Finished Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Game Over! A winner is PMJ and RogueChomp

Status
Not open for further replies.
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 2 ends Saturday, Oct 5 at 12pm MST

SheNinja said:
DNA, we said do you have any evidence besides meta.
Click to expand...

You know what really stands out to me in this post? The word "we". Interesting.

Because you know who jumped to SheNinja's defense just a bit ago to try and steer the bandwagon in a different direction? Sir Taco. To me, it seems like a last minute ditch to try and save a fellow scum member, and it's only reinforced by the fact that SheNinja considers them a group.

I say that we should continue the SheNinja lynch, and if he flips scum, we hammer Sir Taco tomorrow.

And by the way, to answer your question, your attempt to accuse DNA came off as extremely scummy. That's the other main reason as to why you're being voted for, along with the fact that you've been behaving very differently from how you normally do.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 2 ends Saturday, Oct 5 at 12pm MST

^You bring up good points...someone else said we and it bugged me but I forgot and will have to look back.

So four arms..

Pointing out things that stand out along the way from individuals as to why theyre scummy and eventually posting cases as to why they are big lynch candidates and refusing to repost said cases each time a player is too lazy to read for him/herself

Is the same as...

Players not presenting any credible evidence against whom they think is playing differently and me asking those players for a solid case?

Yep, I must be a hypocrite. Difference is, ive posted a case multiple times on my suspects while who im questiong for evidence hasn't posted any. Clearly this is bad logic because its the same in your eyes right? Comprehension is key...


If tokyotoots is right about never voting sheninja, I'm pretty sure raichugirl is scum. Tokyo just quoted where raichugirl said tokyo is more scummy. It could be a bus but either way, if the bus/statement about tokyo being scum because of him jumping on the sheninja wagon ends up bieng false, I think raichugirl is defiinite scum.

You,kniw what I find interesting...that no one has thought about sillykyle's role. Im sure you are glad camo talk but the "Silencer-esque" role is ypusually not town aligned. You all skipped over that tidbit...
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 2 ends Saturday, Oct 5 at 12pm MST

^I disagree. I've thought about sillykyle's role. :>
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 2 ends Saturday, Oct 5 at 12pm MST

I'd have to disagree as well. There's a type of role normally called the Jailer that's usually town-aligned, and "jails" a player for a certain amount of time. A lot of the time, the Jailer is the only one who can talk to that person. Sillykyle, are you still able to talk to camo, or is it just a complete silence? And would you be willing to tell us how long it will last? I mean, I get your reasoning for using it on camo (I probably would have done likewise with an ability like that... lol), but if you could give us some more of the details, then that would be helpful. Any town aligned player would be willing to do this, so I'd suggest that you do so.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 2 ends Saturday, Oct 5 at 12pm MST

sillykyle said:
Alright, here goes. I kidnapped Camoclone. My ability allows me to kidnap someone until the end of the day, making them unable to post, receive votes, or communicate with anyone outside the thread except me. Since he's able to talk to me and no one else, he already knows who kidnapped him, and will just tell everyone during the night meaning there's no point in me trying to keep it a secret. As for why I targeted him, I truly believe that the town will be more productive during the day without him constantly shoving his way into things with his wild accusations and nonsense logic. Love ya buddy! <3
Click to expand...

See SS, it's not that hard to quote posts if someone missed something.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 2 ends Saturday, Oct 5 at 12pm MST

I know what the jailer or jailor is, I also know what a jail keeper is. Dependant on the mod of course but the jailers main role is to roleblock anything targeting the jailed while also having the jailed person not able to target anyone either. You don't see it too often either so other than that, its usually a scum aligned player in my experience.

I didna t miss your post sillykyle, just wondering why everyone believes everything at first glance is all. I didn't even say I doubted you, I said it was interesting that no one brought it up after you posted it.

Notw that I asked that question you've cleared up some of my curiousity. Especially since twistedturtwig didn't question you before but now all of a sudden wants you to elaborate. Perculiar indeed.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 2 ends Saturday, Oct 5 at 12pm MST

I didn't say you missed it, I said TT missed it. ;)
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 2 ends Saturday, Oct 5 at 12pm MST

SoldiersSpirit said:
If tokyotoots is right about never voting sheninja, I'm pretty sure raichugirl is scum. Tokyo just quoted where raichugirl said tokyo is more scummy. It could be a bus but either way, if the bus/statement about tokyo being scum because of him jumping on the sheninja wagon ends up bieng false, I think raichugirl is defiinite scum.

You,kniw what I find interesting...that no one has thought about sillykyle's role. Im sure you are glad camo talk but the "Silencer-esque" role is ypusually not town aligned. You all skipped over that tidbit...
Click to expand...

Interesting. I'd also like to know more about Raichu's case. Although, from the games I've seen Raichu in, she seems to like to work from behind.

On the note of Sillykyle... I don't know. You're right, it does seem a bit odd, considering how he phrased it. "I kidnapped Camoclone" seems a lot more menacing than "I put Camoclone in jail", but then again, wouldn't it be, like, the absolute worst idea in the world to come out and publicly say that you were the one who kidnapped Camoclone if you were a wolf? It could be reverse psychology, but still, it is a bit dangerous for a wolf to do.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 2 ends Saturday, Oct 5 at 12pm MST

I said kidnapping because that's what it says in the role and also in the post.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 2 ends Saturday, Oct 5 at 12pm MST

Yea, it was just perculiar that no one mentioned it, at all :/. Seer should have a good list of people to choose from this night.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 2 ends Saturday, Oct 5 at 12pm MST

Thanks for clearing that up, sillykyle. I hadn't remembered that you had already posted that.

