Finished Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Nerds Win
- Thread starter Riskbreakers
- Start date
- Status
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
It appears as though meaty is not the only one who wants safariblade dead. If safariblade is dangerous, whatever role that has affected him will kill him soon enough. If not, it probably means safari has some kind of ability that allows him to survive a hit or too, which could prove either really good, or really bad. I'm going wait on a vote for now, since it doesn't look like we've got much more to go off of, other than "somebody wants safari dead." which doesn't really help us much.
Azelf Master said:
It appears as though meaty is not the only one who wants safariblade dead. If safariblade is dangerous, whatever role that has affected him will kill him soon enough. If not, it probably means safari has some kind of ability that allows him to survive a hit or too, which could prove either really good, or really bad. I'm going wait on a vote for now, since it doesn't look like we've got much more to go off of, other than "somebody wants safari dead." which doesn't really help us much.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
Just a thought guys, the nerds can't kill tonight, and we're suspicious of safariblade hating on tdl, but safariblade can't speak tonight. I say we let safariblade live for today, and see what he has to say in two days. We can afford to let him live as the nerds can't kill.
Also, isn't it convienient that someone tried to kill TDL, and safariblade voted for TDl as a joke that everyone rubbed off. However, TDL was killed AND safariblade was silenced, and then Meaty made a very convenient accusation of safariblade. I'm thinking Meaty is quite quite suspicious. What do you guys think?
Just a thought guys, the nerds can't kill tonight, and we're suspicious of safariblade hating on tdl, but safariblade can't speak tonight. I say we let safariblade live for today, and see what he has to say in two days. We can afford to let him live as the nerds can't kill.
Also, isn't it convienient that someone tried to kill TDL, and safariblade voted for TDl as a joke that everyone rubbed off. However, TDL was killed AND safariblade was silenced, and then Meaty made a very convenient accusation of safariblade. I'm thinking Meaty is quite quite suspicious. What do you guys think?
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
And given how everything you have just said is counter-intuitive to everything just assumed, suggesting a rather obvious cover-up,
Vote: Chillarmy
Or kill him now so that we rub out a threat faster and don't wait around taking shots in the dark.
And given how everything you have just said is counter-intuitive to everything just assumed, suggesting a rather obvious cover-up,
Vote: Chillarmy
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
Uhm... what? Why are you voting for me? safariblade was probably making a joke, what we he be doing voting for someone when the votes were balready something like 6-1? Then safariblade was conveniently silenced, while someone attempted to kill TDL... This seems to me like a conspiracy, and it makes perfect sense to me >.< What seems interesting is how quickly you voted for me? Are you trying to cover for Meaty? Are you a nerd too?
Uhm... what? Why are you voting for me? safariblade was probably making a joke, what we he be doing voting for someone when the votes were balready something like 6-1? Then safariblade was conveniently silenced, while someone attempted to kill TDL... This seems to me like a conspiracy, and it makes perfect sense to me >.< What seems interesting is how quickly you voted for me? Are you trying to cover for Meaty? Are you a nerd too?
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
I don't know, or care, what faction Meaty is from. But that doesn't mean that he can't make sound points.
If Safariblade has been neutralized in some way due to a role, that probably means that role was activated in response to safariblade doing something. And now he can't talk for a whole day? More likely than not safariblade was trying to do something.
I don't know if that proves if Safariblade is part of one faction or the other, but you are awful quick to jump to defend him...which probably means that you two are from the same faction.
It's a good of a guess as any.
I don't know, or care, what faction Meaty is from. But that doesn't mean that he can't make sound points.
If Safariblade has been neutralized in some way due to a role, that probably means that role was activated in response to safariblade doing something. And now he can't talk for a whole day? More likely than not safariblade was trying to do something.
I don't know if that proves if Safariblade is part of one faction or the other, but you are awful quick to jump to defend him...which probably means that you two are from the same faction.
It's a good of a guess as any.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
Vote Count as of 11/19 9:07AM GMT+8 (approximately 11/18 5:07PM for Californians)
safariblade : 1
Chillarmy : 1
Vote Count as of 11/19 9:07AM GMT+8 (approximately 11/18 5:07PM for Californians)
safariblade : 1
Chillarmy : 1
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
I can safetly say I am a huge help to the neutral faction. I can also say if you lynch me another will die, who is also very valuable. You'd be best to look at other option than lynching me.
And, safariblade would be kind of stupid to vote for TDL and then kill him the next night. Don't you think he's smarter than that?
I'm still standing on the grounds that both you and Meaty are suspicious, but I'll wait and see what others think.
I can safetly say I am a huge help to the neutral faction. I can also say if you lynch me another will die, who is also very valuable. You'd be best to look at other option than lynching me.
And, safariblade would be kind of stupid to vote for TDL and then kill him the next night. Don't you think he's smarter than that?
