Finished Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Nerds Win
- Thread starter Riskbreakers
- Start date
- Status
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8
You know what, I don't even care if this next comment gets me killed. I'm sick of leaning back while no one catches anything that is going on.
HOW WOULD YOU KNOW THAT! How would you know that the jocks tried to kill PMJ for that reason unless you were the one that told them that!? Even better, if the jocks knew that those people could be killed, and didn't want them to be killed, then one of those people Storm Blade just mentioned is probably a jock too.
And remember when Storm Blade voted for me.
That's not a reason. That's going along with lynching a neutral and it's an easy way to get a neutral lynched without having to explain yourself.
PLEASE TELL ME SOMONE ELSE SEES THIS AND DOESN'T THINK IT'S A RANDOM ACCUSATION.
You know what, I don't even care if this next comment gets me killed. I'm sick of leaning back while no one catches anything that is going on.
Storm Blade said:
HOW WOULD YOU KNOW THAT! How would you know that the jocks tried to kill PMJ for that reason unless you were the one that told them that!? Even better, if the jocks knew that those people could be killed, and didn't want them to be killed, then one of those people Storm Blade just mentioned is probably a jock too.
And remember when Storm Blade voted for me.
Storm Blade said:
That's not a reason. That's going along with lynching a neutral and it's an easy way to get a neutral lynched without having to explain yourself.
PLEASE TELL ME SOMONE ELSE SEES THIS AND DOESN'T THINK IT'S A RANDOM ACCUSATION.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8
pmj's logic seems to make sense... blah237 might not be a wolf. Although, I don't like the idea of keeping a townie around that casts suspicion at random people. He's dangerous that way even if he isn't a wolf/jock/nerd/whatever. It's kind of a lose/lose for us.
unvote: Blah237
I don't think he's a wolf, so I see no reason to vote for him. At least not yet. At the same time, I don't see anyone else really worth voting for at this point in time.
pmj's logic seems to make sense... blah237 might not be a wolf. Although, I don't like the idea of keeping a townie around that casts suspicion at random people. He's dangerous that way even if he isn't a wolf/jock/nerd/whatever. It's kind of a lose/lose for us.
unvote: Blah237
I don't think he's a wolf, so I see no reason to vote for him. At least not yet. At the same time, I don't see anyone else really worth voting for at this point in time.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8
Blah237, hate to say it, but bandwagons do happen. In a perfect world there wouldn't be any, but there are, and have been every single day. Day 1 it happened to Yoshidude, day 2 it happened to Chillarmy, and today it almost happened to you. Its hard to let 25+ people all form their own opinions on a series of complicated clues and all come up with the same answer. If it weren't for bandwagoning, we would almost never decide on a lynch unless a bad guy was revealed the night before. Much as I dislike bandwagoning, we can't lynch everybody who does it.
Blah237, hate to say it, but bandwagons do happen. In a perfect world there wouldn't be any, but there are, and have been every single day. Day 1 it happened to Yoshidude, day 2 it happened to Chillarmy, and today it almost happened to you. Its hard to let 25+ people all form their own opinions on a series of complicated clues and all come up with the same answer. If it weren't for bandwagoning, we would almost never decide on a lynch unless a bad guy was revealed the night before. Much as I dislike bandwagoning, we can't lynch everybody who does it.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8
Hmmm...yeah I guess PMJ is sorta right.
Unvote: Blah237
Just be careful...I've got my eye on you. Realize that your panicked and quick-accusing attitude made you a target. I myself, am not a fan of bandwagoning, but in the case of Yoshidude (and almost you) it's usually a time when we don't have any other choice. Random.org is not a friend :<
Hmmm...yeah I guess PMJ is sorta right.
Unvote: Blah237
Just be careful...I've got my eye on you. Realize that your panicked and quick-accusing attitude made you a target. I myself, am not a fan of bandwagoning, but in the case of Yoshidude (and almost you) it's usually a time when we don't have any other choice. Random.org is not a friend :<
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8
Calling replacements inactive isn't really fair, they didn't get that much of a chance to vote.
1. Your a good player.
2. The town wouldn't lynch you.
3. Your the big cheese.
Argetlam said:Well, the only other replacement is Pokechamp. Wut about me?He replaced dmaster. The inactives are:
Storm Blade 5
sillykyle! 3
Gale 3
PokeChamp 2
Lenny 2Dead
Nengeni 2
HypnoticLuxray 2
Argetlam 3
Afro-G 1
Blue Thunder 1
Mew Jadester 1
I'm sure there's some of them we can rule out, I just don't have time to right now.
