RE: Pokemon Journey Through Life, CHAPTER 5 IS ON ITS WAY!!
Well, having re-read that last chapter, I can say you seem to have done a similar thing to me... you've built things up a lot before truly getting to any "action". The plane thing was cool, don't get me wrong. But "action" in these fics tends to involve the pokemon rather than other things
. But basically, you've gone for a good foundation before truly setting off. This is a great sign to me - it shows that the writer is actually thinking about the story, rather than creating lots of senseless "drama" that don't gel together at all. Good!
Right, onto my criticisms. They aren't THAT plentiful, but they do exist. I'll give a list for your convinience
1) You should put spaces between paragraphs. It makes things a LOT neater upon reading, and it generally helps the flow of the story.
2) If a character talks, and you're going to have them do something afterwards (even if it's describing HOW they talked), you need to have a comma before the last speech mark. I know this sounds INCREDIBLY Grammer Nazi-ish, but it's true. That comma slows the pace of reading down slightly, allowing for more time to absorb what is going on. One quick example:
Monkeyking63 said:
"So where you guys from" asked Ellen as the plane was landing.
Calum's corrected version said:
"So where you guys from," asked Ellen as the plane was landing.
There was also one clear point that you missed your speech marks, but that's not OVERLY criminal, unless you're going for total perfection
3) Be careful which version of words you use when. It's common to misuse words like "Their" and "too", but watch out for it.
Monkeyking63 said:
The three were surprised they were being honored for doing what there gut told them to do
Calum's corrected version said:
The three were surprised they were being honored for doing what their gut told them to do
4) It might just be the style of your fic, I dunno, but it MIGHT be an idea to try and avoid most of the common shorthands that you see in internet writing. Not lol and those, things like these:
Monkeyking63 said:
"ya we probably should of went to our seats" said Ellen as they were trying to get up.
Well what do I have to lose, o ya, 100 lives.
Not to stop you using them if they fit what you're going for, but it's a casual observation. My last quote also brings me to my final (for now) point I want to make.
5) There weren't many examples of this, but be careful of run-on sentences. Saying too many things in a single sentence makes things confusing for the reader to understand.
Monkeyking63 said:
Well what do I have to lose, o ya, 100 lives.
Calum's corrected version said:
Well, what do I have to lose? Oh yeah... 100 lives.
This is the only one I could find off-hand.This may be the only one, I don't know, but watch out for them all the same!
Well, that's my analysis so far. You told me you wanted "brutal", so that's what I went for. I hope you can take positives from the criticisms I noted - they ARE designed to be constructive. I also DID note good things as well, so it's hardly all doom and gloom
I also noted that you used MS Word, like me. HOWEVER, be careful of editing your posts with this in mind. Pokebeach has a nasty habit of wrecking your quotation marks, hyphens, apostrophes AND ellipses; it replaces them with squares... You'll need to edit your whole post to repair this if you want to edit anything there. Alternatively, you could do something I haven't done yet - edit the word document and re-copy it over the top of your first post.
I think your time for build-up in this story is done though - now is the time for action. That's talking the obvious, but I reckon that you have a decent start and need to progress that start with some good action scenes
Good luck with this once your break starts