Finished Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Town Wins
- Thread starter TheGuy
- Start date
- Status
PMJ
Silhouette Gloom of the Sundown Lands
Forum Head
Articles Head
Elite Member
Advanced Member
Member
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
Lugia's reveal is highly suspicious. Even though Lugia is telling the truth about Drohn's role, he (Lugia) is not confirmed town.
Lugia's reveal is highly suspicious. Even though Lugia is telling the truth about Drohn's role, he (Lugia) is not confirmed town.
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
Sorry. I was just trying to see if I could supply some info that you could use your super-epic-detective-skills-that-are-fuelled-by-your-huge-experience. Also TheGuy sorry about breaking my rule. I take full responsibility and I hope to not mess up like that in the future.
PMJ said:
Sorry. I was just trying to see if I could supply some info that you could use your super-epic-detective-skills-that-are-fuelled-by-your-huge-experience. Also TheGuy sorry about breaking my rule. I take full responsibility and I hope to not mess up like that in the future.
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
Mimes, in fact, aren't supposed to talk.And God smites Lugia123 for breaking his speech impediment twice (Not even one hour after his warning.)
The day will continue.
I'd also like to mention that the following people have yet to post this day: WanderingWolf, Haunted Water, Guts, and RaichuGirl.
There are 26 Eligible Votes, meaning that 14 are required to lynch.
Mimes, in fact, aren't supposed to talk.And God smites Lugia123 for breaking his speech impediment twice (Not even one hour after his warning.)
Role said:
The day will continue.
I'd also like to mention that the following people have yet to post this day: WanderingWolf, Haunted Water, Guts, and RaichuGirl.
There are 26 Eligible Votes, meaning that 14 are required to lynch.
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
##Waitttt a minuteeeee!
According to that role he should never have gotten my ability, since I did not PM you and therefore didn't use my ability.
Also, kinda sucks for me that my role got shown here even though he was't supposed to talk. Luckily it's not a huge loss for the town, since my role didn't seem that strong. Unless I could get a super powerful item that kills wolves!
This does at least confirm me as town I think, so I likely won't be lynched today and that means I did better than last game. I'm pretty sure wolves don't like it when people are confirmed town so I don't expect to live much longer now.
##Waitttt a minuteeeee!
According to that role he should never have gotten my ability, since I did not PM you and therefore didn't use my ability.
Also, kinda sucks for me that my role got shown here even though he was't supposed to talk. Luckily it's not a huge loss for the town, since my role didn't seem that strong. Unless I could get a super powerful item that kills wolves!
This does at least confirm me as town I think, so I likely won't be lynched today and that means I did better than last game.
I'm pretty sure wolves don't like it when people are confirmed town so I don't expect to live much longer now. 
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
##UNHail: Drohn
We're getting nowhere right now. lots of talk that keep circling back
##SHOOT: Luispipe8
##UNHail: Drohn
We're getting nowhere right now. lots of talk that keep circling back
##SHOOT: Luispipe8
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
Why did Lugia have to do that... Such a role essentially has seering capabilities.
Why did Lugia have to do that... Such a role essentially has seering capabilities.
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
End the tyrannical reign of the Fire Lord!
Your role has a few things that are making me unsure of you. For one, your description clearly says you don't care either way who wins. You are happy to go along with the Reign of Terror, eh?
Also, your ability makes it seem like you are playing a game with more people, since whoever gets the highest card is the winner. Who are these others?
I don't think you are a wolf, but I think it is very possible you are an indie and you aren't revealing everything in your role.
Drohn said:
End the tyrannical reign of the Fire Lord!
Your role has a few things that are making me unsure of you. For one, your description clearly says you don't care either way who wins. You are happy to go along with the Reign of Terror, eh?
Also, your ability makes it seem like you are playing a game with more people, since whoever gets the highest card is the winner. Who are these others?
I don't think you are a wolf, but I think it is very possible you are an indie and you aren't revealing everything in your role.
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
I find his role fairly believable all things considered. While his description does say that he doesn't care either way who wins, I feel as if that might just be poor wording. Personally, my Role PM doesn't say "you don't want x faction to win because..." it just describes me as a character. It also says "you don't care for the revolution" as opposed to not caring who wins -- that just means he doesn't like getting in the thick of it, not that he doesn't take any sides at all.
