Finished Werewolf XXIII: A Sacrifice for Anti-Arceus [AND THE WINNERS ARE...]

[Squirtle Squad]

RE: Werewolf XXIII: A Sacrifice for Anti-Arceus [DAY 7: ends Monday 3rd]

Eron seems a little touchy...
Still I'd sleep better knowing the SoJ are scum free...

Supposing MTC isn't scum and we lynch him I'm probably gonna use my vote on Eron tomorrow. I've been suspicious of him since he revealed his ability and he should definitely be next!

 

[Machamp The Champion]

RE: Werewolf XXIII: A Sacrifice for Anti-Arceus [DAY 7: ends Monday 3rd]

Ugh. As reinforce said, I could have edited my flavour.

Looking at the role PMs of other wolves, they have 2 paragraphs for their flavor (except Dusknoir and maybe Smeargle). The top one is pretty ambiguous as to what alignment they are, but the bottom one shows their intent for joining the Anti-Arceus cult. My guess is the flavor you've shown would simply be the top paragraph of your flavor. I could easily see the bottom paragraph elaborating that you joined the Anti-Arceus cult to find your future husband, or something similar. But of course, his flavor could be the flavor of a townie.

And really, the flavour means NOTHING.

Of course the flavor means something. Why it wouldn't I have no idea.

 

[Machamp The Champion]

RE: Werewolf XXIII: A Sacrifice for Anti-Arceus [DAY 7: ends Monday 3rd]

One random thing I just remembered. One Approved was killed with a Janitor power (their role isn't revealed to the town), and none of the dead scum had a Janitor power, so it may be a good idea to think about what Pokemon might have a one. Out of the players we know the Pokemon name of (that aren't on Eron's list), we have Terrakion, Munna, Hariyama, Jynx, and Kirlia, and maybe a few others I'm forgetting. Of those, Munna seems the most likely honestly. Just putting this out there.

 

[rev3rsor]

RE: Werewolf XXIII: A Sacrifice for Anti-Arceus [DAY 7: ends Monday 3rd]

Hmm, yeah, that could be possible: it's a possible lead but by no means definitive.
This isn't really based on evidence but I get the feeling that both MTC and PMJ are probably town, and that Eron is scum. Nothing personal, just that it's what I think.

 

[bbninjas]

RE: Werewolf XXIII: A Sacrifice for Anti-Arceus [DAY 7: ends Monday 3rd]

Hmm, yeah, that could be possible: it's a possible lead but by no means definitive.
This isn't really based on evidence but I get the feeling that both MTC and PMJ are probably town, and that Eron is scum. Nothing personal, just that it's what I think.

Naturally I think MTC is town (his posts honestly seem helpful and 'when I flip town' stuff), PMJ the only lead I can see is what I believe is his more natural play style, although I think he is scummiest ATM, and there are some good points against Eron.

 

[PMJ]

RE: Werewolf XXIII: A Sacrifice for Anti-Arceus [DAY 7: ends Monday 3rd]

This isn't really based on evidence but I get the feeling that both MTC and PMJ are probably town, and that Eron is scum. Nothing personal, just that it's what I think.

After reading through some of MTC's posts I am somewhat of a mind to agree with you. That said, I am not one to admit I am wrong until I have definitive proof I am wrong (read as: lynch MTC, swords of justice? mo like swords of SCUMstice am I right).

Honestly, the only reason I am going for MTC so hard is because of Teal. That's it.

 

[rev3rsor]

RE: Werewolf XXIII: A Sacrifice for Anti-Arceus [DAY 7: ends Monday 3rd]

...for a moment I was confused because Teal was the GM, but I understand your point.
I get this feeling that Teal (or any GM) would say that as a general disclaimer though, but your point about the Swords of Justice normally being together could still be true. (I'm personally sticking to my own opinion, but only because it's my own opinion.)

