Finished Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Nerds Win
- Thread starter Riskbreakers
- Start date
- Status
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
Well, would that person might have something against safariblade (TDL, perhaps...?), or they just did it randomly, because they had no other lead on who they'd want to silence. But I guess it is possible that head jock targetted TDL, and a jock with a side ability silenced safariblade. But then wouldn't that mean that one of the nerds could have silenced someone as well? That leads me to believe that whoever silenced safariblade was an indipendent role.
Well, would that person might have something against safariblade (TDL, perhaps...?), or they just did it randomly, because they had no other lead on who they'd want to silence. But I guess it is possible that head jock targetted TDL, and a jock with a side ability silenced safariblade. But then wouldn't that mean that one of the nerds could have silenced someone as well? That leads me to believe that whoever silenced safariblade was an indipendent role.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
Alright, I've been thinking, ad here's what I've come up with.
I'm very suspicious of Chillarmy, safariblade, and Dark Void. They're going just a little bit too far in defending each other. No one strongly defends someone else unless they either are a seer or some other role revealer and know that person's role OR they are werewolves and know who each other are anyway. I think the latter is probably more likely. Of course, after I say this, they are all going to deny it and stop defending each other.
Alright, I've been thinking, ad here's what I've come up with.
I'm very suspicious of Chillarmy, safariblade, and Dark Void. They're going just a little bit too far in defending each other. No one strongly defends someone else unless they either are a seer or some other role revealer and know that person's role OR they are werewolves and know who each other are anyway. I think the latter is probably more likely. Of course, after I say this, they are all going to deny it and stop defending each other.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
Yeah, after thinking about it more, Chillarmy has good points. I say we just go for Meaty.
UNVOTE: Chillarmy
VOTE: Meaty
Yeah, after thinking about it more, Chillarmy has good points. I say we just go for Meaty.
UNVOTE: Chillarmy
VOTE: Meaty
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
No, I'm not goign to stop defending safariblade, because I feel he needs a fair chance to defend himself. And why are you all of the sudden changing suspicions so quickly, are you suspecting your fellow faction members to ease off suspicion, but then defending them when they're in trouble?
I'm going to bed.
No, I'm not goign to stop defending safariblade, because I feel he needs a fair chance to defend himself. And why are you all of the sudden changing suspicions so quickly, are you suspecting your fellow faction members to ease off suspicion, but then defending them when they're in trouble?
I'm going to bed.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
2 Chillarmy
2 Meaty
1 safariblade
Vote Count as of 11:32AM GMT+8 (11/20)
2 Chillarmy
2 Meaty
1 safariblade
Vote Count as of 11:32AM GMT+8 (11/20)
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
For the sake of stopping an unreasonable bandwagon on myself, I'll join a more reasonable bandwagon against Chillarmy. Blah237 has a somewhat valid point, and DNA and I have pointed out other things against Chillarmy earlier. He just seems really quick to point fingers and try to eliminate others, so I think he's guilty of something, and I find it dangerous that people are actually listening to him, so I want him out. I guess we'll give safariblade a chance to explain things on the next day.
Unvote: safariblade
Vote: Chillarmy
For the sake of stopping an unreasonable bandwagon on myself, I'll join a more reasonable bandwagon against Chillarmy. Blah237 has a somewhat valid point, and DNA and I have pointed out other things against Chillarmy earlier. He just seems really quick to point fingers and try to eliminate others, so I think he's guilty of something, and I find it dangerous that people are actually listening to him, so I want him out. I guess we'll give safariblade a chance to explain things on the next day.
Unvote: safariblade
Vote: Chillarmy
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
I agreed more with Chillarmy's points which is why I didn't think he was overreacting. He was quick to point at you, Meaty, but because you were quick to him IIRC.
I agreed more with Chillarmy's points which is why I didn't think he was overreacting. He was quick to point at you, Meaty, but because you were quick to him IIRC.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
Better put in my opinion as the one who is centered in this little event.
Has it been brought up yet that this could all be a coincidence? Did you ever think that I was targeted by the jocks because I am a good player? Did you ever think that I was protected because I am a good player? This seems like a coincidence to me at least. I actually think that safariblade was silenced as a side effect of his role, not because of an independent's role. Maybe he was the one who protected me or revealed PMJ and Guy's roles, and as a consequence he may not post?
Also, I'm pretty sure it was Lenny who protected me. We're pretty good friends, and he realized from our chat WW games that I usually die early. With Lenny gone I guess I'm pretty much open for kill, unless of course there's two people with protecting roles.
