Finished The Resistance Game 1 - Spies Win
- Thread starter Celever
- Start date
- Status
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3
Actually, I don't think I'm grasping at straws at all. I think I've hit the nail on the head rather nicely, otherwise you wouldn't have responded the way you have, frankly. I've been presenting my case, and responding to your rebuttals. I don't see how that's at all tunneling -- in fact, I see that as case-presenting; as investigating; as being inquisitive.
Porygon-X said:
Actually, I don't think I'm grasping at straws at all. I think I've hit the nail on the head rather nicely, otherwise you wouldn't have responded the way you have, frankly. I've been presenting my case, and responding to your rebuttals. I don't see how that's at all tunneling -- in fact, I see that as case-presenting; as investigating; as being inquisitive.
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3
I'm going on a camping holiday p much now and will have limited access to the internet, so to save this game being cancelled due to long stretches of inactivity I am seeking a cohost. Please PM me if onterested.
In other news, I'll write the flavour up tonight, but the mission was a FAILURE. The detective said that two people sabotaged the mission.
Whoever is next, could you syggest please? I am leaving now, and as I'm on iPad I can't check.
Thanks guys! ^_^
I'm going on a camping holiday p much now and will have limited access to the internet, so to save this game being cancelled due to long stretches of inactivity I am seeking a cohost. Please PM me if onterested.
In other news, I'll write the flavour up tonight, but the mission was a FAILURE. The detective said that two people sabotaged the mission.
Whoever is next, could you syggest please? I am leaving now, and as I'm on iPad I can't check.
Thanks guys! ^_^
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3
woah what
I was half expecting there'd be a fail in that team but two? Either there was a bad troll resistance or I just suck at picking people from the discussion earlier.
Well I'm sure there's going to be a lot more discussion this round, so I'll stay tuned.
woah what
I was half expecting there'd be a fail in that team but two? Either there was a bad troll resistance or I just suck at picking people from the discussion earlier.
Well I'm sure there's going to be a lot more discussion this round, so I'll stay tuned.
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3
Two people! Okay, that's exciting!
Okay, so... Here we go. The people in this mission were as follows:
PMJ, WanderingWolf, Kecleon-X, TheGuy, Keeper of Night & rev3rsor
Now, excluding myself as Town because, if I were a Spy, I would not have fought my place on the mission knowing there was another Spy on it to fail (plus, I didn't get a message from Celever! But that's a given statement.
), we have five people who are possible Spies.
Okay, so PMJ noted in his post that KoN and rev3rsor are scumbuddies, and I subscribe to that logic. I've got a good feeling about it, and I can definitely see that happening. However, this does not rule out anyone else as non-spies per-say (in fact, I would like to hear more from PMJ on what he thinks is going in, for more reason than one), for they could have tossed the succeed seeing over two more of their team-mates on the list, however for the moment let's find out who the two were.
I also, honestly, have a peculiar feeling about WW. I won't go into more detail until I can read over his posts more, but I'd at least like to hear his opinion on the recent happenings.
Do I also recall something about TheGuy being called scummy by someone, too? I feel like I did. Who did that and why?
But as it goes, two -- give up to two more if need be -- people off that list are town. This is actually good for us -- we can work this out.
Celever said:
Two people! Okay, that's exciting!
Okay, so... Here we go. The people in this mission were as follows:
PMJ, WanderingWolf, Kecleon-X, TheGuy, Keeper of Night & rev3rsor
Now, excluding myself as Town because, if I were a Spy, I would not have fought my place on the mission knowing there was another Spy on it to fail (plus, I didn't get a message from Celever! But that's a given statement.
), we have five people who are possible Spies. Okay, so PMJ noted in his post that KoN and rev3rsor are scumbuddies, and I subscribe to that logic. I've got a good feeling about it, and I can definitely see that happening. However, this does not rule out anyone else as non-spies per-say (in fact, I would like to hear more from PMJ on what he thinks is going in, for more reason than one), for they could have tossed the succeed seeing over two more of their team-mates on the list, however for the moment let's find out who the two were.
I also, honestly, have a peculiar feeling about WW. I won't go into more detail until I can read over his posts more, but I'd at least like to hear his opinion on the recent happenings.
Do I also recall something about TheGuy being called scummy by someone, too? I feel like I did. Who did that and why?