 

[Wailord_2]

RE: Werewolf XXIII: A Sacrifice for Anti-Arceus [DAY 7: ends Monday 3rd]

I think right now that Eron is most suspicious based on the fact that his role uses paradise in it and once more wolves started getting lynched he started getting more active. Also, because he revealed his role after he asked everyone what pokemon they are. If he were scum he would know who is town and therefore only confirm people as town that have already told him what pokemon they are.
I'd also like to say that I don't think that the SoJ's roles say that not everyone else is necessarily town, means that there is for sure a scum in that group.

 

[Reinforce]

RE: Werewolf XXIII: A Sacrifice for Anti-Arceus [DAY 7: ends Monday 3rd]

I think right now that Eron is most suspicious based on the fact that his role uses paradise in it and once more wolves started getting lynched he started getting more active. Also, because he revealed his role after he asked everyone what pokemon they are. If he were scum he would know who is town and therefore only confirm people as town that have already told him what pokemon they are.
I'd also like to say that I don't think that the SoJ's roles say that not everyone else is necessarily town, means that there is for sure a scum in that group.

I think we are all in the same mind about those suspicions. However, Teal has stated in yesterday's update that there is only one wolf left, so it cannot be both Eron and MtC/bbninjas.

Anyway... Day's ending soon and it looks like we haven't made any solid decision yet.

So, I think we have three lynch candidates up: PMJ, Machamp the Champion, Eron. Because:

1) PMJ - His behavior and playstyle has given off vibes of desperation since a few days ago, with Celever and CrimsonFlame. And we know that only the wolf/wolves have cause to be desperate in the game's current situation. Furthermore, he's tunneled MtC pretty hard, with OMGUS thrown in.

2) Machamp the Champion - Suspected due to Drohn's role flavor text implications. He's retaliated at PMJ in the same manner, although he did go for Bigfoot first yesterday.

3) Eron - His role claim flavor text contains references to paradise and dreams, which has been a common theme in the flavor text of the wolves revealed so far. And while his ability is pretty useful, his results haven't been indicative of alignment.

There's been mention of lynching all three eventually, but of course we can only do one at a time, so it's a matter of who to go after first.

IMO, I think we should go for Eron first. I believe that the evidence against him is the most logical of the three, and it's based on role. And if he had made up or lied about the paradise part, then all the more reason we have to suspect him. It's too bad about his useful ability though, but I think with our advantage in numbers, there is no pressing need for the town semi-clearing it offers.

##VOTE: Eron

 

[GM DracLord]

RE: Werewolf XXIII: A Sacrifice for Anti-Arceus [DAY 7: ends Monday 3rd]

I think right now that Eron is most suspicious based on the fact that his role uses paradise in it and once more wolves started getting lynched he started getting more active. Also, because he revealed his role after he asked everyone what pokemon they are. If he were scum he would know who is town and therefore only confirm people as town that have already told him what pokemon they are.
I'd also like to say that I don't think that the SoJ's roles say that not everyone else is necessarily town, means that there is for sure a scum in that group.

I think we are all in the same mind about those suspicions. However, Teal has stated in yesterday's update that there is only one wolf left, so it cannot be both Eron and MtC/bbninjas.

Anyway... Day's ending soon and it looks like we haven't made any solid decision yet.

So, I think we have three lynch candidates up: PMJ, Machamp the Champion, Eron. Because:

1) PMJ - His behavior and playstyle has given off vibes of desperation since a few days ago, with Celever and CrimsonFlame. And we know that only the wolf/wolves have cause to be desperate in the game's current situation. Furthermore, he's tunneled MtC pretty hard, with OMGUS thrown in.

2) Machamp the Champion - Suspected due to Drohn's role flavor text implications. He's retaliated at PMJ in the same manner, although he did go for Bigfoot first yesterday.

3) Eron - His role claim flavor text contains references to paradise and dreams, which has been a common theme in the flavor text of the wolves revealed so far. And while his ability is pretty useful, his results haven't been indicative of alignment.

There's been mention of lynching all three eventually, but of course we can only do one at a time, so it's a matter of who to go after first.

IMO, I think we should go for Eron first. I believe that the evidence against him is the most logical of the three, and it's based on role. And if he had made up or lied about the paradise part, then all the more reason we have to suspect him. It's too bad about his useful ability though, but I think with our advantage in numbers, there is no pressing need for the town semi-clearing it offers.