(Ooc: Yay 600th post!!)
Calling replacements inactive isn't really fair, they didn't get that much of a chance to vote.
I could think of a few good reasons.
1. Your a good player.
2. The town wouldn't lynch you.
3. Your the big cheese.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8
I'm back. What important did I miss?
I'm back. What important did I miss?
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8
Basically everyone now knows that I'm the priest, jocks tried to kill PMJ for some reason, but someone somehow stopped all night activity.
Also is it a coincidence that everyone suddenly keeps confusing your and you're!?
doublenikesocks said:
Basically everyone now knows that I'm the priest, jocks tried to kill PMJ for some reason, but someone somehow stopped all night activity.
Also is it a coincidence that everyone suddenly keeps confusing your and you're!?
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8
Why am I the most suspicious?
Here is what happened:
I am accused of being the head jock.
I refute that claim with a good point and evidence.
Then, you guys say I'm a just a regular jock and am a suspicious person.
Is there any concrete proof whatsoever that I am a jock and/or have a powerful night role?
Just asking for proof here...
Meaty said:
Why am I the most suspicious?
Here is what happened:
I am accused of being the head jock.
I refute that claim with a good point and evidence.
Then, you guys say I'm a just a regular jock and am a suspicious person.
Is there any concrete proof whatsoever that I am a jock and/or have a powerful night role?
Just asking for proof here...
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8
Vote Count
Blah - 6 Votes
November 29 is the deadline.
Vote Count
Blah - 6 Votes
November 29 is the deadline.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8
Okay so I read all the pages of this day. You'll have to excuse me, but I feel like I'll go insane if I read anything more for the moment. Whatever I say next, keep in mind it is coming from someone who has only a day's worth of knowledge so if I miss something please be patient with me.
Anyway, so far as I have seen, Blah237 seems to be the popular vote at the moment. I can understand this; for one, his posts are extremely annoying and he seems to be scattering blame wherever he can put it. However, as has been pointed out, he is most likely neutral.
So I guess the question before I vote is if there are any theories on who might be of an enemy faction?
Two additional questions (thank you for your patience):
1. Nerds vs. Jocks. What do we know about them? Is one one of them like the Werewolves and the other an independent masonic-faction, or are they both equally like Werewolves?
2. PMJ. Apparently he can kill people. What are the specifics of his role?
Again, please be patient with me if I say something that appears misinformed. Like I said, I've got only a day's-worth of knowledge so keep that in mind.
Okay so I read all the pages of this day. You'll have to excuse me, but I feel like I'll go insane if I read anything more for the moment. Whatever I say next, keep in mind it is coming from someone who has only a day's worth of knowledge so if I miss something please be patient with me.
Anyway, so far as I have seen, Blah237 seems to be the popular vote at the moment. I can understand this; for one, his posts are extremely annoying and he seems to be scattering blame wherever he can put it. However, as has been pointed out, he is most likely neutral.
So I guess the question before I vote is if there are any theories on who might be of an enemy faction?
Two additional questions (thank you for your patience):
1. Nerds vs. Jocks. What do we know about them? Is one one of them like the Werewolves and the other an independent masonic-faction, or are they both equally like Werewolves?
2. PMJ. Apparently he can kill people. What are the specifics of his role?
Again, please be patient with me if I say something that appears misinformed. Like I said, I've got only a day's-worth of knowledge so keep that in mind.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8
PMJ's role was revealed night 1 that he is only able to kill people who have been suspicious of him, so since nobody is going to suspect a confirmed townie it means his role is basically only going to work on people suspicious of him day 1. Oh, and his role can only be used once (unless he kills himself to use it again, which I doubt will happen). Nerds and jocks are both as far as we can tell equally werewolf factions, although we aren't sure if nerds only need to wipe out jocks and vice versa, or if they have to kill everyone not allied with them.
PMJ's role was revealed night 1 that he is only able to kill people who have been suspicious of him, so since nobody is going to suspect a confirmed townie it means his role is basically only going to work on people suspicious of him day 1. Oh, and his role can only be used once (unless he kills himself to use it again, which I doubt will happen). Nerds and jocks are both as far as we can tell equally werewolf factions, although we aren't sure if nerds only need to wipe out jocks and vice versa, or if they have to kill everyone not allied with them.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8
Well, as said before, SR was replaced very quickly by you, and that would make sme think that he had an important role in the game. That could be a jock, or it could be just a good townie role, or he may have just PM'd in that he needed replacing early. People usually go for worst case scenario in this game, so they want to believe the first scenario. Looking back at it the evidence of you actually being a wolf is pretty slim.