But as it goes, two -- give up to two more if need be -- people off that list are town. This is actually good for us -- we can work this out.
PMJ
Silhouette Gloom of the Sundown Lands
Forum Head
Articles Head
Elite Member
Advanced Member
Member
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3
I'm actually not surprised.
There are, what, two missions left? If we send any spies at all on them, then that's gg.
Time for me to overthink things again. Here we go:
I have no reason not to believe that WW is telling the truth when he said he sent in a fail for the resistance. By doing so, he allows his other buddies to vote to succeed the mission and not get caught with like 3 or more people failing it.
If WW was actually town and it turns out he actually did vote fail then he's playing against his win condition which is a lame thing to do. I thought for a while that this could be a gambit by WW as town, but the spies know what his alignment is so if WW was town they wouldn't trust him at his word.
New idea: WW proclaimed his fail vote so his scumbuddies could safely vote success. Look who posted before WW could get a chance to, and was the first person to comment on this latest development? rev3rsor, who voted to fail before WW could discreetly message his buddies to vote succeed.
After watching GM DracLord play mafia, I'm leaning less towards scum and more towards newbie. So WW takes his place on PMJ's patented scum-o-meter. For now.
I'm actually not surprised.
There are, what, two missions left? If we send any spies at all on them, then that's gg.
Time for me to overthink things again. Here we go:
I have no reason not to believe that WW is telling the truth when he said he sent in a fail for the resistance. By doing so, he allows his other buddies to vote to succeed the mission and not get caught with like 3 or more people failing it.
If WW was actually town and it turns out he actually did vote fail then he's playing against his win condition which is a lame thing to do. I thought for a while that this could be a gambit by WW as town, but the spies know what his alignment is so if WW was town they wouldn't trust him at his word.
New idea: WW proclaimed his fail vote so his scumbuddies could safely vote success. Look who posted before WW could get a chance to, and was the first person to comment on this latest development? rev3rsor, who voted to fail before WW could discreetly message his buddies to vote succeed.
After watching GM DracLord play mafia, I'm leaning less towards scum and more towards newbie. So WW takes his place on PMJ's patented scum-o-meter. For now.
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3
Actually, if I'm allowed to quote the message to Celever I sent,
I pretty much said I wanted to fail the mission for the shits and giggles, but now that the resistance has a chance, I wouldn't.
Take that as you will, but I'm not spy.
Actually, if I'm allowed to quote the message to Celever I sent,
I pretty much said I wanted to fail the mission for the shits and giggles, but now that the resistance has a chance, I wouldn't.
Take that as you will, but I'm not spy.
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3
Yeah, the more I think about it, the more I think PMJ has a good point, and that WW and rev are the spies. Although, WW may have just been goofing off, and there were simply 2 spies on the mission. If that's the case, I actually think Kecleon looks more like Resistance to me than TheGuy. But I still think it's WW and rev.
For my mission (yes, I'm leader), I'm going to put Me, PMJ, Drohn, Keeper of Night and Kecleon-X on this mission. I want Drac to vote first, then rev, then WW, then TheGuy, then the others. I vote yes.
Yeah, the more I think about it, the more I think PMJ has a good point, and that WW and rev are the spies. Although, WW may have just been goofing off, and there were simply 2 spies on the mission. If that's the case, I actually think Kecleon looks more like Resistance to me than TheGuy. But I still think it's WW and rev.
For my mission (yes, I'm leader), I'm going to put Me, PMJ, Drohn, Keeper of Night and Kecleon-X on this mission. I want Drac to vote first, then rev, then WW, then TheGuy, then the others. I vote yes.
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3
This one only has 5 people on the mission, so even if you're Resistance, it can still succeed. I would still approve the mission if it was the one I posted + TheGuy - Kecleon, because I think you're likely to be the last Resistance.
TheGuy said:
This one only has 5 people on the mission, so even if you're Resistance, it can still succeed. I would still approve the mission if it was the one I posted + TheGuy - Kecleon, because I think you're likely to be the last Resistance.
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3
Did a posts get deleted? Where are PMJ's accusations on WW coming from? I guess something got deleted, since WW is also going along with it.. So WW admitted he chose to fail the mission?