##VOTE: Eron

I dont know.. I think if i were in erons shoe ... I would leave the paradise part out if i were a scum since it would obviously backfired.. I trust eron atm.

##Vote : PMJ

 

[bbninjas]

RE: Werewolf XXIII: A Sacrifice for Anti-Arceus [DAY 7: ends Monday 3rd]

I think right now that Eron is most suspicious based on the fact that his role uses paradise in it and once more wolves started getting lynched he started getting more active. Also, because he revealed his role after he asked everyone what pokemon they are. If he were scum he would know who is town and therefore only confirm people as town that have already told him what pokemon they are.
I'd also like to say that I don't think that the SoJ's roles say that not everyone else is necessarily town, means that there is for sure a scum in that group.

I think we are all in the same mind about those suspicions. However, Teal has stated in yesterday's update that there is only one wolf left, so it cannot be both Eron and MtC/bbninjas.

Anyway... Day's ending soon and it looks like we haven't made any solid decision yet.

So, I think we have three lynch candidates up: PMJ, Machamp the Champion, Eron. Because:

1) PMJ - His behavior and playstyle has given off vibes of desperation since a few days ago, with Celever and CrimsonFlame. And we know that only the wolf/wolves have cause to be desperate in the game's current situation. Furthermore, he's tunneled MtC pretty hard, with OMGUS thrown in.

2) Machamp the Champion - Suspected due to Drohn's role flavor text implications. He's retaliated at PMJ in the same manner, although he did go for Bigfoot first yesterday.

3) Eron - His role claim flavor text contains references to paradise and dreams, which has been a common theme in the flavor text of the wolves revealed so far. And while his ability is pretty useful, his results haven't been indicative of alignment.

There's been mention of lynching all three eventually, but of course we can only do one at a time, so it's a matter of who to go after first.

IMO, I think we should go for Eron first. I believe that the evidence against him is the most logical of the three, and it's based on role. And if he had made up or lied about the paradise part, then all the more reason we have to suspect him. It's too bad about his useful ability though, but I think with our advantage in numbers, there is no pressing need for the town semi-clearing it offers.

##VOTE: Eron

Not to mention that due to Eron deleting posts, he is now completely vanilla.
@Teal Vote Count Please

 

[Ice Espeon]

RE: Werewolf XXIII: A Sacrifice for Anti-Arceus [DAY 7: ends Monday 3rd]

##VOTE: Machamp the Champion

Because of the Swordsmen of Misjustice. If MTC is town then as others have said, Eron seems like a good option.

 

[bbninjas]

RE: Werewolf XXIII: A Sacrifice for Anti-Arceus [DAY 7: ends Monday 3rd]

##VOTE: Machamp the Champion

Because of the Swordsmen of Misjustice. If MTC is town then as others have said, Eron seems like a good option.

What about PMJ?

 

[PMJ]

RE: Werewolf XXIII: A Sacrifice for Anti-Arceus [DAY 7: ends Monday 3rd]

1) PMJ - His behavior and playstyle has given off vibes of desperation since a few days ago, with Celever and CrimsonFlame. And we know that only the wolf/wolves have cause to be desperate in the game's current situation. Furthermore, he's tunneled MtC pretty hard, with OMGUS thrown in.

I don't understand how I have been acting desperate, even with Celever. I posted my thoughts and cast a vote.

And I did not OMGUS MTC. I voted for him (post 1863) and he did not vote for me until the next day (in fairness, it was because the previous day ended before he could post).

MTC wants to lynch Bigfoot because MTC thinks he is being suspicious. MTC is also trying to give Bigfoot guidance on who to kill with his kiss of death.

However, MTC strongly suggested that he does not believe that Bigfoot could be scum with this kiss of death role. Therefore, he thinks Bigfoot is town.

MTC is trying to push the lynch of someone who he thinks is town. He argued that Bigfoot is lying, but that is not likely because Bigfoot openly admitted that his ability activates on getting lynched. This is a bad idea for scum to do, because then the town can just lynch him to prove his role. If he was scum, then great. If he was being honest, then he can kill a second, also suspicious, player.

