Finished Werewolf XXVII: Revelation

Status
Not open for further replies.
We're about 60 hours into this day and we're making no ground. We've still got two lynches to do today. Unless someone can provide a good reason for us NOT to lynch Cinesra first and someone else later I want to see the votes.
 
What do I think of a Cinesra lynch? There's nothing to think of; it's a typical inactive lynch. Funny that you should choose Cinesra out of like seven inactives... why not Cookie, who is too new, improbable to be an asset unless his role is remarkably strong and he can use it well (and it's the same chance for everyone to have such a role), and judging by past cases like that, will probably barely show up, if at all? Why not Vom? Why not Luispipe, who has only appeared to vote or unvote?
 
Woah, 60 hrs? I didn't realise it was that long. ##vote: Cinesra until further notice
 
Lynch me??? Haha I knew you'd suggest it :p

"I am Town"
- Wait wrong WW game....

No but seriously, the only thing I want is information, whoever dies I'm not particularly fussed. I can see dodgy stuff in all the suspects.
Right now I'm set on either Yeowie, bb, or Cinesra.

It doesn't particularly matter who dies in what order, just not bb first..
so out of Yeowie or Cinesra thats who I'm down for..

Depending on how that lynch goes will depend on whether or not I go for bb for the second lynch.
 
Chaos Jackal said:
What do I think of a Cinesra lynch? There's nothing to think of; it's a typical inactive lynch. Funny that you should choose Cinesra out of like seven inactives... why not Cookie, who is too new, improbable to be an asset unless his role is remarkably strong and he can use it well (and it's the same chance for everyone to have such a role), and judging by past cases like that, will probably barely show up, if at all? Why not Vom? Why not Luispipe, who has only appeared to vote or unvote?
Click to expand...
I'd just like to point out that I pointed out Cinesra before, so that was probably an unconscious thing that made the choice. Also, Vom's away for a week or so as a lot of us know from Convicted, so that would be one reason I haven't voted for him.
 
Squirtle Squad said:
Depending on how that lynch goes will depend on whether or not I go for bb for the second lynch.
Click to expand...
How exactly will a lynch on Yeowie or Cinesra help you decide whether or not to lynch me? Try Celever or Camo, but those too have no relation to me (except for perhaps Cinesra, and if he flips scum, I may be somewhat cleared for suggesting to go for him first).
 
Chaos Jackal said:
What do I think of a Cinesra lynch? There's nothing to think of; it's a typical inactive lynch. Funny that you should choose Cinesra out of like seven inactives... why not Cookie, who is too new, improbable to be an asset unless his role is remarkably strong and he can use it well (and it's the same chance for everyone to have such a role), and judging by past cases like that, will probably barely show up, if at all? Why not Vom? Why not Luispipe, who has only appeared to vote or unvote?
Click to expand...
I already said why not Cookie. Cookie is actually inactive and will be subbed, so we might get a good contributor out of that. Vom I semi-assumed was active because he's always active, but I guess he's not shown up yet. OH I actually just realised that Vom's away for the week, more like 3 or 4 days now, I remember bb saying so in Convicted. Luis has also made a few decent posts, I don't think he's been particularly useless thus far.

Cinesra is a known active lurker and isn't useful for the town, but can survive for a long time as mafia because people only lynch him when other options have run out. I don't see how all of those users are the same, really.

bbninjas said:
I'd just like to point out that I pointed out Cinesra before, so that was probably an unconscious thing that made the choice. Also, Vom's away for a week or so as a lot of us know from Convicted, so that would be one reason I haven't voted for him.
Click to expand...
I don't recall you mentioning Cinesra, but maybe it was retained in the back of my mind in some way. If Cinesra flips town I'm blaming you! :U
 
bbninjas said:
How exactly will a lynch on Yeowie or Cinesra help you decide whether or not to lynch me? Try Celever or Camo, but those too have no relation to me (except for perhaps Cinesra, and if he flips scum, I may be somewhat cleared for suggesting to go for him first).
Click to expand...