I did a bit of research on the "Reign of Terror" (it was a thing irl) and it looks like the whole thing was about executing people who opposed the revolution, so that fits just fine, I believe.
I noticed the thing about the "other players" too and I came to two conclusions:
1) There are other literal players in the game with this role spread among the three factions and possibly a wolfie.
2) These are not literal players and TheGuy instead randomizes numbers at night and has the flavour of them being different players.
However you are correct in that it is not a standard mafia role, and as such we should proceed with caution of some description with Drohn. I think he has made overall town plays, though, and he is an awful liar. I'm not saying he won't, but I feel like it'll be easier to tell if he does lie than most other players lol.
Shampoo Thief said:
I find his role fairly believable all things considered. While his description does say that he doesn't care either way who wins, I feel as if that might just be poor wording. Personally, my Role PM doesn't say "you don't want x faction to win because..." it just describes me as a character. It also says "you don't care for the revolution" as opposed to not caring who wins -- that just means he doesn't like getting in the thick of it, not that he doesn't take any sides at all.
I did a bit of research on the "Reign of Terror" (it was a thing irl) and it looks like the whole thing was about executing people who opposed the revolution, so that fits just fine, I believe.
I noticed the thing about the "other players" too and I came to two conclusions:
1) There are other literal players in the game with this role spread among the three factions and possibly a wolfie.
2) These are not literal players and TheGuy instead randomizes numbers at night and has the flavour of them being different players.
However you are correct in that it is not a standard mafia role, and as such we should proceed with caution of some description with Drohn. I think he has made overall town plays, though, and he is an awful liar. I'm not saying he won't, but I feel like it'll be easier to tell if he does lie than most other players lol.
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
Don't rush to call someone an awful liar. Behind a computer screen, nearly everyone can become a good liar. This role could easily fit an indie, and saying that Drohn is an awful liar doesn't really prove anything. He's played in how many games? One? Two? And he's done what? Reveal his role Day 1? You can't classify someone as a bad liar based on that, especially given the fact that you see no facial expressions, breathing, or motions, but just his words typed in a forum post.
Don't rush to call someone an awful liar. Behind a computer screen, nearly everyone can become a good liar. This role could easily fit an indie, and saying that Drohn is an awful liar doesn't really prove anything. He's played in how many games? One? Two? And he's done what? Reveal his role Day 1? You can't classify someone as a bad liar based on that, especially given the fact that you see no facial expressions, breathing, or motions, but just his words typed in a forum post.
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
Actually Drohn's one of my best friends on PokéBeach and we talk on Skype a lot. If I ever need an honest opinion I just contact him because he just doesn't lie. While he has admitted he will do it in Werewolf, I think that we would be able to tell when he does.
Besides, the whole case isn't just built on "he can't lie" because the main argument for that not being a town role is that it implies several people have the role, which would be spread among several different factions. However, it seems likely to me that if this is the case then we will have at least one, maybe two on the town, so Drohn could very easily be that townie. I did point out that we have to treat him with some kind of caution, though.
Chaos Jackal said:
Actually Drohn's one of my best friends on PokéBeach and we talk on Skype a lot
. If I ever need an honest opinion I just contact him because he just doesn't lie. While he has admitted he will do it in Werewolf, I think that we would be able to tell when he does.Besides, the whole case isn't just built on "he can't lie" because the main argument for that not being a town role is that it implies several people have the role, which would be spread among several different factions. However, it seems likely to me that if this is the case then we will have at least one, maybe two on the town, so Drohn could very easily be that townie. I did point out that we have to treat him with some kind of caution, though.
PMJ
Silhouette Gloom of the Sundown Lands
Forum Head
Articles Head
Elite Member
Advanced Member
Member
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
Time to make good on my promise.
I don't think you understood my post.
I am not saying that you are scum for targeting Drohn with your night action. I'm saying that the act of removing the town's main weapon against the scum is anti-town. The more players that can't vote, the easier it is for the scum to control the lynch.
