Finished Werewolf XXVII: Revelation

Status
Not open for further replies.
Woah. I was just reading up on what I missed. It seems like BB is a bad bandwagon which is not worth pursuing for at least are first lynch. Maybe for D1 p.2 we could work on him. I think because today is showing no leads we should start to think about who could be mafia, and who we don't want to continue the game. Do we think JoshB, or Yeowie is really going to help us down the line. Even though they have shown this game to be a little off they are still to active players who may give us a reason to lynch them?

I think Celever has an interesting idea. If someone isn't going to help us why keep them? We don't have any kind of lead, so we kind of don't have many options.
 
Im definitely leaning more towards an inactive lynch for this first lynch. All those who are up as suspects are all actives. The more they talk the more chance they have of slipping up if they are scum.
This is Day 1. Lets kill an inactive (probably gonna get modkilled anyway down the line). Then for our second lynch we will have more information to work with.

In terms of who we kill, yeah Cinesra would be alright, Id be more leaning towards Cookies cos he hasn't said a word and is also new...


Thoughts?
 
Holy Cupcakes, that's a lot of posts since I left this morning, just caught up because more keep coming in xD, are all werewolf games like this?

I feel like Celever's onto something here. I'm no expert, but if he's not doing anything useful, then why keep him around?
 
I think we should look, and see who is uncharacteristically inactive. This is also early D1, so people probably have even known about the game starting.
 
Don't get me wrong I think BB is scum. Celever you aren't going to make any progress with that. Get on JoshB's wagon and lets make some progress.
 
Killing an inactive doesn't make sense at all right now. We get literally no information from it. I don't like that. #2 on Celever's list.
 
well fine then, lets just do it! Just the longer we sit and argue the more time we waste....


Even though I know we've got ages for the timer to die, its still somewhat pressuring :p
 
If you scum read him we should lynch him. Otherwise we should go for an active lurker as opposed to Josh who might end up being useful in the future, or who might scum slip if he's mafia and make an easy lynch for us.
Mr.Muffin said:
I think we should look, and see who is uncharacteristically inactive. This is also early D1, so people probably have even known about the game starting.
Click to expand...
I think it's too early for that since the point of lynching an active lurker is progressing quickly. We should just focus on low risk lynches right now, and Cinesra sort of stands out to me.
Squirtle Squad said:
Im definitely leaning more towards an inactive lynch for this first lynch. All those who are up as suspects are all actives. The more they talk the more chance they have of slipping up if they are scum.
This is Day 1. Lets kill an inactive (probably gonna get modkilled anyway down the line). Then for our second lynch we will have more information to work with.

In terms of who we kill, yeah Cinesra would be alright, Id be more leaning towards Cookies cos he hasn't said a word and is also new...


Thoughts?
Click to expand...
I don't think Cookie is a great idea, because in the future he'll get subbed out, and then we might get a pretty good town contributor in Keeper of Night.We've got subs to use so it won't be modkill immediately.
Camoclone said:
Killing an inactive doesn't make sense at all right now. We get literally no information from it. I don't like that. #2 on Celever's list.
Click to expand...
Why did you not share your thoughts on this generally well-recepted idea at all? That's pretty weird.
 
Celever said:
Otherwise we should go for an active lurker as opposed to Josh who might end up being useful in the future, or who might scum slip if he's mafia and make an easy lynch for us.
Click to expand...
might
He has been scummy enough to warrant getting turbo lynched right now. It makes sense and will give us a ton of info.
 
Camo knows Bb is scum because they are both scum partners... Didn't you forget!?

Ok so what benefit is leaving Bb around if he is in fact scum??? Try and clue us in without giving away your secrets.
 
Squirtle Squad said:
Ok so what benefit is leaving Bb around if he is in fact scum??? Try and clue us in without giving away your secrets.
Click to expand...
It has nothing to do with him. That's all I will say.

btw town lurks just as much as scum (and sometimes has more reasons to lurk).
 
All aboard the Josh wagon! This band is leaving the station...

**You'd better be right!!**

After Camo's successful reads last game during D1, I reckon just do it...

Accept Jeremy! If he's wrong we still have a second lynch to complete, and killing Josh will give us information
 
Lynching an active idea is a much better idea and Camo knows it. Notice how he avoided sharing thoughts in it and now has left the thread? We get a p good lead on Camp now if Cinesra flips scum; he just subtly defended him. Cinesra is a good idea, because Josh is going to be an obvious mafia in the future if he is. He's not worth a lynch at this point at all.

Clearly Camo's role is connected to bb's, and I think I know how, but I won't say. We should stick on Cinesra today for now.
 
Ohhhhhhhhhhhh it all makes sense now!!!! Pretty sure I know stuff now :p Thanks Celever....

Why can't we just lynch Josh, and then based on how successful or unsuccesful the lynch is we can hit someone like Cinesra?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top