This is what MTC was suggesting that Bigfoot do with Meaty. I originally said that MTC was fine with killing off Meaty because as the last scum, MTC would know that Meaty was town. However, I forgot to consider that MTC was bussing Meaty, a low-risk move since Meaty was on the verge of getting modkilled anyway.

In the event I am lynched, however, here is my list of suspects.

1. MTC. This should be a given.
2. Eron. Wailord brings up a good point but I can't help but feel that the word paradise is a red herring here. With Teal screwing with the Swords of Justice role PMs, it seems like something he'd do.
3. Squirtle Squad. alex hardly posted and wasn't subbed out until N5. That usually means they're acting behind the scenes, using scum actions to stay in.

Also:

@@Pressure: Squirtle Squad, Reinforce, Mr.Muffin
Are you Sableye? If not, state your role name for the class.

 

[Squirtle Squad]

RE: Werewolf XXIII: A Sacrifice for Anti-Arceus [DAY 7: ends Monday 3rd]

I'm sableye!! I wrote it ages back,

Yes!!! Finally im a suspect!!
Whilst it's a waste of a lynch for town, it's more beneficial for town that im dead,
So I'm ready! Bring it on! Haha

 

[AlexanderTheAwesome]

RE: Werewolf XXIII: A Sacrifice for Anti-Arceus [DAY 7: ends Monday 3rd]

I'm sableye!! I wrote it ages back,

Yes!!! Finally im a suspect!!
Whilst it's a waste of a lynch for town, it's more beneficial for town that im dead,
So I'm ready! Bring it on! Haha

We have better things to do than lynch you
Also why would you reveal that, scum could've killed you -_-

 

[Squirtle Squad]

RE: Werewolf XXIII: A Sacrifice for Anti-Arceus [DAY 7: ends Monday 3rd]

In the event I am lynched, however, here is my list of suspects.

1. MTC. This should be a given.
2. Eron. Wailord brings up a good point but I can't help but feel that the word paradise is a red herring here. With Teal screwing with the Swords of Justice role PMs, it seems like something he'd do.
3. Squirtle Squad. alex hardly posted and wasn't subbed out until N5. That usually means they're acting behind the scenes, using scum actions to stay in.

Also:

@@Pressure: Squirtle Squad, Reinforce, Mr.Muffin
Are you Sableye? If not, state your role name for the class.

Yes I am Sableye

 

[bbninjas]

RE: Werewolf XXIII: A Sacrifice for Anti-Arceus [DAY 7: ends Monday 3rd]

I think there is 3 on PMJ and 5 on MTC.

I seriously am starting to not think either the two are scum - they are both gambling that they are town:

-snip-
In the event I am lynched, however, here is my list of suspects.
-snip-

If PMJ is lynched, and is scum, the game is over...

And here are a few similar snipped quotes of MTC:

Tomorrow after I'm lynched (which I will be cause the town is full of stupids)...

WHAT???? WHY??? HOW HAVE YOU BEEN CONVINCED I AM SCUM???? THIS ENTIRE ARGUMENT IS ONE OF THE STUPIDEST I'VE EVER SEEN IN WW!!

*ahem* Sorry. Had to get that off my chest. In case I'm nightkilled (not happening because of PMJ :\), here's the post I would've made if I got to the thread yesterday:
-snip-

Anyway, of got the very strange feeling the Mr Muffin is scum. Just how he is acting throughout the game, if I had to choose someone ATM, besides MTC or PMJ, I would actually choose Mr Muffin. Gut feeling.

 

[PMJ]

RE: Werewolf XXIII: A Sacrifice for Anti-Arceus [DAY 7: ends Monday 3rd]

Squirtle Squad, full claim please. It's the late game and the majority of players left have already done so.

 

[PMJ]

RE: Werewolf XXIII: A Sacrifice for Anti-Arceus [DAY 7: ends Monday 3rd]

Teal, are the other two players still required to supply a response to my pressure, even though someone answered with yes? I mean, I guess technically it's possible Squirtle Squad is lying, but I just wanted to make sure so as not to have them think they don't and then wind up dead.