It's a role that can be of either alignment (if you hit scum, it makes it harder for them to control the lynch).
My point is that even if you are town, your role in the grand scheme of things is of little consequence, so losing it would not be all that detrimental. It wouldn't be all that helpful until the late game (and that's only assuming you are hitting scum every day with it), and No Lynch is not an option for me. I will always be ready to roll the dice if there's a chance we can hit scum. It's classic risk vs reward.
On that note, great job Lugia getting yourself modkilled. clap.gif
ST brings up a good point, Drohn. I'm interested in hearing your explanation.
Time to make good on my promise.
Luispipe8 said:
I don't think you understood my post.
I am not saying that you are scum for targeting Drohn with your night action. I'm saying that the act of removing the town's main weapon against the scum is anti-town. The more players that can't vote, the easier it is for the scum to control the lynch.
It's a role that can be of either alignment (if you hit scum, it makes it harder for them to control the lynch).
My point is that even if you are town, your role in the grand scheme of things is of little consequence, so losing it would not be all that detrimental. It wouldn't be all that helpful until the late game (and that's only assuming you are hitting scum every day with it), and No Lynch is not an option for me. I will always be ready to roll the dice if there's a chance we can hit scum. It's classic risk vs reward.
On that note, great job Lugia getting yourself modkilled. clap.gif
ST brings up a good point, Drohn. I'm interested in hearing your explanation.
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
If you ask my friends, they'll tell you I don't lie. But this is WW, and I have the whole cyberspace covering for me. Lying becomes easy.
The role description is kinda bad, however I doubt that there are more people with that role. There are twenty decks; they don't match the number of players, and I can't believe that there are twenty people having that role. Perhaps, when saying "players", TheGuy might not even refer to in-game players, but rather those shady guys in the pub where Drohn's character plays cards. His role could easily be "You have a one-in-twenty chance to get an item". Given the fact that we have heard nothing of items this day, we can assume that item(s) are powerful. So a one-in-twenty chance could be justified more than having a random number of in-game players with the exact same ability of drawing. Besides, if they had, how would the ability work? They would all have to use it together, or something else? What if all of them died except one? Would he win by default? There are too many questions rising from saying that there are more players with the ability, and it's impossible that the description wouldn't have adressed at least one of them. Either Drohn has hidden something about his role, or it's just a gambling role with a chance of getting an item. And I'm more inclined to believe the latter.
If you ask my friends, they'll tell you I don't lie. But this is WW, and I have the whole cyberspace covering for me. Lying becomes easy.
The role description is kinda bad, however I doubt that there are more people with that role. There are twenty decks; they don't match the number of players, and I can't believe that there are twenty people having that role. Perhaps, when saying "players", TheGuy might not even refer to in-game players, but rather those shady guys in the pub where Drohn's character plays cards. His role could easily be "You have a one-in-twenty chance to get an item". Given the fact that we have heard nothing of items this day, we can assume that item(s) are powerful. So a one-in-twenty chance could be justified more than having a random number of in-game players with the exact same ability of drawing. Besides, if they had, how would the ability work? They would all have to use it together, or something else? What if all of them died except one? Would he win by default? There are too many questions rising from saying that there are more players with the ability, and it's impossible that the description wouldn't have adressed at least one of them. Either Drohn has hidden something about his role, or it's just a gambling role with a chance of getting an item. And I'm more inclined to believe the latter.
PMJ
Silhouette Gloom of the Sundown Lands
Forum Head
Articles Head
Elite Member
Advanced Member
Member
RE: Werewolf XXII: The Reign of Terror - Day 1 Ends August 2nd
The thing that bugs me about that theory is that if these were theoretical players (that Drohn was competing with), TheGuy would have differentiated them from the players that Drohn must pass the winning item to in some way.
Plus, "one in twenty" is the same thing as 5%. No item could justify such odds unless it was mind-blowingly OP.
Chaos Jackal said:
The thing that bugs me about that theory is that if these were theoretical players (that Drohn was competing with), TheGuy would have differentiated them from the players that Drohn must pass the winning item to in some way.
Plus, "one in twenty" is the same thing as 5%. No item could justify such odds unless it was mind-blowingly OP.
- Status