No, Jesi or SF are not on my list because they didn't do anything particularly scummy this game. And I don't expect Rainyman123 to write a full case but a little more than what he posted now should be expected from town players new or not. Who is your main candidate for today's lynch BBninjas?
He doesn't really show much interest in anyone besides Rainy. After bb says that he wants to lynch Robin in the following post, he disappears and doesn't appear until a couple days later.
##VOTE: rainyman123
I also apologize for being a little inactive, my stance on Rainy hasn't changed thus I will vote for him, be careful not to hammer if you want to continue discussion. In my opinion the amount of posts shouldn't be taken too much in account. I think that the argument that BBninjas is playing scummy because he posts a lot is nonsense. I don't see him trying to control the situation or something like that. Looking back at SceptileMaster's last post made me suspicious. He ''just'' wants to lynch Rainy and that doesn't sit right with me. He just left after making that post.
He then shows up and puts Rainy at L-1.
Rainyman's claim has two mistakes in it. It doesn't look like a legit town or safe claim. He could be indy. I don't find that unlikely and I want to find out. I also don't think Rainy is more helpful or trustworthy as SceptileMaster who was only there to discuss the policy lynch and went inactive later on. Everyone changing their votes to SceptileMaster is actually a bit scummy if you ask me. Also TGK's relation to Rainy is rather dubious. Rainy's lynch could really give us some handy info and leads. But it doesn't seem like it's going to happen so I might as well unvote...
I also think Blaker's comment is noticeably scummy.
Him assuming that Rainy would be indy is odd, and could potentially be a slip, if Robin knew that Rainy wasn't mafia.
Man I was just about to post something... And I do check Pokébeach often even when I don't have time to post.
I already suspected Double Suspect could give town something similar to another lynch. So I'm glad I voted for the senate order
I should've placed my vote on Rainyman yesterday once Blaker's claimed his role. Could it be that yesterday's last minute lynch was the work of scum/indie? Ninjapenguin and Jabberwock do you think it was the right call to let Blakers be lynched instead of Rainyman by the randomiser?
This post is filled with attempts to get town cred. Complaining about the lynch. It's been repeated multiple times, but Robin had a lot of time to do something about it, if he didn't like how things were looking.
Yes that's why I regret not voting for Rainyman
Ok? You could call it unnecessary. Your post may posses the same purpose it doesn't really have much to say either. Don't you have something to say about yesterday, the senate order or the night kill?
This sounds like he's confused over why the NK didn't happen and is trying to fish for why it failed.
Constant requests? Dude... I only asked Scattered Mind if he had anything to say about the night kill. And those other two things you mentioned simply are not true. You really seem to be pushing it and that is scummy. I will vote place my vote on you later if you stick with these vague arguments.
Here he's threatening NP to unvote him. Also OMGUS.
I didn't pay enough attention at the remaining time and the vote count. I was planning to place my vote but I didn't get the moment. And sure it takes 15 seconds to write "##VOTE: Rainy" but placing a vote without anything to add is always taken the wrong way by other players. My checking thread / posting behaviour hasn't changed that much I think. Maybe you haven't been monitoring my profile like in other games so you came with a different conclusion.
He's being overly cautious. A blank vote is not necessarily bad, especially at the end of the day, when there's plenty of reasons that have already been presented.
PikaMasterJesi, I get that school is a priority, but if you have time to make a small post like the one above. Please give us something that is slightly contributional even when it's just one small read.
I agree with BBninjas that QuakingPunch is a better lynch candidate for today. I for one don't think TGK's claim was a made up. I have to believe he used some kind of common sense when he claimed no Jedi was targeted by an ability. Any one of us could've proven him wrong. But TGK probably thought it was save because the message came from Squirtle Squad.
Some fair points have been made against QuakingPunch. But I admit the case he made on NinjaPenguin has some merit. So far NinjaPenguin has only been pushing lynches on players that flipped Jedi. quakingpunch's behaviour does seem out of place though. What convinced me he is likely scum is the sudden claim. And that ability he has looks too strong. I'm going to place my double vote and that will put quakingpunch in the red zone, be careful if you don't want to end day 4 early.
##VOTE: quakingpunch73
He's going along with the quaking wagon, but is still trying to give him some town points. This is also the second time he's put someone close to a lynch, this time very early on in the day.
Hm okay fair point. He could vote himself to end the day.
##UNVOTE
Then he backpedals when he's called out for it.
Playing slightly on the offensive side is part of my playstyle, I don't recall that to be different from previous games. That's also why I hear panicking and nervous a lot. But in reality I'm sitting behind my desk quite comfortably.. Also I don't think my counter arguments were to be called OMGUS. it's not like I immediatly wanted to push a lynch on NinjaPenguin. I didn't agree, so I spoke up.