I'm still standing on the grounds that both you and Meaty are suspicious, but I'll wait and see what others think.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
Chillarmy, the problem with your logic is that we know that TDL was targeted by the jocks, so nerds not being able to kill this night hardly matters in terms of waiting to lynch safariblade. safariblade being muted for the day does make him even more suspicious, and DNA has a point with you seeming to try to cover something up and point a finger at me. Not to mention right now your logic seems to be making a lot of wild assumptions, so I don't think we should all jump to conclusions just yet. I only voted for safari at this point because most evidence is pointing to him, so far.
Chillarmy, the problem with your logic is that we know that TDL was targeted by the jocks, so nerds not being able to kill this night hardly matters in terms of waiting to lynch safariblade. safariblade being muted for the day does make him even more suspicious, and DNA has a point with you seeming to try to cover something up and point a finger at me. Not to mention right now your logic seems to be making a lot of wild assumptions, so I don't think we should all jump to conclusions just yet. I only voted for safari at this point because most evidence is pointing to him, so far.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
Misread ftl.
I thought the nerds targetted safariblade. However, I'm still standing with my theory. I'm also not trying to jump to conclusions, I'm merely stating a possibility that seems quite likely to me. Wouldn't you agree that it seems rather suspicious that safariblade was silenced and TDL was targetted, so safariblade has no grounds to defend himself? I feel the jocks have a silencer. I could be wrong about you and DNA being suspicious, but I find it interesting that you made a connection that I believe everyone else thought was just a joke by safariblade. Seriously, what would safariblade want to accomplish by voting for TDL if he was a nerd?
Misread ftl.
I thought the nerds targetted safariblade. However, I'm still standing with my theory. I'm also not trying to jump to conclusions, I'm merely stating a possibility that seems quite likely to me. Wouldn't you agree that it seems rather suspicious that safariblade was silenced and TDL was targetted, so safariblade has no grounds to defend himself? I feel the jocks have a silencer. I could be wrong about you and DNA being suspicious, but I find it interesting that you made a connection that I believe everyone else thought was just a joke by safariblade. Seriously, what would safariblade want to accomplish by voting for TDL if he was a nerd?
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
So as for what I have figured out so far, it seems like we have come to 2 conclusions: safari voted for TDL then tried to kill him on the next night. I hold by this being an extremely odd move for anyone to make, as you are framing yourself, essentially. As far as I can tell, the only evidence that supports this is that safariblade is unable to speak, which could be presuming to be a side effect of their role failing/being blocked. Correct me if I'm wrong on this, I'm just not understanding any of the other evidence for this, if there is other evidence please say so. THe other option is to lynch Chillarmy for defending safariblade. As it is, I'm just not seeing enough evidence to say that safariblade is evil (in fact, I'm seeing more evidence that he isn't) and therefore neither lynch is looking good to me. If there is anything I missed please point it out.
So as for what I have figured out so far, it seems like we have come to 2 conclusions: safari voted for TDL then tried to kill him on the next night. I hold by this being an extremely odd move for anyone to make, as you are framing yourself, essentially. As far as I can tell, the only evidence that supports this is that safariblade is unable to speak, which could be presuming to be a side effect of their role failing/being blocked. Correct me if I'm wrong on this, I'm just not understanding any of the other evidence for this, if there is other evidence please say so. THe other option is to lynch Chillarmy for defending safariblade. As it is, I'm just not seeing enough evidence to say that safariblade is evil (in fact, I'm seeing more evidence that he isn't) and therefore neither lynch is looking good to me. If there is anything I missed please point it out.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
Why does everyone think that sb got silenced because of a side effect of his role? I just think someone simply had a silencing role and had no one to target, so they picked an experienced player. Use common sense people.
Why does everyone think that sb got silenced because of a side effect of his role? I just think someone simply had a silencing role and had no one to target, so they picked an experienced player. Use common sense people.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
I agree. But I am also stumped as to why safari tried to lynch TDL, most likely a joke, and now TDL's a target? But TDL is being protected, and safari can't post? And based on this safari is the one trying to kill TDL? I guess there is a decent chance. I'm guessing it could be the jock's plan to get Safari out though. Taking advantage of a lame joke, perhaps? Then it just so happens that he's also blocked from posting...it seems pretty plausible, but I don't know. Overall, Chillarmy is a better lynch...
I agree. But I am also stumped as to why safari tried to lynch TDL, most likely a joke, and now TDL's a target? But TDL is being protected, and safari can't post? And based on this safari is the one trying to kill TDL? I guess there is a decent chance. I'm guessing it could be the jock's plan to get Safari out though. Taking advantage of a lame joke, perhaps? Then it just so happens that he's also blocked from posting...it seems pretty plausible, but I don't know. Overall, Chillarmy is a better lynch...