That means from the ones that didn't go (Draclord, Porygon, Machamp, and myself) there are also 2 or 3 spies. I expect rev3sor to be a spy and WanderingWolf to be a possible spy. WanderingWolf can be a troll that should never have signed up if he was not playing it seriously, in which case, you really shouldn't be playing and ruining it for us. The reason I consider the latter a strong possibility for WW is because he had no reason to confess he voted to fail. It would help if someone could repeat what the deleted posts said.
I'll wait with my vote for now as requested and because I need to know if WW is a troll or spy before I choose.
Did a posts get deleted? Where are PMJ's accusations on WW coming from? I guess something got deleted, since WW is also going along with it.. So WW admitted he chose to fail the mission?
2 people from here are spies (or WW is a troll?).rev3rsor said:
That means from the ones that didn't go (Draclord, Porygon, Machamp, and myself) there are also 2 or 3 spies. I expect rev3sor to be a spy and WanderingWolf to be a possible spy. WanderingWolf can be a troll that should never have signed up if he was not playing it seriously, in which case, you really shouldn't be playing and ruining it for us. The reason I consider the latter a strong possibility for WW is because he had no reason to confess he voted to fail. It would help if someone could repeat what the deleted posts said.
I'll wait with my vote for now as requested and because I need to know if WW is a troll or spy before I choose.
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3
Ok, never mind, the post was not deleted. I got confused and thought he admitted after we got the results, but it was during the voting period. I agree with PMJ in that case; he was probably letting the other spies know he would fail the mission. He would not have done that if there weren't 2 or more spies on board (if there was only one then he could have simply not voted to fail himself). So rev3rsor picked a team of 3 or more spies? Why would he do that if he knew he could fail the mission by himself alone? I guess rev3rsor isn't a spy then? I'm actually clueless now..
Edit: Actually, rev3sor might have wanted more spies on board so there wouldn't be too many spies on the sideline. If there were too many spies not in the mission there would only be 1 fail, meaning that 3 of the people on the side were confirmed spies. WW is likely one of the other spies that he picked to go along with himself (and decided to post a hint -masked as a joke- for his fellow spies).
Edit 2: This means there were too many spies on board the last mission and some of them are on board now. I'm going to vote no now, because it's not worth the risk of waiting. I could understand you wanted to have a fixed order for finding out information before you decide whether or not the mission should go on or not, but why would you already vote yourself? It seems like you're not trying to find out information, but are trying to get your team through. Very suspicious.
Ok, never mind, the post was not deleted. I got confused and thought he admitted after we got the results, but it was during the voting period. I agree with PMJ in that case; he was probably letting the other spies know he would fail the mission. He would not have done that if there weren't 2 or more spies on board (if there was only one then he could have simply not voted to fail himself). So rev3rsor picked a team of 3 or more spies? Why would he do that if he knew he could fail the mission by himself alone? I guess rev3rsor isn't a spy then? I'm actually clueless now..
Edit: Actually, rev3sor might have wanted more spies on board so there wouldn't be too many spies on the sideline. If there were too many spies not in the mission there would only be 1 fail, meaning that 3 of the people on the side were confirmed spies. WW is likely one of the other spies that he picked to go along with himself (and decided to post a hint -masked as a joke- for his fellow spies).
Edit 2: This means there were too many spies on board the last mission and some of them are on board now. I'm going to vote no now, because it's not worth the risk of waiting. I could understand you wanted to have a fixed order for finding out information before you decide whether or not the mission should go on or not, but why would you already vote yourself? It seems like you're not trying to find out information, but are trying to get your team through. Very suspicious.
RE: The Resistance Game 1 - Round 3
Oh, wait... I forgot about this:
So that means there were probably 3 spies on that mission. In that case, I think the spies are probably Porygon, WW, rev and... TheGuy? It might be Kecleon, but I'm not sure. There's also the possibility that WW made that post just in case rev hadn't submitted his vote already, but I doubt it.
I think everyone should make a list of who they think the spies are, similar to this one.
Oh, wait... I forgot about this:
PMJ said:
So that means there were probably 3 spies on that mission. In that case, I think the spies are probably Porygon, WW, rev and... TheGuy? It might be Kecleon, but I'm not sure. There's also the possibility that WW made that post just in case rev hadn't submitted his vote already, but I doubt it.
I think everyone should make a list of who they think the spies are, similar to this one.
- Status