RE: Pokemon Top Design - Challenge 1 is up (Crystal Pokemon)
I need Martainia, Rotom479 and MiniPika12 to submit their cards.
Overall Impressions: They were very well done. Spelling and proof reading should be double checked though.
Rankings are
1st Place (tie) - XKurami93X and Apophys with 38
3rd Place (Tie) - Daren and MS Eevelution with 37
5th Place - Dr4g0n with 36
6th Place - Kingdra King with 33
7th Place - Vencargo with 31
8th Place - Muddy68 with 28
9th Place - Light Venusaur with 22
As of now, the people up for elimination are
Martainia
Rotom479
MiniPika12
Info for this round
Daren – Infernape
Concept: You can easily tell it is a Crystal Pokemon. The energy types all made sense here. 10/10
Picture: Very well described, and it fits Infernape. However, nothing told me that it was a Crystal Pokemon. 8/10
Attacks: Dynamic combat was worded really strange. 4/5
Top Stats: All 5 are there. 5/5
Bottom Stats: All 3 are present. 5/5
Flavor Text: Very fitting, and imaginative. 5/5
Total: 37/40
MS Eeveelution – Luxray
Concept: It’s a crystal Pokemon. It’s balanced, and its effective. 10/10
Picture: Excellent. It tells me that it’s a Crystal Pokemon, and it fits Luxray. 10/10
Attacks: Wave Burst is brilliant, but Burnt Shock is very underpowered. 7/10
Top Stats: All 5 are present. 5/5
Bottom Stats: Personally, a +30 weakness would’ve been better than x2. 4/5
Flavor Text: Somewhat short, but it tells me about Luxray. 5/5
Total: 37/40
XKurami93X – Roserade
Concept: It’s a crystal Pokemon. 10/10
Picture: Wonderful and marvellous. 10/10
Attacks: Both are somewhat underpowered. 3/5
Top Stats: All 5 are present. 5/5
Bottom Stats: All 3 are there. 5/5
Flavor Text: Yep. In game PokeDex entries never fail. 5/5
Total: 38/40
Muddy68 – Dragonite
Concept: It’s a crystal Pokemon. 10/10
Picture: The picture would work for a Level X card, as I get a pop up vibe from it. 7/10
Attacks: Both have been used before on real cards, so they need different names. 2/5
Top Stats: The HP is low for a Dragonite. 4/5
Bottom Stats: Weakness and Retreat need some boosts, as they are somewhat low. 2/5
Flavor Text: Dragonite is also a strong Pokemon. Why would it hide in a cave? 3/5
Total: 28/40
Dr4g0n – Aggron
Concept: Crystal Pokemon? Yep 10/10
Picture: Very cool picture. 10/10
Attacks: Both need to be reworded. You also forgot energy in Extreme Burn Out. 3/5
Top Stats: Yep. All 5 are there. 5/5
Bottom Stats: I think a {R} weakness would be better. 3/5
Flavor Text: I can give you full points here. 5/5
Total: 36/40
Kingdra King – Dodrio
Concept: Full points here. 10/10
Picture: Cool picture, but could be explained more. 8/10
Attacks: None of them use {M} energy. 3/5
Top Stats: Yep. All fit. 5/5
Bottom Stats: No no no. All of them need fixing. 1/5
Flavor Text: I can give you full points here. 5/5
Total: 33/40
Apophys – Regigigas
Concept: I love the 3 types chosen. 10/10
Picture: I loved the movie, and that scene was really cool. 10/10
Attacks: Awaken is balanced, but Flow Breaker is underpowered. 3/5
Top Stats: Yep. 5/5
Bottom Stats: Yep. 5/5
Flavor Text: Full points here. 5/5
Total: 38/40
Light Venusaur – Arceus
Concept: The types make sense, but aren’t used on the card. 5/10
Picture: It’s Arceus...with a Shaymin on its head. 4/10
Attacks: Only {C} energy!!! No no no. 0/10
Top Stats: All 5 are here. 5/5
Bottom Stats: The retreat seems a little high. 3/5
Flavor Text: Okay here. 5/5
Total: 22/40
Vencargo – Cloyster
Concept: I love the Pokemon chosen. 10/10
Picture: Very vivid, and descriptive. 10/10
Attacks: Miracle Shot needs to be reworded, as it is hard to understand. 6/10
Top Stats: Yep. All 5 are here. 5/5
Bottom Stats: Makes sense. 5/5
Flavor Text: There isn’t any. 0/5
Total: 31/40