Honestly, I don't think safari and ESP are that stupid. ESP is a veteran player, while safariblade on the other hand was clowning around. The jocks probably decided to abuse safariblade's little joke to cause what we see now. You guys who think safariblade is part of the jocks, or whatever reason you guys are suspicious of him being, need to stop doing exactly what the jocks want; you guys to lynch safariblade. ESP was simply making a joke of things. If you look at his post where he said he wanted to lynch me, read it again. It clearly shows that he was kidding.
Meaty and DNA were a little too quick to jump on Chillarmy, but I don't think that's really reason to lynch the either of them. I actually think they had the right idea by suspecting Chillarmy, who in return didn't really make a solid defense. Even though he says he misread, his defense was still silly, and he used the classic "NOOO I'M GOOD MY ROLE IS HELPFUL TO YOU DUDES." Even if he was telling the truth, that's basically shooting yourself in the foot since you put a target on your head, like PMJ said.
Vote: Chillarmy
I'm more than just an option, hey, hey, hey. Refuse to be forgotten, hey, hey, hey.
Better put in my opinion as the one who is centered in this little event.
Has it been brought up yet that this could all be a coincidence? Did you ever think that I was targeted by the jocks because I am a good player? Did you ever think that I was protected because I am a good player? This seems like a coincidence to me at least. I actually think that safariblade was silenced as a side effect of his role, not because of an independent's role. Maybe he was the one who protected me or revealed PMJ and Guy's roles, and as a consequence he may not post?
Also, I'm pretty sure it was Lenny who protected me. We're pretty good friends, and he realized from our chat WW games that I usually die early. With Lenny gone I guess I'm pretty much open for kill, unless of course there's two people with protecting roles.
Honestly, I don't think safari and ESP are that stupid. ESP is a veteran player, while safariblade on the other hand was clowning around. The jocks probably decided to abuse safariblade's little joke to cause what we see now. You guys who think safariblade is part of the jocks, or whatever reason you guys are suspicious of him being, need to stop doing exactly what the jocks want; you guys to lynch safariblade. ESP was simply making a joke of things. If you look at his post where he said he wanted to lynch me, read it again. It clearly shows that he was kidding.
Meaty and DNA were a little too quick to jump on Chillarmy, but I don't think that's really reason to lynch the either of them. I actually think they had the right idea by suspecting Chillarmy, who in return didn't really make a solid defense. Even though he says he misread, his defense was still silly, and he used the classic "NOOO I'M GOOD MY ROLE IS HELPFUL TO YOU DUDES." Even if he was telling the truth, that's basically shooting yourself in the foot since you put a target on your head, like PMJ said.
Vote: Chillarmy
I'm more than just an option, hey, hey, hey. Refuse to be forgotten, hey, hey, hey.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
Wait...how did I become suspicious? I said that Chillarmy has no evidence on him, which as far as I can tell still holds true. I didn't think we should lynch Chillarmy and said so. That hardly makes me a viable candidate to lynch unless you can find real evidence against me.
Also, has anyone noticed that on the first day we all thought that Blah was speaking in character, and there is none of that in his more recent posts? Risk has been on since Blah has made normal posts and B;ah hasn't been modkilled, so it seems to me that Blah doesn't have anything in his role dictating how he must speak. So...why did he post wierd stuff on night 1?
Wait...how did I become suspicious? I said that Chillarmy has no evidence on him, which as far as I can tell still holds true. I didn't think we should lynch Chillarmy and said so. That hardly makes me a viable candidate to lynch unless you can find real evidence against me.
Also, has anyone noticed that on the first day we all thought that Blah was speaking in character, and there is none of that in his more recent posts? Risk has been on since Blah has made normal posts and B;ah hasn't been modkilled, so it seems to me that Blah doesn't have anything in his role dictating how he must speak. So...why did he post wierd stuff on night 1?
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
Well if it comes to it I'll revote Chillarmy to avoid a waste of a lynch.
Well if it comes to it I'll revote Chillarmy to avoid a waste of a lynch.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
I think TDL has made several good points. I had never thought that it may have been safariblade who found out PMJ and Guy89's identities. It does seem pretty likely to me, since not being able to speak seems like an effect tied to something of the sort.
Chillarmy was not quick to jump on me because I was quick to jump on him, it was the opposite. I accused safariblade, Chillarmy said some things against me, DNA jumped against Chillarmy, and I kind of agreed with DNA. If you guys think that DNA is defending me because we are wolves, well, neutrals are meant to defend each other as well... Honestly, I don't really know why DNA defended me or if he really meant to at all.
