Finished Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Town Wins
- Thread starter TheGuy
- Start date
- Status
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
It's quite simple. Scum wants to gain town creds. Therefore they will defend a townie and when the townie flips town they will push the lynch and / or gain town creds. Alex has never shown any doubt about Luis being town. It's a common strategy.
It's quite simple. Scum wants to gain town creds. Therefore they will defend a townie and when the townie flips town they will push the lynch and / or gain town creds. Alex has never shown any doubt about Luis being town. It's a common strategy.
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
I don't think you got what I mean...
You said that if alex flips scum that makes Luis a primary suspect. Yet at the same time you admitted that if alex was scum, he would protect a townie. What you said makes no sense. Unless you imply that alex is using reverse psychology, based on the fact that no one would ever expect him to be scum and defend scum so strongly. But I don't see where you implied that... not to mention how dangerous it is, risking to lose not one, but two scum members when the whole town is alive.
I don't think you got what I mean...
You said that if alex flips scum that makes Luis a primary suspect. Yet at the same time you admitted that if alex was scum, he would protect a townie. What you said makes no sense. Unless you imply that alex is using reverse psychology, based on the fact that no one would ever expect him to be scum and defend scum so strongly. But I don't see where you implied that... not to mention how dangerous it is, risking to lose not one, but two scum members when the whole town is alive.
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
It works both ways. Alex was defending Luis way too much. If Alex does flip scum then we should watch Luis closely. I could most definitely see scumbuddies defending each other like this D1. On the flip side I could also see scum defending a townie.Chaos Jackal said:
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
So what you're pretty much saying is that whenever a player seems to intensely defend another, and one of them is lynched, then we should keep an eye on the other no matter what the lynched guys flipped as. Well, that's a bit obvious.
What are the chances of a bartender role who's like a spy for the nobility? A role PM like this could easily be faked to look as if the bartender is with the Revolution. Then again, why would that work... unless Robespierre is having a drink there, I can see no reason why the nobles would have a follower... besides, a common citizen like a bartender during the Revolution wasn't generally an enemy of it (if only out of fear) and even more a supporter of the king.
Funny, but it looks like I need more insight on the way the host is thinking and his knowledge of the French Revolution rather than the way Luis is thinking and his knowledge of the game. I can't be sure about him yet, so I'll keep my vote on Wailord.
So what you're pretty much saying is that whenever a player seems to intensely defend another, and one of them is lynched, then we should keep an eye on the other no matter what the lynched guys flipped as. Well, that's a bit obvious.
What are the chances of a bartender role who's like a spy for the nobility? A role PM like this could easily be faked to look as if the bartender is with the Revolution. Then again, why would that work... unless Robespierre is having a drink there, I can see no reason why the nobles would have a follower... besides, a common citizen like a bartender during the Revolution wasn't generally an enemy of it (if only out of fear) and even more a supporter of the king.
Funny, but it looks like I need more insight on the way the host is thinking and his knowledge of the French Revolution rather than the way Luis is thinking and his knowledge of the game. I can't be sure about him yet, so I'll keep my vote on Wailord.
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
This doesn't apply every time but it most definitely applies between Luis and Alex. Especially because Alex is defending Luis without a doubt.Chaos Jackal said:
I don't know. I truly believe that Alex and Luis are good lynches with Wailord close behind. I do know that Luis's claimed role could easily be faked and it could very well be a safeclaim or the example role (that The Guy gave the wolves).Chaos Jackal said:
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
I think everybody that is defending Luis is doing so because your reasoning just doesn't make any sense. I would also rather go for an inactive member. Someone mentioned Wailord, and I'm fine with that too. Obviously I can't vote due to Luis (seriously man, don't do that again), but unless he gets active and starts to contribute I think that's an okay lynch for D1.
I think everybody that is defending Luis is doing so because your reasoning just doesn't make any sense. I would also rather go for an inactive member. Someone mentioned Wailord, and I'm fine with that too. Obviously I can't vote due to Luis (seriously man, don't do that again), but unless he gets active and starts to contribute I think that's an okay lynch for D1.
