Finished Werewolf XXIV: The Wizarding War - The Order of the Phoenix is the Winner!

[Squirtle Squad]

RE: Werewolf XXIV: The Wizarding War - Day 2 ends December 24th, at 23:59 GMT

Okay, this is something else that's been bugging me for a while now. No one in this thread seems to know anything about Harry Potter. Am I the only one in this game who is even slightly knowledgeable on this subject?

Haha the number of people who don't know anything about it is killing me!

I've read the books and seen movies at least 3 times each (books and movies)

Wow can't believe I said something right im gonna go ahead and trust you doggers...
The only thing now bugging me is why you are so sure the Bb and celever are scum yet you vote KoN?? Why??

##unvote xdoggerx

 

[Wailord_2]

RE: Werewolf XXIV: The Wizarding War - Day 2 ends December 24th, at 23:59 GMT

While dogger's name claim is somewhat believable, I find it odd he only did so after Squirtle Squad said Hermione was a possible option. I'll believe him for now, but if someone counterclaims, I'd be slightly more inclined to believe them than dogger

 

[Jeremy1026]

RE: Werewolf XXIV: The Wizarding War - Day 2 ends December 24th, at 23:59 GMT

Dogger, you keep throwing other players under the bus without a you supporting evidence. And no, you having a "feeling" doesn't count. Why do you think Keeper is scum? Why do you think BB and Celever knew your role?

 

[Camoclone]

RE: Werewolf XXIV: The Wizarding War - Day 2 ends December 24th, at 23:59 GMT

##UNVOTE: XDOGGERX

It seems plausible and unless someone counters then I'll believe it. It also explains how you were acting (sort of not really). Imma read back more tomorrow.

 

[bbninjas]

RE: Werewolf XXIV: The Wizarding War - Day 2 ends December 24th, at 23:59 GMT

I think I may unvote just in case as I'll be inactive for 6 or so hours, at least:
##UNVOTE: XDOGGERX

 

[Teal]

RE: Werewolf XXIV: The Wizarding War - Day 2 ends December 24th, at 23:59 GMT

Wow seriously thank you Dogger. If you just name & flavourclaimed like I asked you to you would not have had to reveal your ability. That's exactly why I asked for a name & flavourclaim: this is the type of game, where those alone can confirm some roles (Harry, Ron, Hermione, Hagrid and Dumbledore at the very least + Minerva now since she has pretty much been confirmed to be in the game). If one of them was left out for safe-claims: just wow.

##UNVOTE: xDoggerx

 

[Reinforce]

RE: Werewolf XXIV: The Wizarding War - Day 2 ends December 24th, at 23:59 GMT

Yay for day-off at work

Haaa...

Looks like you're in the clear for now, Dogger. The only issue we have now is why you think we should go for Keeper of Night, bbninjas or Celever. Do you have a reason or evidence that we should go after them? If it's role-related or something like role results, that should be very solid evidence. Please don't tell me this is random accusation.

 

[Jeremy1026]

RE: Werewolf XXIV: The Wizarding War - Day 2 ends December 24th, at 23:59 GMT

Since we are pretty much consensus on not lynching dogger today, we have two options right now as I see it. We follow his suggestion for KoN, or we follow the prophets suggestion of MtC or Lenny? Honestly, neither seems like a great idea.

 

[Keeper of Night]

RE: Werewolf XXIV: The Wizarding War - Day 2 ends December 24th, at 23:59 GMT

Just got tie to read stuff over.

##UNVOTE: xDoggerx

Although I, like others, really could use an explanation as to why you think Celever, bbninjas, and myself are scum.

 

[bbninjas]

RE: Werewolf XXIV: The Wizarding War - Day 2 ends December 24th, at 23:59 GMT

I'd like to know what MtC has to say about everything (please tell me he aint at worlds...), and particularly who he thinks is a good lynch.
Lenny, who do you say is a good lynch?

 

[Keeper of Night]

RE: Werewolf XXIV: The Wizarding War - Day 2 ends December 24th, at 23:59 GMT

I'd like to know what MtC has to say about everything (please tell me he aint at worlds...), and particularly who he thinks is a good lynch.
Lenny, who do you say is a good lynch?