Oh yeah, I forgot I still had my vote on blah.
Unvote: Blah237
Argetlam said:
Well, as said before, SR was replaced very quickly by you, and that would make sme think that he had an important role in the game. That could be a jock, or it could be just a good townie role, or he may have just PM'd in that he needed replacing early. People usually go for worst case scenario in this game, so they want to believe the first scenario. Looking back at it the evidence of you actually being a wolf is pretty slim.
Oh yeah, I forgot I still had my vote on blah.
Unvote: Blah237
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8
We currently have very few leads. Argetlam is being considered because he was replaced so quickly, but we don't really have enough solid evidence to lynch him yet. None of us really have any other ideas. I have a few, but for the sake of not throwing out random accusations I'll hold them for now.
PokeChamp said:
We currently have very few leads. Argetlam is being considered because he was replaced so quickly, but we don't really have enough solid evidence to lynch him yet. None of us really have any other ideas. I have a few, but for the sake of not throwing out random accusations I'll hold them for now.
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8
So, here's what I'm gonna say.
We have less than 2 days to vote. Barely enough people are active to get lynches in. We have only really 2 options in my opinion:
1.) Random Lynch. Someone important whom we don't know (the seer) or someone we do know (Meaty, the priest) could be killed.
2.) We vote off someone, such as Blah, who has tried numerous times to vote to lynch someone with little to no evidence. This tactic is just as bad as a random lynch, and will eventually force us into losing a key player.
I'm standing by my vote for Blah unless someone magically finds a better option (which I am not seeing right now).
So, here's what I'm gonna say.
We have less than 2 days to vote. Barely enough people are active to get lynches in. We have only really 2 options in my opinion:
1.) Random Lynch. Someone important whom we don't know (the seer) or someone we do know (Meaty, the priest) could be killed.
2.) We vote off someone, such as Blah, who has tried numerous times to vote to lynch someone with little to no evidence. This tactic is just as bad as a random lynch, and will eventually force us into losing a key player.
I'm standing by my vote for Blah unless someone magically finds a better option (which I am not seeing right now).
PMJ
Silhouette Gloom of the Sundown Lands
Forum Head
Articles Head
Elite Member
Advanced Member
Member
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8
Well, the fact that we don't know if that's how it works for sure notwithstanding, it wouldn't matter because the only way I would be able to actually use it on a confirmed wolf is if one was revealed during the night update and I survived the night. That still doesn't mean anything because the townies would obviously lynch the revealed wolf, rendering me useless. And even if they decided to lynch someone else and leave the revealed wolf to me (assuming they had suspected me), the wolves could just kill me off in order to save one of their own.
Yeah, I was, but I was thinking about formal suspicion here. Players of werewolf are always (or rather, should always be) suspicious of each other. Does that mean I could kill anyone I wanted? Highly unlikely. I'm certain Meaty is the only viable target, which leads me to toss this out there:
Meaty is obviously not a wolf, but what about you? Your awkward logic behind how my role works leads me to believe you're trying to make me appear more dangerous than I am. I'm convinced Blah isn't a wolf. What about you? If you can convince me otherwise, I'll respectfully withdraw, but I can't speak for everyone else...
Vote: Storm Blade
Blah237 said:
Well, the fact that we don't know if that's how it works for sure notwithstanding, it wouldn't matter because the only way I would be able to actually use it on a confirmed wolf is if one was revealed during the night update and I survived the night. That still doesn't mean anything because the townies would obviously lynch the revealed wolf, rendering me useless. And even if they decided to lynch someone else and leave the revealed wolf to me (assuming they had suspected me), the wolves could just kill me off in order to save one of their own.
Storm Blade said:
Yeah, I was, but I was thinking about formal suspicion here. Players of werewolf are always (or rather, should always be) suspicious of each other. Does that mean I could kill anyone I wanted? Highly unlikely. I'm certain Meaty is the only viable target, which leads me to toss this out there:
Meaty is obviously not a wolf, but what about you? Your awkward logic behind how my role works leads me to believe you're trying to make me appear more dangerous than I am. I'm convinced Blah isn't a wolf. What about you? If you can convince me otherwise, I'll respectfully withdraw, but I can't speak for everyone else...
Vote: Storm Blade
RE: Werewolf XI "Revenge of the Nerds" - Day 3 End 11/29/2011 7AM GMT+8
I honestly don't know what to do at this point. I think I'll hold my vote for now.
I honestly don't know what to do at this point. I think I'll hold my vote for now.
- Status