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
Had to choose someone, blame Random.org.
And anyways, even though It somewhat helps that Alex is supporting me, it does seems interesting that he does not doubt me at all. Just saying. I mean, thanks, don't get me wrong, but I somehow have to agree with Camo that it's very possible that they're holding me for a reason, maybe a N1 Kill?
Drohn said:
Had to choose someone, blame Random.org.
And anyways, even though It somewhat helps that Alex is supporting me, it does seems interesting that he does not doubt me at all. Just saying. I mean, thanks, don't get me wrong, but I somehow have to agree with Camo that it's very possible that they're holding me for a reason, maybe a N1 Kill?
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
Keeper of Night 2
RaichuGirl 2
sillykyle 2
Guts 2
WanderingWolf 1
Sorry for the double post, but on the other hand, one of the above (except for WW since he died from not having enough Internet to live from) makes more sense to me for a lynch, if we go for the inactives.
Keeper of Night 2
RaichuGirl 2
sillykyle 2
Guts 2
WanderingWolf 1
Sorry for the double post, but on the other hand, one of the above (except for WW since he died from not having enough Internet to live from) makes more sense to me for a lynch, if we go for the inactives.
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
.
@Luis who are you going to use your ability on tonight and why? There is no reason for you not to tell us at this point.
The reasoning makes sense and the logic is mostly sound. The only thing that makes me not want to lynch Luis today is because we can easily make sure he uses his role to help the town. If he is a wolf then he will be forced to target scummy users with his ability. He will still have to go before MYLO or LYLO unfortunately. The gambit on Luis was good but it won't work again so don't worry about it. Also you can't vote at allDrohn said:
.@Luis who are you going to use your ability on tonight and why? There is no reason for you not to tell us at this point.
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
Ninjad by Luis so it wasn't a double post. x.x Anyway two of them are subs, so I would go for RaichuGirl, Guts, or Teal who had time to spam random comments and obviously read what was going on based on the replies, but not to contribute.
Ninjad by Luis so it wasn't a double post. x.x Anyway two of them are subs, so I would go for RaichuGirl, Guts, or Teal who had time to spam random comments and obviously read what was going on based on the replies, but not to contribute.
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
Inactives will get modkilled eventually. And they give us little to no information. I'd rather lynch Alex, Luis, or Wailord (a bit less than the others). At the very least they will give us very valuable information to analyze.
Luis I hate to say this but the wolves won't kill you. I wish they did (it would help the town) but your role simply isn't strong enough for them to be afraid of it.Luispipe8 said:Drohn said:
Had to choose someone, blame Random.org.
Drohn said:
Inactives will get modkilled eventually. And they give us little to no information. I'd rather lynch Alex, Luis, or Wailord (a bit less than the others). At the very least they will give us very valuable information to analyze.
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
You said the same thing about me last game...
Camoclone said:
You said the same thing about me last game...
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
KoN is a sub, RG hasn't logged in in forever and WW isn't actually playing; he didn't even receive his role. I haven't checked SK and Guts, so IDK if they have been on PB or not recently, (and iPad) so if someone else could do it that'd be great.
I don't see anything explicitly scummy with Wailord honestly and it seems like a worse wagon than Luis to me... He is acting like a new townie with little time on his hands IMO.
Drohn said:
KoN is a sub, RG hasn't logged in in forever and WW isn't actually playing; he didn't even receive his role. I haven't checked SK and Guts, so IDK if they have been on PB or not recently, (and iPad) so if someone else could do it that'd be great.
I don't see anything explicitly scummy with Wailord honestly and it seems like a worse wagon than Luis to me... He is acting like a new townie with little time on his hands IMO.
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
If anyone is lurking, it's Twisted Turtwig. And if anyone is bandwagoning it's Scorched Feathers.
Just putting it out there. I don't necessarily consider either of them scumtells but I know other people do.
If anyone is lurking, it's Twisted Turtwig. And if anyone is bandwagoning it's Scorched Feathers.
Just putting it out there. I don't necessarily consider either of them scumtells but I know other people do.
- Status