Worlds is long over.
I'm pretty sure Machamp's previous post was a case against me, which led to Dogger's case against me, which lead to the wagon against him for playing off of MtC's logic on two separate occasions.

 

[bbninjas]

RE: Werewolf XXIV: The Wizarding War - Day 2 ends December 24th, at 23:59 GMT

I'd like to know what MtC has to say about everything (please tell me he aint at worlds...), and particularly who he thinks is a good lynch.
Lenny, who do you say is a good lynch?

Worlds is long over.
I'm pretty sure Machamp's previous post was a case against me, which led to Dogger's case against me, which lead to the wagon against him for playing off of MtC's logic on two separate occasions.

Really? Can you find the post?

 

[Keeper of Night]

RE: Werewolf XXIV: The Wizarding War - Day 2 ends December 24th, at 23:59 GMT

Worlds is long over.
I'm pretty sure Machamp's previous post was a case against me, which led to Dogger's case against me, which lead to the wagon against him for playing off of MtC's logic on two separate occasions.

Really? Can you find the post?

http://www.pokebeach.com/forums/thread-active-werewolf-xxiv-the-wizarding-war-day-2-ends-december-24th-at-23-59-gmt?pid=2690283#pid2690283
Found it. Not a case against anybody, just indeciveness and a defense at Teal's point about him tunneling.
He suspects Celever and myself due to our argument over the flavor, myself more so.
He also suspects Teal, who suspects him. Not unlike Dogger wanting me lynched because I voted him.

 

[Machamp The Champion]

RE: Werewolf XXIV: The Wizarding War - Day 2 ends December 24th, at 23:59 GMT

I don't even know what was going on with Dogger. I wasn't sure if he was a power role trying to be subtle, or scum. I guess my question has been answered. He really needs to tell us why he suspects bb, Celever, and Keeper before we decide on who to lynch. (If he doesn't want to reveal why, he should really tell us that so we're not pointlessly bickering for the remainder of the day.) I'm willing to lynch who he wants us to today, and hopefully they'll turn up wolf/indie.

I've played an average of 121 games of this, excluding my first attempts.

121 games?! Assuming you're talking about Forum WW, I find that highly improbable. I feel like anyone who has played 121 WW games must play it professionally on Mafiascum or something.

While it hasn't been mentioned in a while, but it's still fresh in my mind because I read this entire day in one sitting, I really don't like grant's actions and if something drastically changes with the Dogger situation, he would be next in line to lynch in my opinion. First of all, on Day 1 he said he was convinced Lenny was scum and really kept with it throughout the day, then called it RVS the next one. This behavior bothers me and makes grant rather suspicious in my opinion.

I don't find that suspicious. As I've said this game, you have to commit to your pressure for it to actually be pressure, even if it's RVS pressure. He didn't admit it was simple RVS at first to convince Lenny it was RVS pressure. Now that RVS is over, he can admit that it was in fact RVS pressure.

I'd like to know what MtC has to say about everything (please tell me he aint at worlds...), and particularly who he thinks is a good lynch.
Lenny, who do you say is a good lynch?

No, I'm not at worlds... just Regionals. But in all seriousness, I think I've only been gone for a day. You don't need to flip out lol.

 

[rev3rsor]

RE: Werewolf XXIV: The Wizarding War - Day 2 ends December 24th, at 23:59 GMT

Caught up on the thread, so here's basically my thoughts:
I guess I'm decently knowledgeable about Harry Potter in general, having read the books and watched most of the movies. I know enough about the characters mentioned thus far to confirm (? not in-game confirm but common sense confirm) that they're significant enough to be in the game.
dogger's claim seems kinda believable? I guess if there's no counterclaim within today or tomorrow then he should be kinda clean. If he claimed an ability(ies), I must've missed it so could someone please update me on that? yeah, that's all from me for now.

 

[BigfootAUS]

RE: Werewolf XXIV: The Wizarding War - Day 2 ends December 24th, at 23:59 GMT

Until he actually explains his suspicions/leads, I'm keeping my vote on xDoggerx. He made a huge mess of a conversation (as Teal says, you could've just answered the questions directly but no, you toyed with information and wasted our time instead) and is yet to explain his suspicions on KoN, bb and Celever.

