OK, you don't make sense rn.
I make sense you just don't agree.
OK, you make sense literately. Your arguments, however, do not. Please provide reasoning, not statements and nothing else...
Personally I prefer no lynches D1 and it is how we play on a couple other sites,
The very very very good players on mafia sites hardly ever no-lynch d1. They only no lynch in special situations. This is not a special situation.
In an elite game no lynching is a poor decision, I agree - a no lynch in an expert rank game (of which I have participated in several) is an idiotic idea. In a regular game it is a feasible strategy. Please try and realize the difference.
but I realize that the metagame for werewolf is different here so I tend not to give no lynch a real thought while playing here.
Why would the metagame matter at all? Every game we have this discussion so you have never really given it any thought? That surprises me.
Because on some sites no lynching is a well-thought out option Day 1. On this site it is shot down immediately. I never give No Lynching a serious mention because of the aforementioned reason.
However, alex has a point. No more posts after this
You can't tell anyone not to post after this. They can answer if they want to. If I were scum and I didn't know the answer to these questions they would simply post it in the scum chat (assuming a scum chat exists this game).
OK please tell me you looked confused over this sarcastically? I was setting the scene for the example below ffs. If I didn't want people to post I wouldn't put it in a couple of words in a sentence, that whole statement was absolutely idiotic and it is a waste of my time to even reply to ot as on-depth as I have done.
- what will I learn from your lynch?
This is a silly question. What my role is. What to think of my reads. What the next course of action is.
OK, how do these help? Your reads on D1 are useless speculation. Not helpful. Your role being outed is not helpful. Tell me how it is helpful. The next course of action will not be dictated based on your flip. If it is this is an awful town.
You have given no helpful opinions
Irrelevant.
You have given no helpful opinions because it is impossible to do so on Day 1 99.99% of the time. Don't take it as a personal attack! >~>
and like alex said giving us your deceased role is neither helpful nor detrimental, unless there is a random cc flying around the town. On D1 this will not happen.
Ehh no. Of course it's helpful.
How is it bloody helpful!? Statements are useless and frivolous without evidence or basic reasoning to back them up. I say that your flipped role is useless; prove me wrong.
Don't forget, your opinion alone isn't good enough
Ummm ok. This is off topic.
It isn't good enough without a case. I wasn't talking about your opinion personally, I was using it plurally. I should have used "one" but whatever, you knew what I meant.
We need to look at your posts and see if you actually had a case or feasible reason for suspecting the person, and so far you have neither.
What are you hinting at? I haven't even attacked someone yet.
Because some time in this Day 1 you will build an awful case on one or more people, and they will then be a townie. I guarantee it, seriously,
This is why No Lynching is important on Day 1 to me.
I haven't seen solid logic yet. You haven't pushed for it in the past.
False. I even stated that I have pushed for it in the past. Last game, in fact! Back up your claims with evidence, PLEASE. This is also a full post of solid logic; please actually counter it.
In fact, lynching is a little detrimental. It leads to a lot of speculation D2 and can often make the entire day a bit of a trainwreck,
Yeah my bad. We should never ever lynch. If lynching results in a train wreck when is it ever ok to lynch?
You know what's annoying? When people troll others by taking wording literally, both online and IRL. This entire post is about lynching on Day 1. I shouldn't have to say "lynching on Day 1" every single time. For crying out loud please read the post as a post and not as a bunch of out of context sentences. You and I both know that that is an awful way to play Werewolf, or any online thing.
and after a lynch on D1 the wolves are in a perfect position to set up speculation with their kill.
You left out the fact that this applies both ways. The town can use lynch info too.
They cannot. I pointed this out in my post, for the rest of my answer to this read the last 2 sentences of the last reply I made. Together.
I'm not saying that a lynch Day 1 is always a bad thing - not at all - I am saying that No Lynch is so much more viable than people on this site give it credit for.
No lynch D1 is not that viable unless in extreme situations.
Sure, in expert games. In intermediate games? Not so much.
I stood up for No Lynch last game too, FYI, so this isn't off for my playstyle; just in case you mention it!
Ok...
Why would you not change your previous statement about me never mentioning it before once your read this sentence? I countered the argument before you even made it yet you still put it in your post. This is why it is hugely anti-village having you in this game, whether you're a member of the town or not.
