Finished Werewolf XXI-0 - Left4TheWolves
- Thread starter WanderingWolf
- Start date
- Status
RE: Werewolf XXI-0 - Left4TheWolves - Day 1 ends 3rd July 9am AEST
Umm... what, Teal?
Like others have said, what you did was so incredibly anti-town it is not even bloody funny.
However, second of all, I saw the post as well just as it was posted (I can confirm that it said they need to send in their night actions, js) but I made a mental note of the names. I promptly forgot them. You clearly copy/pasted the post somewhere. Townies, generally, don't need that sort of information. Especially straight away. When it gets to claiming then maybe it's important but maybe not, because if I was one of those users I would sure as hell claim a night action. The fact that not only did you copy/paste the post somewhere (PROBABLY SCUMCHAT) but then use it to try and push a lynch on one of them the first day (it was a half-hearted attempt, yes, but it is quite clearly there) is just too scummy in my opinion, and on a day like this, will be, quite frankly, the best lead we'll get.
##AZURE: Teal
Umm... what, Teal?
Like others have said, what you did was so incredibly anti-town it is not even bloody funny.
However, second of all, I saw the post as well just as it was posted (I can confirm that it said they need to send in their night actions, js) but I made a mental note of the names. I promptly forgot them. You clearly copy/pasted the post somewhere. Townies, generally, don't need that sort of information. Especially straight away. When it gets to claiming then maybe it's important but maybe not, because if I was one of those users I would sure as hell claim a night action. The fact that not only did you copy/paste the post somewhere (PROBABLY SCUMCHAT) but then use it to try and push a lynch on one of them the first day (it was a half-hearted attempt, yes, but it is quite clearly there) is just too scummy in my opinion, and on a day like this, will be, quite frankly, the best lead we'll get.
##AZURE: Teal
RE: Werewolf XXI-0 - Left4TheWolves - Day 1 ends 3rd July 9am AEST
Please tell me I'm not the only one who read that post as a completely neutral way of calling out people who didn't confirm roles, just like you'd call out people who didn't vote. This entire line of discussion makes no sense to me.
Please tell me I'm not the only one who read that post as a completely neutral way of calling out people who didn't confirm roles, just like you'd call out people who didn't vote. This entire line of discussion makes no sense to me.
RE: Werewolf XXI-0 - Left4TheWolves - Day 1 ends 3rd July 9am AEST
That's the thing. Now it is, but before it was calling out 3 people who quote on quote "didn't send in night actions". This is information that a host should not reveal, yet WanderingWolf did. He edited it out, sure, but the damage was done and Teal, for whatever reason, decided it was a good cause for discussion.
"Hey, so these people have power roles..."
Athena said:
That's the thing. Now it is, but before it was calling out 3 people who quote on quote "didn't send in night actions". This is information that a host should not reveal, yet WanderingWolf did. He edited it out, sure, but the damage was done and Teal, for whatever reason, decided it was a good cause for discussion.
"Hey, so these people have power roles..."
RE: Werewolf XXI-0 - Left4TheWolves - Day 1 ends 3rd July 9am AEST
He undoubtedly did it to try and get a lynch on one of the 3. He definitely posted it in his scumchat as well (that's just basic logic) and I said that I thought he did in an earlier post as well. I just think that it was a shoddy attempt at getting one of the 3 lynched, which should back fire. Scum hate no lynches on Day 1 just as much as townies do, and it's much more of a neutral play to NL. Teal here is a real lead IMO, and is as good as we're going to get on Day 1. Don't forget, on Day 1 last game grant got a tip on you being scum from one of your posts, Athena (actually I really want to know what that scum tell was as well lol) and it was right. Teal's is actually much more noticeable.
Athena said:
He undoubtedly did it to try and get a lynch on one of the 3. He definitely posted it in his scumchat as well (that's just basic logic) and I said that I thought he did in an earlier post as well. I just think that it was a shoddy attempt at getting one of the 3 lynched, which should back fire. Scum hate no lynches on Day 1 just as much as townies do, and it's much more of a neutral play to NL. Teal here is a real lead IMO, and is as good as we're going to get on Day 1. Don't forget, on Day 1 last game grant got a tip on you being scum from one of your posts, Athena (actually I really want to know what that scum tell was as well lol) and it was right. Teal's is actually much more noticeable.
RE: Werewolf XXI-0 - Left4TheWolves - Day 1 ends 3rd July 9am AEST
##vote: alex
eww no D1 Lynch
Also, there was something in the post about Bisharp, Eron and Bryan needing to submit Night actions IIRC, but it must have been edited out.
##vote: alex
eww no D1 Lynch
Also, there was something in the post about Bisharp, Eron and Bryan needing to submit Night actions IIRC, but it must have been edited out.