Unless I missed them in my skimming, we don't have any leads to really go on for today (unless xDoggerx actually explains stuff clearly!), so that makes all this really tedious. On the plus side, if xDoggerx gets lynched and flips town we'll have 3 suspicions to follow up on in D3 for a lead on non-town players plus my eavesdropping for a lead on the independents.

 

[TheGuy]

RE: Werewolf XXIV: The Wizarding War - Day 2 ends December 24th, at 23:59 GMT

I have never read or watched Harry Potter so if someone claims a character I actually know (Harry, Ron, Hermione, Dumbeldore) then it's probably in the game because I don't think I know any others.

The only thing saving Dogger right now is his claim because his logic hasn't been sound about anything. I'd certainly advise against voting for Keeper at all unless Dogger can provide some good reasons for why we should. I'm still worried about dogger though. He could have easily claimed Hermione, anticipating Hermione to be an important role and if he's going to be lynched anyways - he may as well reveal to his fellow scum members the identity of an important character. And from what I've seen there's no way dogger's played 100+ WW games.

##UNVOTE: Machamp the Champion

 

[xDoggerx]

RE: Werewolf XXIV: The Wizarding War - Day 2 ends December 24th, at 23:59 GMT

It seems like bbninjas an Celever achieved to mess up my idea and were able to make other people believe as they wanted.

I just didn't like the idea of revealing myself but, since I know they are aware of my identity (Hermione Granger) I can also say these two guys are wolves, otherwise they wouldn't be trying to confuse the idea.

Can you elaborate on this part of your post? I'm not sure I understand it correctly. You're saying that they knew who you were but... pretended they didn't? Or you have proof that they know your role name? I don't get it.

Also I'm inclined to believe Dogger's claim.

Ok, bbninjas and Celever were mostly the ones trying to get something out of me, but wait, everything started when I accused KoN, I saw the random joke about KoN being a wolf, and the way he wrote his posts seemed pretty suspicious to me. Anyway, as I turned on KoN, (assuming that he's a wolf), he asked for some help to his companions, bbninjas and celever so he wouldn't seem that suspicious. It's just a theory. And that's why I wanted KoN to be the next lynch, so I could be sure that he's either one of them or not, if I were right, my leads are correct, if not, well, there's the point where I can fix my mistake.

 

[Lenny]

RE: Werewolf XXIV: The Wizarding War - Day 2 ends December 24th, at 23:59 GMT

I too have been gone for the whole day so I'm sorry if I'm missing something.

dogger claimed to have some pretty decent role? Then claimed Hermione? He took us through a wild ride getting to that claim, so I don't know what to believe.

Of course, grantm1999's sudden disappearance after his pressure on me faded is something to note. Especially because he kept tunneling me saying how I stopped posting after pressure subsided, same argument could be made against him now. Maybe his wolf buddies told him to quiet down because he was drawing a target on himself? Or he could be genuinely busy. Still, something to consider.

To bbninjas, I don't know who we should lynch at this point. dogger could be playing us completely, but he might actually be Hermione. Is it worth the risk? I'm not sure, although my gut tells me he's telling the truth. Not sure of anything right now. We had better intel Day 1 than we do now.

To sum it all up, I have no idea what we should do lol.

 

[Keeper of Night]

RE: Werewolf XXIV: The Wizarding War - Day 2 ends December 24th, at 23:59 GMT

Can you elaborate on this part of your post? I'm not sure I understand it correctly. You're saying that they knew who you were but... pretended they didn't? Or you have proof that they know your role name? I don't get it.

Also I'm inclined to believe Dogger's claim.

Ok, bbninjas and Celever were mostly the ones trying to get something out of me, but wait, everything started when I accused KoN, I saw the random joke about KoN being a wolf, and the way he wrote his posts seemed pretty suspicious to me. Anyway, as I turned on KoN, (assuming that he's a wolf), he asked for some help to his companions, bbninjas and celever so he wouldn't seem that suspicious. It's just a theory. And that's why I wanted KoN to be the next lynch, so I could be sure that he's either one of them or not, if I were right, my leads are correct, if not, well, there's the point where I can fix my mistake.

...So yeah, you just have a theory. It doesn't make any sense btw, if you read the start of the day.
Are you actually useful to us in any way? Because your posts so far have just filling the day with confusion, as Bigfoot has already pointed out.