PMJ
Silhouette Gloom of the Sundown Lands
Forum Head
Articles Head
Elite Member
Advanced Member
Member
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
Also I don't think there's any conspiracies involving safariblade. Did anyone forget we just came off of day one? I believe safariblade was just a random pick; not everything has to have some crazy conspiracy.
Can we please stop making posts like these? You might as well be wearing a sign around your neck saying, "Hello everyone. I am part of the neutral faction, and my role is exceptionally useful to them. If you target me, you'll get two for one- isn't that wonderful?"Chillarmy said:
Also I don't think there's any conspiracies involving safariblade. Did anyone forget we just came off of day one? I believe safariblade was just a random pick; not everything has to have some crazy conspiracy.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
Yeah PMJ, I'd also say safari was a random pick. Mods are usually targeted first in WW games because people just assume that they're good players, and then after that, the good players get targeted too.
For someone to pick safari because they know his role, they would have to have contact with a seer who got to see the role of the person he targeted before the night ended but usually, the seer doesn't find out until morning? Right?
And they would also have to know who the seer was. Which would be incredibly stupid for the seer to reveal themselves to anyone this early in the game (hint hint seer, do us all a favor and stay alive).
Yeah PMJ, I'd also say safari was a random pick. Mods are usually targeted first in WW games because people just assume that they're good players, and then after that, the good players get targeted too.
For someone to pick safari because they know his role, they would have to have contact with a seer who got to see the role of the person he targeted before the night ended but usually, the seer doesn't find out until morning? Right?
And they would also have to know who the seer was. Which would be incredibly stupid for the seer to reveal themselves to anyone this early in the game (hint hint seer, do us all a favor and stay alive).
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
I forgot about that, DV. Sooooooooo my theory gives us no leads...just what we need.
I forgot about that, DV. Sooooooooo my theory gives us no leads...just what we need.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
That's why I didn't vote for Safariblade. I know Meaty did and he's got fairly good reasons for it, but they weren't enough for me personally to make a sort of connection and so I withheld suspicion.
However...I voted for Chillarmy because Chillarmy seemed very quick to defend Safariblade. Almost too quick. His reasoning to try and draw suspicion off SB and himself was a bit lackluster at best, and at least for me, I can see it that Chillarmy at the very least probably knows what faction SB is a part of; you could even go far enough to say that they're part of the same one, and Chillarmy could even be the head of that faction.
...You COULD go that far. I'll just stick with the belief that the two of them are in cahoots and leave it at that.
That's why I'm voting for Chillarmy; his reasons aren't all that great and he's a bit shifty.
tl;dr:
I agree too. In and of itself, Safari trying to go after TDL and then getting silenced could just mean that someone else had a silencing role and blocked SB from doing anything today. A case could be made for SB being part of one of the non-neutral factions but it would be shaky at best.Hatman said:
That's why I didn't vote for Safariblade. I know Meaty did and he's got fairly good reasons for it, but they weren't enough for me personally to make a sort of connection and so I withheld suspicion.
However...I voted for Chillarmy because Chillarmy seemed very quick to defend Safariblade. Almost too quick. His reasoning to try and draw suspicion off SB and himself was a bit lackluster at best, and at least for me, I can see it that Chillarmy at the very least probably knows what faction SB is a part of; you could even go far enough to say that they're part of the same one, and Chillarmy could even be the head of that faction.
...You COULD go that far. I'll just stick with the belief that the two of them are in cahoots and leave it at that.
That's why I'm voting for Chillarmy; his reasons aren't all that great and he's a bit shifty.
tl;dr:
andMeaty said:
I agree. Chillarmy, if you want to try and make a post in your defense, you could at least try harder. Saying that you're one of the neutrals and that you can kill someone (allegedly) won't really convince anybody.PMJ said:
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
I am starting to lean towards Chillarmy more than safariblade (gotta love the unvote feature), but the sad part is he might have been stupid enough to be honest when he says he is useful to the neutral faction. He might be lying, in which case he's a pretty obvious lynch, but if he isn't lynched/a jock he will likely be killed jocks tonight... Anyway, let's try not to blatantly give our roles away anymore...
I am starting to lean towards Chillarmy more than safariblade (gotta love the unvote feature), but the sad part is he might have been stupid enough to be honest when he says he is useful to the neutral faction. He might be lying, in which case he's a pretty obvious lynch, but if he isn't lynched/a jock he will likely be killed jocks tonight... Anyway, let's try not to blatantly give our roles away anymore...
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 2 End 11/22/2011 7AM GMT+8
Before I forget I'll place my vote in...
VOTE: Cillarmy
I may change later on. I am not positive but he definitely did jump.
Before I forget I'll place my vote in...
VOTE: Cillarmy
I may change later on. I am not positive but he definitely did jump.
- Status