And I hate to sound like I'm forcing a bandwagon, but as Tyraniking said, at the point where we have a ton of people voting for Chillarmy (we seem to be heading in that direction), it's better for the rest of us to vote for him so that we don't get a random lynch. The same thing pretty much happened with Yoshidude10 to avoid random lynch.
I think TDL has made several good points. I had never thought that it may have been safariblade who found out PMJ and Guy89's identities. It does seem pretty likely to me, since not being able to speak seems like an effect tied to something of the sort.
Chillarmy was not quick to jump on me because I was quick to jump on him, it was the opposite. I accused safariblade, Chillarmy said some things against me, DNA jumped against Chillarmy, and I kind of agreed with DNA. If you guys think that DNA is defending me because we are wolves, well, neutrals are meant to defend each other as well... Honestly, I don't really know why DNA defended me or if he really meant to at all.
And I hate to sound like I'm forcing a bandwagon, but as Tyraniking said, at the point where we have a ton of people voting for Chillarmy (we seem to be heading in that direction), it's better for the rest of us to vote for him so that we don't get a random lynch. The same thing pretty much happened with Yoshidude10 to avoid random lynch.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
Even if Chillarmy doesn't die now he will later. He said that if he dies another will too, and any nerd or jock will want that.
Even if Chillarmy doesn't die now he will later. He said that if he dies another will too, and any nerd or jock will want that.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
This is the third time I am trying to write a big post -_- The first time I forgot about it and the second time this morning I left it on the computer, my mom rushed me out of the house, and later closed it after I told her not to. Since I never saved any of that I will write it again except for parts that only pertained to the voting which I will write about the new situations.
Ok so considering the whole Guy being revealed thing, we should leave him until he starts killing and then see where he gets us. If he kills two or three townies in a row, which I don't think he'll be stupid enough to do, then we should lynch him. But I have another interesting thing to mention. In my first game of Werewolf I was given a role that would help awaken Ragnarok if you remember that story. When both halves of Ragnarok died, I was given a power up since I was otherwise useless rolewise (and I was probably really n00by) Chiirami made several mistakes in revealing unknowingly he was bad that he was the Pink Geek. He covered it up and looked like he was helping us kill the wolves. But that still left suspicion on him and my power up allowed me to target a player and they would die or be powered up based on their allegiance as it said. It ended up winning the game for the townies on the last day when I had targeted him. What this all leads up to is that I think Guy may receive a power up if he survives later into the game. This may or may not be planned but I thought it may be important.
On the safariblade theory originally I thought that it may add up, which it still might. But TDL brought up really great points and I believe what he says is probably true. My only problem is Chillarmy was so quick to jump on Meaty.
Finally I'm done. I actually got through a big post which I couldn't manage to do twice xD
This is the third time I am trying to write a big post -_- The first time I forgot about it and the second time this morning I left it on the computer, my mom rushed me out of the house, and later closed it after I told her not to. Since I never saved any of that I will write it again except for parts that only pertained to the voting which I will write about the new situations.
Ok so considering the whole Guy being revealed thing, we should leave him until he starts killing and then see where he gets us. If he kills two or three townies in a row, which I don't think he'll be stupid enough to do, then we should lynch him. But I have another interesting thing to mention. In my first game of Werewolf I was given a role that would help awaken Ragnarok if you remember that story. When both halves of Ragnarok died, I was given a power up since I was otherwise useless rolewise (and I was probably really n00by) Chiirami made several mistakes in revealing unknowingly he was bad that he was the Pink Geek. He covered it up and looked like he was helping us kill the wolves. But that still left suspicion on him and my power up allowed me to target a player and they would die or be powered up based on their allegiance as it said. It ended up winning the game for the townies on the last day when I had targeted him. What this all leads up to is that I think Guy may receive a power up if he survives later into the game. This may or may not be planned but I thought it may be important.
On the safariblade theory originally I thought that it may add up, which it still might. But TDL brought up really great points and I believe what he says is probably true. My only problem is Chillarmy was so quick to jump on Meaty.
DV he is suspicious because when he defended safari he quickly jumped on Meaty accusing him of making a bad theory or something of the sorts. How I see it Meaty was trying to help us in making a Day 2 lynch with a little bit of evidence. Now you support Chillarmy and are blind to his getting on Meaty. Blah's theory sounds very plausible to me because you will not address why Chillarmy is obviously suspicious.Dark Void said:
Finally I'm done. I actually got through a big post which I couldn't manage to do twice xD
- Status