That's also why I will point out your scummy behaviour. To me it looks like you're trying to ignore the case on quakingpunch. ''His ability could be indie'' is not going to clear him. Did you read his ability? He trains at the Jedi Temple. Would you rather lynch a player that looks suspicious or one that looks scummy because of their claim, contradictions, lies and facts.
I have a good feeling about quaking's lynch. Thus I will replace my vote. ##VOTE: quakingpunch73
Once again, he starts attacking the players who are accusing him. He then proceeds to put quaking in hammer range, attempting to cut the day short.
##Unvote
##Vote: Quakingpunch73
Thanks for answering my praise to end the day early, Jesi.
We later on see that this is exactly what quaking wanted.
Tunnel vision much? I haven't heard simsands discuss anything but my lynch since day 3 & 4. If you read back on day yesterday you will realize just how aggresive simsands is acting, which is not very town like. Why do we not discuss inactive players? Too many players don't open their mouth and that's only a convenience for scum. I've made myself pretty clear yesterday but that seems to be ignored. Those points simsands presented yesterday look like an attempt to help quakingpunch.
##VOTE: simsands
Once again I don't fully understand why I'm suddenly a target. There's not much to defend about behaviour.
Some more OMGUS.
Since scattered asked me to, I went through some old games and looked for Robin's previous reactions to pressure.
@Camoclone is that sarcasm, ouch
I agree with Celever. I don't see a very strong case there TGK. It looks like you're trying to save your own, I understand that. I'm doing it as well, Nothing personal but here goes my first vote:
(I don't want to use my ability this early) Sorry if that's scumtalking and or AtE but I kinda like doing that
##VOTE: Thegrovylekid
Not sure if I still like this game however...
I'm of to sleep now. Time Zones in my disadvantage I guess. Thanks Clever and Scattered mind for your words. I don't feel comfortable going to sleep without activating my ability though. Sad times...
They weren't kidding when they said: everything you say may be used against you in court
EVERYTHING I SAY IS WRONG ARRGGG. why am I still replying.
Good good, although
someone still seems to have a tunnel vision -____-
Now please let me lurk for a while. I'm getting more nervous with every word I type
*Hides
You say I'm just clarifying matters about the serie to appeal to Phoenix Wright fans, I'm not. What use would it have to appeal to two or three people. Getting to know roles has been quite useful so far. By knowing Dahlia Hawthorne was also capable of spirit channeling we could have prevented Mia and Maya from exploiting their role to her for example. And another example is the apparant thief figure. As in Ace Attorney there are several thiefs (Kay Faraday, DeMasque and Filch) None of them have a murderer role in the AA series. This will certainly be useful information at some point. Also your stating that I'm trying to be popular as a fact, you don't speculate much do you?
And yes, the role high prosecutor isn't entirely clear. No one else has been confirmed town either though. So I don't see the point in mentioning it.
In Order in the Court, he was often joking things off, he's acting a bit sarcastic and frustrated.
I will scumhunt but I don't like to make it too obvious. And let's be honest, the chances of there being a good and convincing case during the first day is not something to expect. That's why I said I'm 'probably' not going to vote.
Oh and hey Camoclone, welcome back. Thanks for the convincing case and stuff.
Here how about you analyse this
@PikaMasterJesi :
##VOTE: PikaMasterJesi
I gotta sleep now, maybe you could use some of that so called patience, something that's very rare among Werewolf players...
Also in the meantime you could present your last two questions as actual questions, or perhaps make alternatives with less gibberish
Oh, I LOVE scum hunting <3 Now that is out of the way, be my guest and make up some more reasons to vote me that simply are not true. Also you do realise that certain attitudes can be used for scum hunting?No?
I'm not mad, I'm absolutely FABULOUS
You asked me what my stance is on Bandwagoning.
Ideally, a player should always explain their vote instead of simply agreeing with one or another. But when someone is in a tricky situation or lacks time and motivation to make their own case, it is a tempting thing to do. So, in my opinion it's certainly not a good habit, but I can see why it happens. And just because someone is a hypocrite shouldn't mean they may not attend other players for similar mistakes.
But you Camoclone are the master of hypocrites! Just remember what you said to Eevee. I have three votes for the record including yours.
##UNVOTE
##VOTE: Camoclone
In Celever's School Grades, he did reveal later on that he was playing an act, but we still see the same sarcasm from the previous game. There is a slight bit of OMGUS against Camo, but it doesn't feel a bit like the "I'm not scummy, you are!" act he's been doing this game.
So, points against Robin(/Reinforce)
- He's playing carefully. Overthinking his actions.
- He's panicking from pressure and attacks the players pressuring him.
- Attempts to end the day early at multiple occasions.
- Tries to get town cred.
- Fishing for information.
- Potential early game slip.
Did I miss anything? Since Robin isn't here anymore to defend, I'd appreciate more thoughts/opinions instead.