Well that wouldn't clear you... you could easily be bussing an inactive scum member.
 
bbninjas said:
How exactly will a lynch on Yeowie or Cinesra help you decide whether or not to lynch me? Try Celever or Camo, but those too have no relation to me (except for perhaps Cinesra, and if he flips scum, I may be somewhat cleared for suggesting to go for him first).
Click to expand...
Actually I'm pretty sure that Camo has targeted you with a desperate lover role, which means that if you die he goes with you and vice ver sa. Oftentimes targets are told that they've been targeted, but not always. So there's a connection there at least.

And Yeowie's your brother... generally mafia is a family business. Something to think about :p
 
Celever said:
Actually I'm pretty sure that Camo has targeted you with a desperate lover role, which means that if you die he goes with you and vice ver sa. Oftentimes targets are told that they've been targeted, but not always. So there's a connection there at least.

And Yeowie's your brother... generally mafia is a family business. Something to think about :p
Click to expand...
I don't know why Camo what target me with a lover role, considering I somehow manage to die fairly early as well, basically doubling the chances of both of us active people dying... doesn't look good from a town perspective. Aaaaaand I don't think Camo desperately wanted to mason me enough to increase the chances of him dying.

and :rollseyes:

Squirtle Squad said:
Well that wouldn't clear you... you could easily be bussing an inactive scum member.
Click to expand...
Eh, fair enough. But then that doesn't answer my point: How does lynching either Yeowie or Cinesra help you decide if to or if not to lynch me?
 
I didn't know about Vom, and what you say about Cookie makes sense I guess. I don't recall Luispipe to have made any meaningful post, I think all of them were 5 words+vote/unvote...

In any case, I'm not in for a Cinesra lynch. I don't even get how we ended up in Cinesra when initially it was about who to lynch first between Josh and bb.

Anyway, I'll be going now. I'm going to the seaside for a week, and my activity will be less. I'll still try to check as often as I can. My vote stays as it is.
 
Not directly. I don't really want to lynch you D1 straight up as you are active and actually contribute. so id much prefer to lynch someone else and see what happens. Then make the decision based on what happens.

##unvote Cinesra
we've got leads now so theres no real point killing an inactive. Lets lynch a suspect!

Yeowie or Bb? Which one though :p

##vote Yeowie
for reasons i posted earlier and because id rather not lynch bb straight up.

CJ said it. theres no need to lynch Cinesra right now.
 
I town read Yeowie and he has his wits about him and wants to contribute. Josh is also a major town read. bb is a scum read but an extremely high risk lynch.

There are no better targets today than Cinesra, and this is exactly the mentality which means he is a good lynch. We've got two lynches to use, let's use one to get rid of the active lurker and then afterwards treat this like a new day but with some real information. Is that really such an awful idea?
 
Ive been literally sitting with my computer at uni all day and not once have I seen Cinesra lurking though...

In terms of lurking... Josh has been lurking big time, so has muffin, and grovylekid. make of that what you will
 
Squirtle Squad said:
Ive been literally sitting with my computer at uni all day and not once have I seen Cinesra lurking though...

In terms of lurking... Josh has been lurking big time, so has muffin, and grovylekid. make of that what you will
Click to expand...
grovylekid and Josh are new though. Lurking is one of muffin's scumtells and generally he's more active as town, but he's never active on Day 1 either way so he's not so big a target.
 
however josh has been pretty vocal of his views, and has been weirdly quiet now that the commotion died down.

He may be new but he still seems to know what he's doing
 
Okay, I've decided that I want to lynch Yeowie for information on Celever. I'm finding Celever is slipping across my scum radar to town radar and back again, and I'm starting to find some small contradictions dwelling in his posts. I'm mainly looking at that lover theory; I'm find something odd in it, but can't put a finger on it just yet.

##unvote: Cinesra, ##vote: Yeowie
 
Hey I actually agree with you Bb!! Although I'm also of the lover theory opinion :p haha!

But yes, I think a Yeowie lynch is most beneficial
 
How is lynching the player with one of the highest interests in the game Day 1 beneficial? It was for the same reason I slightly doubted my lynch vote in you, bb, but you're still a strong scum read for me. Yeowie is very much a town read.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top