Finally, there's that hammer scenario, which I mentioned already, it doesn't seem genuine to me.
I think there's a few things that have been, or could be, brought up against Jesi that I think are neutral, so I thought I might mention those. She doesn't always prioritise Mafia over other things. She says she has been quite busy with school, but she clearly has time to be active in the Skype chat and to make her various art pieces. I think she got lynched as town before due to a similar inconsistency. I also think she did got around apologising for her absence and not contributing much else in another game as town, but I can't remember that clearly.
I think that @Robin Aisaga and @PikaMasterJesi both should claim, since it looks like the lynches are going to be pretty close and either could get lynched. I think we need have as much information to go off as we can, for both now and for future.
That really only leaves the aggressive push on Robin when the other wagon was on scum, for me. I don't think that's enough to lynch someone on its own, especially since simsands could still be right on Robin (although I don't think Robin is scum). The other thing that pings my scumdar is the fact that there isn't really anything that simsands has done that is particularly townie (iirc), which is strange. But still not enough for a lynch.
##VOTE: PikaMasterJesi She's my other scumread for a number of points already mentioned by Vracken and a few others. Jesi was defending rainy for a bit until they voted them while not think they were scummy (strange in its own right). quaking was also defending rainy in a similar way, and while not a major thing, it's more important considering the other scummy stuff. There's also this, which could be scumbuddying. Jesi aslo tends to not attach herself to wagons yet subtly push them this game, which is standard scum play. I'll have to find the specific posts later when I have time. Finally, there's that hammer scenario, which I mentioned already, it doesn't seem genuine to me.
I think there's a few things that have been, or could be, brought up against Jesi that I think are neutral, so I thought I might mention those. She doesn't always prioritise Mafia over other things. She says she has been quite busy with school, but she clearly has time to be active in the Skype chat and to make her various art pieces. I think she got lynched as town before due to a similar inconsistency. I also think she did got around apologising for her absence and not contributing much else in another game as town, but I can't remember that clearly.
I think that @Robin Aisaga and @PikaMasterJesi both should claim, since it looks like the lynches are going to be pretty close and either could get lynched. I think we need have as much information to go off as we can, for both now and for future.