RE: Werewolf XXI-0 - Left4TheWolves - Day 1 ends 3rd July 9am AEST
*still going through the post*
*still going through the post*
RE: Werewolf XXI-0 - Left4TheWolves - Day 1 ends 3rd July 9am AEST
UNVOTE: SHAMPOO THIEF
VOTE: REV3RSOR
The real question is why Rev3rsor wasn't reading the thread. The ability slip made by WW doesn't matter one bit because of this everyone was required to submit something regardless if they had a usable ability or not (check the OP).
lol no. I'm not falling for that one.sillykyle said:
UNVOTE: SHAMPOO THIEF
VOTE: REV3RSOR
The real question is why Rev3rsor wasn't reading the thread. The ability slip made by WW doesn't matter one bit because of this everyone was required to submit something regardless if they had a usable ability or not (check the OP).
RE: Werewolf XXI-0 - Left4TheWolves - Day 1 ends 3rd July 9am AEST
Celever:
- If I was scum I wouldn't let the town know this info because in that case scum has it anyway so there would be no point to post that.
- I'm trying to generate discussion. (I succeeded.)
- I said I feel they are town, I'm not pushing their lynch in any way.
- Actually, I always do some notes in a Word document when I play WW to keep up with my reads. However in this case I didn't since I didn't think he would edit it out (it's just as criminal as a player editing a post, how can a host even do that!). I only remembered Eron from the names because I have a closer impression of him (although I guess I might remember wrong, but I'm 99% sure) but the two other names are still in the post as "roles unconfirmed" so it was enough to remember that one name. By the off-chance I remebered "Eron" wrong, pretty sure the only one I could mix him up from the player list is Cinesra. (Sorry, Cinesra?)
I have to say, you have gotten better at this game since the beginning of the last game though~ (not saying you are right about me being a wolf though lol).
Celever:
- If I was scum I wouldn't let the town know this info because in that case scum has it anyway so there would be no point to post that.
- I'm trying to generate discussion. (I succeeded.)
- I said I feel they are town, I'm not pushing their lynch in any way.
- Actually, I always do some notes in a Word document when I play WW to keep up with my reads. However in this case I didn't since I didn't think he would edit it out (it's just as criminal as a player editing a post, how can a host even do that!). I only remembered Eron from the names because I have a closer impression of him (although I guess I might remember wrong, but I'm 99% sure) but the two other names are still in the post as "roles unconfirmed" so it was enough to remember that one name. By the off-chance I remebered "Eron" wrong, pretty sure the only one I could mix him up from the player list is Cinesra. (Sorry, Cinesra?)
I have to say, you have gotten better at this game since the beginning of the last game though~ (not saying you are right about me being a wolf though lol).
RE: Werewolf XXI-0 - Left4TheWolves - Day 1 ends 3rd July 9am AEST
Sorry, but I'm going to have to doubt that. He's said that it makes him feel they're more likely to be inno than wolf, which would mean he wouldn't want them lynched, and he hasn't made any moves to lynch or vote for any of them, either.
Celever said:
Sorry, but I'm going to have to doubt that. He's said that it makes him feel they're more likely to be inno than wolf, which would mean he wouldn't want them lynched, and he hasn't made any moves to lynch or vote for any of them, either.
RE: Werewolf XXI-0 - Left4TheWolves - Day 1 ends 3rd July 9am AEST
I'm with Camo for once; I do think it's a pointless discussion, which is part of why I'm harping on Celever for grasping onto it so tightly. It was kind of a crap move for WW to make, since it points out PRs to the Wolves since they know who's Wolf and who's Inno, but it's not useful at all to us.
I'm with Camo for once; I do think it's a pointless discussion, which is part of why I'm harping on Celever for grasping onto it so tightly. It was kind of a crap move for WW to make, since it points out PRs to the Wolves since they know who's Wolf and who's Inno, but it's not useful at all to us.
RE: Werewolf XXI-0 - Left4TheWolves - Day 1 ends 3rd July 9am AEST
Celever is grasping for straws because it is day 1. Little things become big things. However I'm incredibly troubled by Celever saying that Teal wants to lynch them. Now that Teal has started this discussion we can't ignore it.
Celever is grasping for straws because it is day 1. Little things become big things. However I'm incredibly troubled by Celever saying that Teal wants to lynch them. Now that Teal has started this discussion we can't ignore it.
RE: Werewolf XXI-0 - Left4TheWolves - Day 1 ends 3rd July 9am AEST
Looks like I'll be joining the party. I've got a few things to say, but I'm about to rush out the door for cross country practice, so I'll collect my thoughts when I return.
Looks like I'll be joining the party. I've got a few things to say, but I'm about to rush out the door for cross country practice, so I'll collect my thoughts when I return.
RE: Werewolf XXI-0 - Left4TheWolves - Day 1 ends 3rd July 9am AEST
Grasping for straws is one thing, holding tightly onto one of those straws and defending it to such an extent as Celever already has is another. The only thing that's stopping me from voting him is that I'm not sure if Scum would stick their neck out so far in defense of a theory so early on D1, since it seems like it would call too much attention (as it has).
Camoclone said:
Grasping for straws is one thing, holding tightly onto one of those straws and defending it to such an extent as Celever already has is another. The only thing that's stopping me from voting him is that I'm not sure if Scum would stick their neck out so far in defense of a theory so early on D1, since it seems like it would call too much attention (as it has).
- Status