Machamp the Champion said:
I don't like how you're withholding information from the town. All it takes is 1 scum to find it for all the others to know it, so it's probably best if you just tell the town so they don't have to waste their time.
... Seriously?
I told Luispipe in exact detail how I deduced who your doublevoter could be. And since it is a post that everyone could see, I wouldn't be able to stop everyone from doing it too. It may have been roundabout, but it was in no way "withholding information." If that had been my intent, then I wouldn't have posted that I had figured out who it could be AND how I did so. And if I were a wolf, I wouldn't even bother posting it in public and just go tell my teammates directly in the wolf chat if I were "withholding information". Your accusation is preposterous.
And if you were to ask "Why didn't I just say it directly?" It's because it's a
deduction... and deductions can be wrong.
I could be wrong. So I ain't stating it out here as fact because I acknowledge that there are still so many unknown factors that could possibly prove my deduction wrong. And as GM Draclord has pointed out, it isn't all that important to pinpoint who it is at the moment because it's not the game-changing information that decides who's wolf or town. It's something we need to find out for sure only when we're claiming roles. Which we aren't.
Really, the fact that you're jumping and painting suspicion on people for false and trivial reasons isn't helping your case.