And SS, the reason that I questioned him now instead of earlier is because the topic was brought back up again, by you, actually. I wasn't on PB when the first discussion about it took place, and by the time that I saw it, it had been buried under a bunch of other posts.

And here's one thing that I think really points to sillykyle's innocence. He's still able to communicate with camo. That's the one big difference between a Jailer and a Silencer. The scum would much prefer to completely silence a player, while a town aligned Jailer has the opportunity to learn information from the player they jail while simultaneously keeping them safe, in a sort of way. I can see why he'd want to silence camo; I'm sure 90% of us would want to, but all the same, camo's only a vanilla townie, (or a godfather; can't count that out), so either way, there's not much he can learn. Hopefully, if he has multiple uses of this ability, he'll be able to use it effectively to get some info out there for a townie, or jail a scum.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 2 ends Saturday, Oct 5 at 12pm MST

I read the last two pages to get an idea of the current situation but I need to catch up some earlier ones a bit later.

As a quick notice on the current themes.

I think that sillykyle is town. Not confirmed town, but the role is usually a townie role and I would treat it as such for the time being. Also, TT noticed an interesting aspect too, it seems. I would treat silly as 80% town or so lol.

Btw. I still think that SoldiersSpirit is town.

I haven't seen SheNinja's "role reveal", if you want me to see it soon, please quote it. Otherwise I'll check the rest of the thread in a few hours. (I'll go make food and do other stuff for now.)

PS.: I have 2222 posts and 666 PM:s! :O
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 2 ends Saturday, Oct 5 at 12pm MST

TwistedTurtwig said:
And here's one thing that I think really points to sillykyle's innocence. He's still able to communicate with camo. That's the one big difference between a Jailer and a Silencer. The scum would much prefer to completely silence a player, while a town aligned Jailer has the opportunity to learn information from the player they jail while simultaneously keeping them safe, in a sort of way. ... Hopefully, if he has multiple uses of this ability, he'll be able to use it effectively to get some info out there for a townie, or jail a scum.
Click to expand...

Didn't sillykyle say that he could communicate through an anonymous qt, and his reveal was totally unwarranted?

Also, if camoclone is smart, he will keep his mouth shut since sillykyle is definitely not confirmed town.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 2 ends Saturday, Oct 5 at 12pm MST

He says he can see what was done to the person he targets during the night. He claims that Camo was targeted by a kidnap and an alarm of some sort. This is going off of memory but I think that's what he said.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 2 ends Saturday, Oct 5 at 12pm MST

PMJ said:
TwistedTurtwig said:
And here's one thing that I think really points to sillykyle's innocence. He's still able to communicate with camo. That's the one big difference between a Jailer and a Silencer. The scum would much prefer to completely silence a player, while a town aligned Jailer has the opportunity to learn information from the player they jail while simultaneously keeping them safe, in a sort of way. ... Hopefully, if he has multiple uses of this ability, he'll be able to use it effectively to get some info out there for a townie, or jail a scum.
Click to expand...

Didn't sillykyle say that he could communicate through an anonymous qt, and his reveal was totally unwarranted?

Also, if camoclone is smart, he will keep his mouth shut since sillykyle is definitely not confirmed town.
Click to expand...

Yeah, I realized that right after I revealed. The role PM says nothing about it being anonymous or even a QT at all, the only way I found out was when I got the PM with the link and opened the QT. Scumbag Astra. :[

For anyone who's curious, Camoclone is just being his normal self and accusing random people such as Guy, James, Sheninja and myself.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 2 ends Saturday, Oct 5 at 12pm MST

He also claims that Four Arms was targeted by a vigilante, and was saved by LF. He won't say how he came to this conclusion.

Sorry for the triple post. :x
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 2 ends Saturday, Oct 5 at 12pm MST

I don't believe it. First of all, Luckyfire is notorious for doing nothing in werewolf except look scummy and get lynched and then take it. Seriously, I don't even know why people keep letting her play. So even if she did have some sort of protection role, I doubt she would use it unless she was scum and she was directed to use it on Four Arms, which would mean they're both scum.

If she's an Angel, she's indie, and I doubt she would even bother picking her target unless she was forced to.

And camoclone was supposed to be vt. He confirmed Red Rain as vt too, so I want to know how camo got this information. Only thing I can think of is they're either masons (unlikely since they could have just confirmed each other) or scum, and camo is just feeding sillykyle his partners' information.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 2 ends Saturday, Oct 5 at 12pm MST

camoclone is referring to the day 2 update, where LF (now dead) protected whoever Luigi is. Click Not sure how he figures Four Arms is Luigi though...
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 2 ends Saturday, Oct 5 at 12pm MST

sillykyle said:
He says he can see what was done to the person he targets during the night. He claims that Camo was targeted by a kidnap and an alarm of some sort. This is going off of memory but I think that's what he said.
Click to expand...

Yes, I recall this. You stated the kidnap was you, so that rules that out.
And I claimed that the alarm was me. The result is that camo's alignment wasn't changed.
 
RE: Werewolf XVIII: The Blank Game: Day 2 ends Saturday, Oct 5 at 12pm MST

DNA is scum and everyone should be on his wagon.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top