Kecleon-X said:
Your point of "we think you're scum because you might not be town" is faulty and, quite frankly, nonsensical. That logic can be used on everyone else, so I don't know why I seem to be a magnet for it. You can choose whether or not to believe my role as you wish, but you can stop tunneling any time now. But of course, that logic goes for literally everyone else, so why me, then? What's your logic? The "He could be dangerous" just isn't doing it for me. That is a stock justification that could be pulled out on anyone.
That logic IS being applied to all possible wolves. It's how we will win. I "magnet" you first, because you are the only possible wolf that can risk us losing with your ability. Do you recommend we take out the non-threatening possible wolves first? Where is your logic in that?
If I were a wolf, why would I use my actual role as my farce one? If I thought it would make me look suspicious, I would change it. Besides, I still don't know what you're afraid of. I use the ability once on someone I think is going to be a threat (i.e. not you), open a bottle of whiskey and have a good day (Jurassic Park reference). I still don't get why you see me as a threat. It's like arresting the guy with the gun in the room just because he has a gun.
Here you can find my sister's role (and how she died in my arms
): http://www.pokebeach.com/forums/thread-active-werewolf-xx-seleno-city-day-9-ends-thursday-april-24-at-8-pm-est?pid=2591426#pid2591426
Me being wolf and camo being town wouldn't make any sense, but if there is doubt about my role I'm sure it will be removed the next morning when I'm likely eaten and when the person I seer has their role publicly revealed due to my ability.
I never said you were. I was just wanting a refresher.
I'm glad you're okay with this plan. To me it seemed like you weren't before. If you really are town at least you'll still win despite being lynched today.
Wait, that's how that works? I skimmed the rules, so I could have missed it -- TT?
Right now your ability is not needed for us to win, since the confirmed town are a majority. Letting it exist amongst possible wolves is an unneeded and illogical risk to take in my opinion.
My previous point still stands. If I were a wolf, I wouldn't even tell you I had such an ability. I would come up with another role and just say that I had that one repeatedly, muttering of your ignorance of simple "facts". And then get lynched. Either way, it would be meaningless to incriminate myself by putting a scummy role out there.
Arguing over it is pointless. All four possible wolves will claim to be town. There is no way we can know for sure whom to believe, so the smartest thing to do is to take out the threats and continue lynching the possibles until both wolves hidden in it are gone.
This I agree with, though I just don't think that lynching a possibly helpful role would be a good idea. I mean, sure, I could target a Townie accidentally, but that just means that I cleared them as not the alpha. C'mon, man. You're making a big mistake.